No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
It used to be that the century preceding the 1830 invasion of Algiers represented a siècle obscur. The historical obscurity stems in part from the nature of Ottoman rule in this particular province of the empire. However, the most compelling explanation lies in the immense devastation wrought during the first decades of France's occupation and the wanton destruction of much of the written record documenting Algeria's pre-colonial history. Compared with other countries of the Maghrib—or, indeed, to eastern Ottoman lands—Algeria suffered a systematic erasure of its historical memory at the hands of invaders and settlers to a degree experienced only by Palestinian society.
Tal Shuval's work is part of a collective scholarly endeavor that seeks to recuperate the lost history of Algeria's urban past. Research produced in the past decade or so has deepened our knowledge of pre-colonial Algerian cities and their populations—for example, M. Amine's 1991 doctoral dissertation devoted to commerce and merchants in Algiers in the late Ottoman period; Miriam Hoexter's Endowments, Rulers and Community: Waqf al-Haramayn in Ottoman Algiers (1998); and Isabelle Grangaud's 1998 doctoral dissertation, “La ville imprenable. Histoire sociale de Constantine au XVIIIè siècle.” Shuval's study of Algiers, a revised version of his doctoral dissertation, is divided into two major sections. The first analyzes in depth the various segments of the city's population, divided into rulers and ruled, and also tackles the complicated question of population densities in Algiers over time. The second part deals with city structures, the urban core, residential zones, and the distribution of the urban populace in space. While the author provides an excellent overview of the city's history from the period prior to the Ottoman takeover, he concentrates on the eight decades between 1711 and 1791. This era, marked by stable government and prosperity, brought the city and its inhabitants into its second Ottoman “apogee” under Mehmed Pasha ibn Osman, who held the office of dey for a quarter of a century. His death in 1791 represented the terminus ad quem of this golden age.
The kinds of questions that the historian can raise—and, more important, answer—about this era are, needless to say, determined by kinds and quantity of documentation available. Despite the loss of considerable historical material, the author made very fine use of microfilmed documents in Turkish and Arabic, often extremely recondite in nature, housed at the Centre dees archives d'outre-mer in Aix-en-Provence. Several categories of documents, each serving to illuminate one of the two major dimensions of this study—population and the social uses of city space and built environment—were used. For reconstructing the capital's population, the records of the bayt al-māl, particularly the mukhallafāt, provided a veritable “mine d'information” for certain social groups—above all, the military institution and its various constituent parts. Shuval's findings regarding the composition of the military by the close of the 18th century are intriguing. On the one hand, the odjak had come to include indigenous Algerians due to the inability to draft sufficient new recruits from Anatolia or the Balkans; on the other hand, despite the admission of locals into the militia, ethnic-based distinctions between the civilian population and the askeri appeared to have been maintained. This contrasts significantly with the situation in the neighboring beylik of Tunis, where similar lines of distinction had not only blurred but had virtually disappeared by this period. Waqf records reveal much about city quarters, economic activities, residential patterns, and so on, and also supplement the lacunae found in the bayt al-māl documents, particularly for information on the Andalusian segment of the population, the sons of the odjak, and women. Notably absent from the narrative are two important communities—the Jews and the Mzabites—a regrettable omission caused by the absence of available sources.
Shuval's meticulous research makes a number of scholarly contributions. First, he takes on the contentious issue of the size of the city's population, employing a comparative historical methodology throughout to make compelling arguments regarding over-estimates of urban densities. Second, at a larger level of analysis, this methodology is deployed quite effectively to highlight similarities as well as differences between Algiers and other Ottoman or Mediterranean cities. He also reminds us that—unlike most other Arab Ottoman cities—Ottoman rule transformed Algiers in a much more profound manner than was true of other such urban areas, such as Cairo or Damascus. As was true of Carthage to the east, Algiers was founded by the Phoenicians, one of a string of port-city colonies along the North African coast, but it remained a small, relatively unimportant Berber town until the 16th century. As Andrew Hess observed several decades ago, and as Shuval demonstrates in this study, the incorporation of Algiers into the Ottoman Empire was historically as significant as the 7th-century Arab Muslim conquests of North Africa. Finally, Shuval was clearly concerned with recuperating the history of the city's women residents to the extent permitted by the sources. For example, he devotes a section to “La milice et les femmes” in which he refutes much of what Pierre Boyer had to say about restrictions on marriage for the political-military class.
Taken together, the work of Shuval, Hoexter, and Grangaud, as well as other research in progress, has resulted in a significant paradigm shift in terms of our understanding of Ottoman Algerian history. The only quarrel this reviewer has with Shaval's very competent work is the fact that there is no index, an omission that may perhaps be attributed to the publisher rather than the author. This is all the more curious since the volume includes a good glossary as well as three excellent appendixes devoted to the distribution of city markets, caravanserails, and public baths.