In 1796 the state of Massachusetts convicted an elderly man of bestiality. Three years later, neighboring Connecticut did the same. The men who were convicted, John Farrell and Gideon Washburn, were both sentenced to hang. It had been 120 years since anyone had been executed for bestiality in either Connecticut or Massachusetts. Ultimately, neither man was executed. Farrell was eventually pardoned after a petitioning campaign and Washburn died in jail.
In their fascinating examination of the two cases, Doron S. Ben-Atar and Richard D. Brown focus on New England's “usually disciplined and rational” white ruling class and its concerns, ones that would ultimately lead to such unusual convictions (9). Ben-Atar and Brown tightly focus the book on one question: “our task as historians is to explain why officials in the New England interior chose to prosecute John Farrell and Gideon Washburn for the hanging crime of bestiality in the late 1790s” (4).
The men convicted did not tightly fit similar profiles. One was an outsider of sorts while the other had long-standing family roots in the community. One was married and one was not. One was an Irish immigrant. But they did share some similarities. They both lived in small towns. And they both were tried in courts that were sites for the struggles between and among powerful local elites.
To explain why their communities convicted elderly men of the “gendered” crime of bestiality, Ben-Atar and Brown situate the cases within the context of the sexual revolution of the late eighteenth century, as well as the political, religious, and cultural turbulence occurring in the US and Europe, all viewed through the lens of economic changes and hardships in New England. Chapters detail communal concerns as well as the long history of European cultural references to, and understandings of, sodomy and bestiality.
The framework is decidedly European. The book does not extensively explore same-sex sexuality or bestiality in the North American context of New France, New Spain, indigenous cultures, or other colonies and states, but instead focusses on the long history and rich scholarship of European histories of sexuality. One of the men, Gideon Washburn, the reader is told, “developed connections with nearby Indians” and “did not readily find a comfortable place among his Yankee neighbors,” suggesting that local cultural preoccupations may also be effectively plumbed to understand cultures in late eighteenth-century New England (52). Ultimately, the book argues that the changes in Paris and London (as well as in urban centers in the US) caused locals to fret about the decline of Christian sexual morality as “leaders in the hinterlands came to see themselves as the final guardians of morality” (87).
In seeking to determine why these communities took the extraordinary steps of convicting elderly men of bestiality, the book refers to the cases as a “Puritan flashback” (136, 143, 150). The authors view the convictions as “isolated reminders of Puritan severity” (150). But one does wonder if such cases can most productively be viewed as “anachronistic” and what is lost by not seeing them as indeed part of their own time and place – perhaps not as a “the return of the old order” but instead as something new (150).
Mark Kann's recent book Taming Passion for the Public Good: Policing Sex in the Early Republic finds that “American leaders were able to conserve, legitimize, and perpetuate patriarchal authority over the sex lives of the first few generations of Americans to reside in a newly emergent liberal society.” Kann argues that “upper-status, elite men in cities and villages across America perceived a significant post-Revolution need to regulate and tame people's passions.” For Kann, the trends toward loosening sexual policing in the years leading up to the Revolution reversed course as many saw “policing people's passion and sex lives fundamental to the establishment and survival of virtuous republics.”Footnote 1 As Clare Lyons and others have argued, this thrust would continue and grow after the Revolution and through the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
The explanation offered in Taming Lust, that the convictions should be viewed as “anachronistic” given that the “cultural outlook of the early republic was so profoundly different from the Puritan era” (146), then, is a different perspective than the one that is offered by Kann's Taming Passion and others who see alternative readings of the type of evidence presented here. Were these bestiality cases a leftover from a bygone era or a sign of things to come? Taming Lust provides a well-written look at the European cultural reference points of late eighteenth-century New England elites and will no doubt provoke future discussion and debate regarding the history of sexuality in the early republic.
