Boğaç Ergene's book revolves around Ottoman judicial practice. Even though several studies about the functioning of kadı justice in the Ottoman Empire have appeared in the last thirty-five years and one may feel that the theme is all but exhausted, this book is important in that the author neatly arranges and discusses a number of issues related to judicial processes in the kadı courts of two northern Anatolian towns, which were not among the major ones, and may thus be considered representative of the majority of Ottoman urban centers. Ergene's book has several merits, the most important of which is that he tests his findings against two ethnographic models in an attempt to provide a theoretical framework to his study, in order to overcome the (sometimes simplistic) impressionism and empiricism by which a study based on sicils can be characterized. The author's argument is patiently built up. It is chapter 10 and the epilogue that eventually give the book its very special quality, while also exhibiting Ergene's profound consciousness of the virtues and weaknesses of his source material.
Thematically, the author aims at exploring the position and role of the Islamic court of justice in provincial society and administration, as well as the interaction between court and local community. Particular emphasis is put in this context on the influence that society exerted on the court and its practice, but also on the latter's social prestige and status. Methodologically, the book is divided in two basic sections after the first two introductory chapters. The first section (chapters 3–5) greatly benefits from the author's decision to make use of statistical–quantitative analysis in order to substantiate his arguments. In contrast, the second section (chapters 6–10) is marked by a shift to an empirical, more impressionistic approach; chapters 6–10 are to a large extent built around the “traditional” technique of discussing particular cases drawn from the registers of the Islamic courts of justice. The way in which these cases are discussed and commented on by the author reveals, however, an excellent understanding of the subtleties and intricacies of Ottoman society and justice. Nevertheless, Ergene could have benefited from the extensive bibliography based on the analysis of sicil records in order to locate cases that could have enriched his pool of comparable data, especially because his decision to study Kastamonu beside Çankırı arose from such a need. Furthermore, Hans Ulrich Krafft's case is without doubt very interesting and informative, but the author somewhat exaggerates its importance. It should not be overlooked that Krafft was not the typical court client and we do not know for sure the accuracy of his every statement about his experience. I would argue that the same applies to the positive attitude of the author toward contemporaneous accounts by Westerners in general.
Ergene reaches a number of important conclusions and draws attention to issues that may appear obvious in hindsight but have not been adequately emphasized by Ottomanist scholarship: the Islamic courts of different towns could differ in terms of their functions and social roles, the Islamic judge—as all judges—was not an unbiased adjudicator who stood outside and beyond society, a certain proportion of litigants (or people around them) were quite familiar with court practices and could skillfully manipulate them and use those techniques and strategies that they thought to be most fitting for them to win their cases, and Ottoman courts of justice conciliated strict observance of the law with regard for social needs and pressure. The picture that emerges from the book is one of communities that were on the whole knowledgeable of the fact that they had several options regarding places, methods, and strategies of settling their disputes. This picture remains mostly impressionistic, but this does not reduce the book's importance. On the contrary, Ergene's book stimulates us to think of several questions that most likely are unanswerable. For instance, two basic issues are what percentage of a region's population actually resorted to court and what percentage of those who resorted to court demonstrated some deeper understanding of the judicial system and of how to manipulate a dispute so as to win their cases in or out of court. Was it many, several, some, or very few?
The limitations of the book in a way originate in the nature and gaps of the sicils, which form its principal source material. The author's stated ambition is to explore the relationship and interaction between society and courts of justice, and he excels in it, given his basic source. However, sicils were—as the author admits on page 208 (see also his quote from Najwa al-Qattan on pp. 199–200)—records that were kept for the particular needs of the courts of justice and not with the 20th- or 21st-century historian in mind. Sometimes Ergene seems to forget this and treats the sicils as if they were literary narrative sources with authors who developed techniques in order to increase the dramatic effect for their readers (see, for instance, the first paragraphs of the section entitled “Voices and Screams in the Sicils” on p. 133).
All in all, Boğaç Ergene's book is a stimulating one with a fresh approach and inspiring ideas. Therefore, it is a very welcome addition to the literature on Ottoman justice and its social role.
