Children from infants to adolescents appeared onstage in unprecedented numbers in late Victorian Britain as theatre took an increasingly prominent role in an emergent world of mass leisure and modern entertainment. In Child Labor in the British Victorian Entertainment Industry, a well-packed scholarly work of substance and insight, Dyan Colclough recovers the history of the theatrical child both as performer and worker, with emphasis on the latter underresearched figure primarily in the London theatre. A standout stage persona might vault a Victorian child actor into stardom and celebrity—idolized by audiences, idealized in literature, glamorized in photography and the press, and all while rewarded with relatively generous wages. Offstage, however, the prospective child performer could be subjected to a grueling regime of trade training, virtually becoming a wage slave with no payment at all during preproduction rehearsals that lasted as long as six to eight weeks before the curtain went up on long-run shows in London's great houses. In the eyes of reformers, evangelical and humanitarian, this was the child as victim, the exploited object of rescue work and a further indictment of the theatre as moral swamp.
Beginning in the early 1880s, child-themed productions surged, creating an unprecedented market for young performers. Richard D'Oyly Carte had an all-child cast for an afternoon production of Pirates of Penzance, which outran the evening adult version. Carte, as much an entrepreneur as an impresario, also recruited a wholly juvenile cast for one of his touring companies, a significant part of the expansionist reach of an increasingly commercialized theatre industry. The vogue for stage spectacle and fantasy found its most grandiose formulation (and one most financially rewarding for proprietors) in pantomime, the revamped Christmas show that could run for three or four months with massive casts of children in diverse costume roles—fairies, goblins, animals, vegetables. Theatre missionaries recorded one hapless youth enduring a long wait—an inescapable backstage penalty for supers—while virtually imprisoned in the tight, unventilated costume of a carrot. Children played an enormous role in the popularization of the previously elite art of ballet, in the music halls as well as on the legitimate stage. Here, the feeder industry made up of trainers and agents was most involved and exacting, which campaigners against child cruelty saw as typified by the figure of the ballet mistress with the cane.
Colclough is particularly revealing on the complex moves and motives of reformers, the contest over protective legislation, and the evasive response of employers. By this account, London theatre mogul Augustus Harris of Drury Lane, who claimed labor to be a pleasure not a hardship, is the true pantomime villain. Also welcome is closer scrutiny of the gendered nature of theatrical child labor. Girls were more likely to be employed than boys and were often hired to play boys onstage. Although girl actors enjoyed pay rates surpassing anything available to them in the wider market, they were more vulnerable to exploitation. Production styles gave an erotic burnish to the contemporary fixation on the child as the embodiment of purity and innocence, and consequently raised levels of sexual abuse and harassment.
Child Labor in the British Victorian Entertainment Industry does indeed interpret the theatre of the day as an industry—not the “quintessentially light industry” (353) suggested by Tracy Davis in The Economics of the British Stage, 1800–1914 (Cambridge University Press, 2000), but an oppressive equivalent of the archetypal factory of Britain's capitalist Industrial Revolution. Here Colclough works from the humanist Left perspective in British social history and cultural studies (“history from below”), with its focus on labor and working-class subjects. The stark analogy of theatre as dark satanic mill is necessarily qualified, most obviously in the unique fusion of production and consumption at the moment of performance. This is the site and occasion of the child worker's emotional reward, the return on labor in the adulation of the audience, a revered exercise of empowerment—“agency” (40)—for both.
The book's historiographic model generates an occasional earnest formalism but inspires an impressive depth of research and imaginative engagement with the subject. Extracts from a vast range of sources in the newspaper and periodical press give an immediacy to the otherwise elusive voices of the child subjects. Illustrations are well chosen though a number suffer from poor reproduction. As is still their common fate, they remain interpretively unincorporated into the main text. Though hardly a titanic error, W. T. Stead is misspelled.
Dyan Colclough makes an important contribution to the history of the Victorian theatre and the phenomenon of child involvement in it—a subject of growing transatlantic scholarly interest (witness, for example, Shauna Vey's recent study of juvenile actors in nineteenth-century America, reviewed in Theatre Survey 57.3). There is a certain editorial sleight of hand in the title of Colclough's study, which refers to the British entertainment industry yet is confined to the legitimate theatre and mostly in London. By the late Victorian period, complementary entertainment forms, such as music hall, the circus, and seaside and exhibition sites, had taken on features of modern industrial production, with or without child labor. Some attention to these wider developments would help test the utility of the factory model for the theatre and its performers and address the distinctions between entertainment and the dramatic arts.
