Together, Race and Multiculturalism in Malaysia and Singapore and Eating Her Curries and Kway dramatically expand the literature on the cultural underpinnings of identity-making in Southeast Asia.
Singapore and Malaysia often prove enigmatic to outside observers. While both countries have achieved impressive economic modernization, their approaches to multiculturalism may puzzle those who associate social modernization with the minimization of racial consciousness. Indeed, rather than discarding the racial categories inherited from British colonial authorities, both states have actively entrenched them. Since separation in 1965, the states have consciously promoted “Chinese majoritarian culture in Singapore and Malay cultural primacy in Malaysia at the level of public policy” (p. 3).
In his introduction, Daniel P. S. Goh offers an astute response to this apparent contradiction: both “Western liberal multiculturalism” and “Asian state multiculturalism” are attempts to grapple with the racial legacies of a shared colonial past, and therefore address comparable theoretical questions. Thus, Goh's anthology seeks to reopen the academic discourse: “The common problem the essays collected here engage with is the manifestation of state multiculturalism in Singapore and Malaysia that have institutionalized colonial racial identities and woven them into the fabric of political and social life to the extent that they constitute a common sense through which people conceive identities of themselves and others” (pp. 2–3).
By focusing on cultural practice, Goh and his colleagues offer an important addition to a literature historically dominated by the political ramifications of multiculturalism. The volume's greatest strength lies in the contributors' inspired ability to weave a coherent, linear argument that impressively overlays the wide array of disciplines, methodologies, and cultural lenses represented. This is not a mere compilation of eleven related essays. Rather, the anthology bears the marks of a successful collaborative dialogue.
Part one, “Postcolony and Cosmopolis,” is devoted to the role of government directives in the articulation of race. Philip Holden's opening chapter lays an important cornerstone for the remainder of the anthology. Through an examination of race and English-language literature in Singapore, Holden challenges the popular assumption that the state simply manages primordial communities, arguing instead that state multiracialism plays a role in “recreating and redeploying racialization” (p. 34). In support, in chapter 2 Helen Ting provides a fascinating case study, meticulously detailing the ideological underpinnings of recent Malaysian history textbooks, particularly in relation to the concept of ketuanan Melayu, or Malay sovereignty. For a comparative example, in chapter 3 Daniel Goh describes Singapore's gradual turn to “Chineseness” and Confucian values in the postcolonial era. Part one concludes with incisive pieces on Singapore's negotiation of race and cosmopolitanism (chapter 4) and the reactions of Malaysian bloggers to an increasingly self-empowered Hindi population (chapter 5).
Part two, “Representing Race, Performing Multiculturalism,” scrutinizes social and cultural texts. In chapter 6, Gaik Cheng Khoo considers the progressive, cosmopolitan filmography of Yasmin Ahmad and its challenges to a conservative Malay cultural elite. This essay is followed by a pair of Singapore-focused essays examining racist stereotypes in local film (chapter 7) and portrayals of Indian women in local literature (chapter 8). Read together, these three essays remind us that no community exists in a vacuum; the representation of a specific subculture is always informed by and interpreted through the expectations of other groups. Thus, cinematic and literary portrayals invariably affect the processes of cultural identification.
Chapters 9 and 10 append a corollary to this point: vernacular practices can either “disarticulate” or “re-territorialize” racial governmentality. In other words, just as the mat rock and heavy metal music scene can blur social boundaries, inviting other groups to participate in a traditionally working-class, Malay male subculture, the practice of Bhangra music can be coopted to reaffirm “Punjabi-ness” and exclusivity in a multicultural society.
Finally, the anthology is capped in chapter 11 by an exploration of Wong Hoy Cheong's visual art, work that speaks to a burgeoning cultural hybridity that is challenging the ongoing postcolonial model of racial governmentality.
The final assessment is that “state multiculturalism in both countries does not erase specific vernacular identities; but rather preserves and disciplines these identities within the racial grid and enacts historical erasure of different, radical visions of multiracialism that attempt to subvert or transcend the racial grid [of Chinese, Malay, Indian, and Other]” (p. 214). Drawing from colonial taxonomies, the racial governmentalities of Singapore and Malaysia continue to form subcultures around clearly demarcated racial and linguistic communities, actively impeding various forms of cultural hybridization.
Despite the comprehensive breadth of Goh's anthology, Nicole Tarulevicz's Eating Her Curries and Kway is able to locate yet another lens for deciphering race, postcolonialism, and identity in Singapore: food culture. Still, nearly any chapter of Tarulevicz's book could be effortlessly slotted into the consistent argumentative thread running throughout Race and Multiculturalism in Malaysia and Singapore.
Indeed, Tarulevicz argues, the culinary and gastronomic record is central to Singapore's articulation of local identity and its infamous regulation of social behavior: “Food is a site of meaning-making in Singapore. It is a prescriptive society and, far from being excluded from this process, food is critical to the development of its rules” (p. 164). Specifically, she says, food production and consumption are means for Singaporeans to negotiate the myriad complexities of multiracialism. By using food as a malleable marker of cultural heritage, the society defines not only what “counts” as authentically Singaporean, but also how race and gender relate to that constructed ideal.
Through analyses of Singaporean cookbooks (chapter 6), food-related advertising (chapter 7), and the marketing of Singaporean cuisine (chapter 8), Tarulevicz illustrates how food becomes a powerful nationalist symbol, a rhetorical anchor in the inevitable cultural discourses of a small but cosmopolitan city-state. The state capitalizes on the powerful symbolic value of food heritage as it negotiates the local and global, multicultural and sectarian, East and West, past and present.
Furthermore, the sites of food preparation and consumption become important loci for both colonial and state ordering, as authorities obsessively intervene in these “foodscapes” in order to regulate public space, the national image, and even the individual body. Sections on public eating spaces (chapter 3) and Singaporean kitchens (chapter 4) examine the “regulation of public space and food hygiene against the backdrop of colonial policy and anxieties” (p. 6). From the hawker centers to the kitchens of public housing estates, the writer suggests, the state expresses its vision of a sanitized, domesticated nation.
Unfortunately, Tarulevicz occasionally falls into a common trap faced by political scholars of Singapore, which is to confuse instances of ordinary common sense with systematic and unsavory draconian control. Thus, a bridal magazine's predictable tips for encouraging guests to arrive on time, or Female magazine's incontestable commentary on gym etiquette (“grunting a la Monica Seles is [irritating to others]”), are brandished as evidence that citizens must be “coerced” or “directed” into orderly behavior by the Singaporean state (pp. 46–47). The question of state overreach in Singapore is a legitimate one, but over-extrapolating from innocent or isolated examples is counterproductive.
That said, Tarulevicz is a fine writer. Her unexplained choice of title is puzzling—the reader half-expects a personal narrative—but Eating Her Curries and Kway follows a standard academic format. The Singapore neophyte will find it pleasantly readable, but the serious cultural scholar will also benefit from Tarulevicz's steady stream of insights and fresh perspectives.
Together, these two books mark an important contribution to our understanding of multicultural politics—not only on the Malayan peninsula, but wherever societies are negotiating complex interethnic identities.
