What immediately comes to the minds of scholars, tourists and even Guatemalans about Livingston, Guatemala, is that it is a Garifuna town, whose mixed African- and Carib-descended residents are more connected to Caribbean island countries and urban cities in the United States than to their own country. Guatemalans and foreigners commonly conceive of it as distinctly non-Guatemalan. The fact that it cannot even be reached by road strengthens these beliefs. This is the setting for Hilary Kahn's book.
In contrast to Livingston, the rest of Guatemala has come to be associated primarily with Maya culture, be it in the past or in the present, when in fact there is great cultural diversity throughout this country in multiple, well-known places like Antigua, Panajachel and Quetzaltenango. But rather than noting this diversity, class, ethnic and linguistic heterogeneity tend to be flattened in the popular and most scholarly writing on Guatemala to the extent that particular places take on very specific cultural associations in which this diversity, if not erased, is minimised.
In this ethnography, Kahn contrasts the dominant discourses that describe Livingston as a Garifuna homeland with its uniquely uniform, un-Guatemalan culture, and makes obvious the cultural diversity of the place in which Garifunas comprise one of the smaller ethnic groups living there. In fact, both indigenous people and ladinos constitute far greater numbers, each of them more than five times the number of Garifunas. Among the different indigenous people living in Livingston, Q'eqchi' Mayas comprise the greatest numbers. What is fascinating about the popular imaginary of Livingston is that neither ladinos nor Q'eqchi' Mayas come to mind. In fact, as Kahn explains in the opening of her book, Q'eqchi' Mayas appear to pass unnoticed or are perceived as unchanging, traditional beings, who, because of their seeming fixity, are not noticed. Intrigued by the ways in which other residents and visitors regard and even fail to notice these Mayas, Kahn studies how Q'eqchi' Mayas conceive that they ‘are part of an enduring, yet ever-changing network of relations’ (p. 2). Kahn explains how identity and morality for Q'eqchi' Mayas are constructed through social relations and action, an ethnographically based assessment that is maintained as she presents nuanced discussions of Q'eqchi' Maya history, consumptive patterns, cosmological ideologies, and, especially, the various ways in which Q'eqchi' Mayas express their culture and identity during festivities. Although Kahn discusses Q'eqchi' Mayas as her primary subjects, the rich cultural diversity of Livingston and the broader connections that people of this place have to Guatemala and beyond do not drop from discussion.
To a large degree, Kahn's theoretical and methodological approaches are dependent on her use of the camera. She employs what she describes as ‘ethnographic vérité’, a process, like cinema vérité, that she uses to de-centre her gaze and invite the multiple gazes of her subjects to contribute to the ethnographic construction. For her, this means the ethnographer and her subjects mutually construct an ethnographic record, a collaborative image of themselves and the ethnographer. In order to do this, she and her Q'eqchi' Maya collaborators use a video camera to record events in their lives, but, even more so, the camera becomes a ‘protagonist, as a catalyst for action’ (p. 183). In fact, the book is less an analysis of images, though it would have been useful and interesting for the reader to see some of the images captured by her video project collaborators, than a discussion of how the camera itself, its use by Kahn and community members, and their various perceptions of what it and the images themselves mean. The very materiality of the camera, the practice of filming, and the images produced acted to draw out Q'eqchi' Maya concepts of social relations, morality and self-conception. This is most clearly illustrated in the three personal vignettes in the book's chapter, ‘I Am a Camera, Vignettes of Ethnographic Vérité’. She argues that, like Q'eqchi' themselves, she was ‘an ethnographer in motion’ and that this ‘dissolves the distinctions between object and subject, self and other, and insider and outsider’ (p. 185). Ultimately, she aimed to place her own objectifying ethnographic gaze within the multiple gazes of Q'eqchi' Mayas. Her view, her visual notes are just a part of a complex of other views and visual notes.
It is important to recognise that Kahn's theoretical grounding from the perspective of ethnographic vérité does contribute to an innovative analysis of her data that is quite distinctive from other ethnographies about Mayas. Furthermore, because the camera was intrusive, did objectify, and, though not really grappled with by Kahn, was an expensive material item that marks her as different from Q'eqchi’, the camera itself was never neutral. The presence of the camera seems to test all the others, Kahn, the Q'eqchi’, and the other residents of Livingston. The camera draws out what is moral behaviour, how one practises one's identity and conceives of oneself as a member of a community.
The camera clearly served to tease out various Q'eqchi' perspectives and certainly forced Kahn to consider how she was integrated into Q'eqchi' imaginaries, all of which helped Kahn learn about Q'eqchi' concepts of identity and morality. In the end, however, the ethnographic product, this book, is still her interpretation of these multiple perspectives. It is, simply, her story about this community. Some readers may be put off by Kahn's discussion of her own subject position, as in motion and as an insider-outsider, since this perspective has effectively been trodden by other anthropologists and directs attention towards Kahn herself and away from Q'eqchi' Mayas. Certainly, ethnographic research is an inter-subjective relationship and cameras are an extension of that, not just an objective tool. While her discussion about her own shifting subject position and that of the camera in relation to the Livingston community of Q'eqchi' Mayas in theory may ‘contribute to the dismantling of centred knowledge and sight from a dominant perspective’, this is not demonstrated in the ethnography produced. It is, for the most part, a conventional ethnographic work. The overview of Q'eqchi' history, the discussions of traditional dances and the Día de Guadalupe holiday, and analysis of crime will be of interest to those scholars whose research does not focus on identity. These are the chapters that help anchor her arguments about Q'eqchi' identity and morality within broader historical and social contexts.
