The history of the Workers’ Theatre Movement in the United States is a point where many ongoing labor and theatre stories converge. As worker-students and their faculty in labor colleges in the 1920s and 1930s performed, wrote, improvised, devised, and seemingly willed into being numerous plays, pageants, skits, and sketches, they wrestled with questions of intent, content, and intended audience. Should the plays serve as entertainment and pedagogical tools to give presence and confidence to the (mostly) young worker-students? Should the plays strictly be about the ongoing labor crises made all the more urgent by the Great Depression? Further, should the subject matter of the plays be entirely local and in the present? Should the labor college performers and directors themselves be the creators of the work? Rehearsing Revolutions: The Labor Drama Experiment and Radical Activism in the Early Twentieth Century, Mary McAvoy's vital and fiercely intelligent examination of several labor college theatre programs and their leaders in the period, affirms the importance of examining and studying the unpolished, amateur, and, in McAvoy's words, “at best, artistically mediocre” scripts and performances of these worker-students (27). Their work not only proved to be a guiding force for the future of labor relations in this country, but also looked ahead to current forms of theatre making such as applied and devised theatre, both of which the Workers’ Theatre undoubtedly was.
McAvoy's study, which features six chapters and a conclusion, examines five labor college theatre programs: Portland Labor College in Portland, Oregon; Brookwood Labor College in Katonah, New York; the Southern Summer School for Women Workers in Industry (transient, but primarily in the western region of North Carolina); Highlander Folk School in Monteagle, Tennessee; and Commonwealth Labor College in Mena, Arkansas. McAvoy's opening chapter, “The Labor Drama Experiment,” introduces the reader to an excerpt of a student-written labor play first performed at Brookwood in February 1926, and then lays out her strategy of presenting case studies within the context of developing labor drama in the period between the world wars. She then devotes a chapter to each of the theatre programs and their leaders, with a concluding chapter examining, as its title indicates, “Labor Drama's Legacies.”
Although many familiar organizations and historical figures make appearances in the book, including Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt, the AFO, the CIO, and the indefatigable Wobblies of the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), one of the most striking aspects of these labor college theatre stories is the presence of strong women leaders. McAvoy sketches their respective stories and backgrounds effectively, revealing their many differences in theatrical experience and background. Doris Smith, of Portland Labor College, for example, had considerable theatre experience but “little connection to the organized labor movement and no experience with worker organizing” (40). Hazel MacKaye, daughter of noted theatre maker Steele MacKaye, introduced daring experimentation and challenged what labor theatre should look like in ways that outlasted her brief tenure at Brookwood Labor College. Zilphia Horton's work at Highlander Folk School served as a foundation for a lifetime of activist work that entered the era of the civil rights movement and highly influenced the most prominent male director examined in the book, Lee Hays, who would become better known as a member of the groundbreaking folk music group The Weavers. The diverse artistic voices brought different levels of emphasis and experience to their work, while sharing a zeal for and appreciation of amateur theatre to reach, build, and in many cases, enlighten and inspire audiences.
The questions raised, and the decisions made, by the labor dramatic directors at the time, McAvoy points out, still resonate today, because the challenges of pedagogical theatre, and theatre pedagogy, remain with student actors and those who teach them. Notably, the leaders and directors of these labor theatre programs were often younger (and without much more experience) than the students themselves. Some of the liveliest sections of Rehearsing Revolutions highlight the artistic processes that championed the voices and experiences of the worker-students, processes that resulted in the creation of a considerable amount of original work. These works were often quite short: McAvoy frequently notes the typical length as ranging from five to nine pages. The plays also tended to be somewhat repetitive in story line (frustrated workers unite to drive away a vicious boss) and, as noted earlier, were something less than great as dramatic literature. Nevertheless, the process of gathering enthusiastic amateurs who combined their voices and ideas to put on a show that spoke of their problems and lives to receptive audiences remains a strong force in today's theatre. We witness the fruits of these amateur gatherings in ensemble theatre making of the present and the future. McAvoy successfully “position[s] labor drama as a space for vital and productive experimentation that provided opportunities to nurture new ideas, take risks, and ultimately wrestle with the challenges of being politically engaged artists and citizens” (205).
As McAvoy clearly sets forth in this valuable study, many artists are still rehearsing the revolutions, and these rehearsals enrich the worlds of education, activism, and art.
