The university occupies a peculiar space in democratic societies with market economies. Higher education serves the cause of democracy by fostering a more able and enlightened citizenry and the needs of the economy by producing a more skilled and creative workforce. The university likewise depends on the state and the market for its resources, for the tuitions, the grants, the contracts, the licenses, the royalties, and the gifts that are the lifeblood of every institution of higher learning.
At the same time that the university serves society and draws on its means, the university also declares the right to deliver education and scholarship on the terms determined by the university's scholars and teachers—and only by its scholars and teachers. The content of the curriculum and the mode of its delivery, the agendas for inquiries and the conclusions to be drawn from them, and the standards of evaluation of students and teachers and scholars, the university claims, all should be left to the university itself. It is an audacious assertion relative to the norms of the democratic polity and the capitalist market, but it is not a brazen claim of privilege or a selfish plea for indulgence. Rather, the university can only fulfill its role in society if its members, the faculty and the students, are free to explore ideas, to debate their implications, and to follow the inquiries wherever they may lead. If the resources the university draws from the polity and from the economy are its lifeblood, academic freedom is its oxygen.
And therein lies the tension. The university forever has been in but not of the polity and the market. Its values are not the preferences of the majority or the prejudices of the powerful, or the returns of its investors, or the wants of its customers. Its ideals are the Enlightenment principles of reasoned argument, systematic evidence, and judicious inference. Interference in the process of inquiry threatens the university by bending truth to the needs of power. In asserting academic freedom, that is, the university is not being needlessly provocative. The task of the university is not to bite the hand that feeds it, nor to reject the hand that receives its ministrations. The imperative is to ensure that the hand that supplies it and the hand that receives from it does not also hold its leash—or worse still, its muzzle.Footnote 1
PRESSURES ON UNIVERSITY FINANCES, AND ACADEMIC FREEDOM
The financial model of higher education has changed dramatically during the last half century. National and state governments have curtailed their support for higher education and research, but public agencies still rank among the primary patrons of American colleges and universities. Partly out of necessity, and partly responding to the opportunities in the marketplace, colleges and university have raised their prices, taking in more of their resources in tuition from students and their families. Mandated by government and encouraged by industry, they have sought to profit from their research through grants, contracts, and the commercialization of intellectual property. Like all other kinds of eleemosynary institutions, but in the advance guard, colleges and universities have solicited philanthropic support for current activities and enduring priorities.
This new financial environment in higher education has only complicated the protection of academic freedom. While governments have pulled back their financing, for example, they have in no way loosened the strings that are attached to it. Naturally, government agencies are accountable to elected officials, and elected officials to the public, and many of the regulatory demands that governments make on colleges and universities are prima facie reasonable on that basis. The line between accountability to the public and government control, however, is not a bright one. For instance, many social scientists object to the requirements for prior review and approval of research on human subjects, even though they acknowledge the ethical obligations that social scientists owe to participants in their research and even though they recognize that the federal government (which mandates the review) delegates the actual oversight largely to the community of researchers themselves. The concern is that the actual effect of the regulation—if not the actual purpose—is to discourage particular kinds of scholarly research and to steer it away from topics that might be deemed controversial. Even in instances in which government regulations do not venture as near to the conduct of research and teaching, for example in the reporting obligations for government grants or the process requirements in employment, the impact on colleges and universities is substantial. Every institution of higher learning spends more of its money—and the time and the energy of its faculty and staff—on regulatory compliance than it ever did before. The university's continued reliance on government affects the university's priorities. Dollars spent on compliance are dollars diverted from other core activities, like instruction and research. That the reward for compliance is a diminishing share of the operating budget is an aggravation to every academic leader (particularly in public institutions).
The shift toward private support through contracts, licenses, tuition, and philanthropy presents its own challenges to academic freedom. The university faces increasing pressure from government and increasing encouragement from industry to commercialize the products of its research and teaching. As we have recently seen, the financial rewards to colleges and universities that are successful in such “knowledge transfer” are enormous. The concept of ideas made private property and sold in the marketplace, however, runs contrary to the university's traditional commitments to free exchange of ideas among scholars, teachers, and students, within the academy and beyond it. Policymakers have grappled with the issue in setting the rules for patents and copyrights. The university itself has lived for some time with the tension and the internal conflicts it creates, for example between engineers and natural scientists and between faculty in business schools and faculty in liberal arts departments. As pressures escalate, and temptation beckons, many scholars fear that the value of ideas in intellectual exchange will yield precedence to the value of ideas in commercial exchange, both in establishing the priorities of the university and in setting the university's standards for membership.
The turn to tuition as a larger funding source has stressed another aspect of academic freedom: the prerogative of the faculty to legislate the curriculum and the standards by which the students' performance in it will be judged. The rankings of colleges and universities by U.S. News and World Report and other publications certainly have played their part in convincing students and their families to regard higher education not as a means of self-improvement, self-knowledge, or self-fulfillment but as a straightforward consumer purchase. But financial necessity has also spurred colleges and universities to compete more intensively to serve students, both to earn the vital tuition dollars they provide and (for the lucky and relatively few institutions that can be selective) to attract the high-ability students who burnish the reputations that justify the premium prices. On the whole, the increased attention to the quality of the experience that the university gives to students has been much to the good. As many who have children (or grandchildren) in college now (or recently) attest, the university expects more of itself, and instruction is better, academic and career counseling is better, and services are better than a generation or two ago. Whether the education students receive from the university is improved, however, is up for greater debate. The “commodification” of higher education, many critics argue, has made colleges and universities reluctant to demand as much in the curriculum and to expect as much from students in its fulfillment. The commercial principle of consumer satisfaction, they say, has limited the faculty's ability—or sapped its will—to prioritize intellectual merit.
Finally, the new financial formation in higher education has given additional leverage to officers of the public, leaders of commerce, families of students, and contributors to philanthropy who might seek to exert influence within the university. Study and inquiry that is truly free often strays outside of social and political bounds. The members of the university, therefore, both the students and the faculty, are wont to read, write, say, and do things that challenge, provoke, upset, or offend others. Whether their purpose is to influence the public debate or not, social scientists and scholars in allied fields like business and law are particularly likely to explore questions in their teaching and research that bear on some of the most important and contentious issues of the day. (Much as we might flatter ourselves, however, we are hardly unique in our ability to generate controversy, as climate scientists, evolutionary biologists, and ethicists will testify.) Presidents, provosts, deans, and department chairs in every college and university are familiar with communications expressing indignation, disappointment, anger, or distress over particular acts of certain students or (more often) specific members of the faculty, some demanding a remedy. In certain cases, the grievances call attention to relationships with the university. In all cases, whether the source makes a connection to the university explicit or not, academic leaders make it their business to find it out. They have a duty to the university to ensure that the students and faculty will be judged solely according to principles of intellectual merit. They also have a responsibility to the university to manage relationships that are important to the university in the present and for the future.
PROTECTING ACADEMIC FREEDOM IN THE NEW FISCAL ENVIRONMENT
Serious as they are, however, the university is not powerless against the challenges to academic freedom in the new world of higher education finance. First, remarkably, the authoritative response to many of the threats to free inquiry is the response that the university itself chooses to give. Governments leave the determination of many of the details of their regulations, such as acceptable practices in ethical human subjects research, to the university and its faculty, that is, to the colleagues and peers of the teachers and researchers. Colleges and universities enter into contracts for knowledge transfer as informed and equal parties, free to accept or refuse or negotiate the conditions offered by commercial collaborators. Even today, students (and their parents) willingly submit to the judgment of teachers, either in deference to ancient custom, out of respect for the teacher's qualifications, or as an investment in the value of their degrees. Finally, many benefactors of higher education are motivated—quite literally—by philanthropy, by love for the university, and by commitment to its mission, and they eagerly accept the guidance of the university's leaders so that the terms of purposes of their gifts serve the university best. Apart from the polity and the market in its core commitments, the university even today possesses considerable authority and prestige, and so it enjoys a great deal of autonomy. To a significant extent, the university opens itself to pressures that it determines.Footnote 2
The university's ability to influence the demands made on it is not absolute. Colleges and universities have a great deal of say in their dealings with the institutions and individuals that provide their resources, but governments, businesses, students, and donors are also free to take their resources elsewhere if they do not like what they hear. In extremis, the university has the choice to starve or to suffocate.
Even when the university is not given deference, however, it still has several resources to influence its investors, customers, and patrons toward respect for academic freedom.Footnote 3
The first asset is a clear—and clearly articulated—sense of the university's values. As a dean, I counted myself fortunate that the University of Chicago has recourse to statements of principles of decision and action authored by its faculty members. Of several, the most directly relevant to this discussion is the “Report on the University's Role in Political and Social Activism,” the product of a 1967 committee led by the distinguished First Amendment scholar Harry Kalven, Jr. The Kalven Report takes as given the likelihood that free inquiry creates controversy. “A university faithful to its mission,” it notes, “will provide enduring challenges to social values, policies, practices, and institutions…. In brief, a good university, like Socrates, will be upsetting.” The Kalven Committee enjoined the university to “embrace, be hospitable to, and encourage the widest diversity of views within its own community.” To do so, the committee argued, the university as an institution must eschew comment of any kind on the great issues of the day, including responses to the utterances and pronouncements of individual students and members of the faculty. The university's role in social activism, it averred, is to be “the home and sponsor of critics” and “not itself the critic.”Footnote 4
The value of the Kalven Report is less in its particulars—admirable as many, myself included, may find them—than in its simple existence. An open statement of principles like the Kalven Report serves two important purposes in defending academic freedom. For members of the immediate university community, for students, members of the faculty, and academic leaders, it is a reminder of the core values of the academic community. As such, it serves as a guide to action within the university, ruling some courses proper and other courses not. For audiences outside the immediate community, and particularly for individuals and institutions that might be disposed to attach troublesome conditions to financial support, clarity in the expression of principles directs attention upward from the particular to the universal. The provocation in the words or actions of members of the university community, it says, is not specific to this issue or this complainant, and neither is the university's response. By its nature, the intellectual work of the university rouses many grievances, but by adhering to its express principles, the university exercises consistency in its response to complaints, and to the words and actions themselves. (Principles have meaning as principles only if they sometimes force conclusions that we would otherwise not wish to accept.) Indeed, it says, the university does as it does in pursuit of its higher calling, the advancement of knowledge, in service to society. In short, a statement of principles gives an explanation for the university's action (or inaction), an accounting of the university's responsibilities to its students and its faculty, to its friends and supporters, and to society at large. And explanations, we know, help make respectful disagreement possible.Footnote 5
A second asset for the university in the protection of academic freedom is a faculty who uses it and defends its use. On one level, the faculty advances academic freedom by taking provocative positions and “forcing” the university to defend its exercise. Although the faculty tends to underestimate the resolve of academic leaders in guarding the prerogatives of scholars and teachers—they do not see the half of it—the university is stronger for the “trouble” its faculty creates. In a negotiation, there is often value in not being able to control the actions of third parties. More important still, the faculty advances academic freedom by using it to follow ideas where they lead, without fear, favor, or preconception. There is no more powerful demonstration of the social value of free inquiry than a scholar who revolutionizes a field by advancing ideas that were unorthodox, unfashionable, unpopular, or even heretical in their time. (There is also no better illustration of the importance of the university's being home and sponsor to critics regardless of point of view. Revolutionary advances begin with heterodoxies, so it is impossible to pick the winners in the marketplace of ideas in advance.) Like it or not, many of the patrons of colleges and universities—particularly government—support higher education because it gets results, for them narrowly, for society broadly, and if it takes a great measure of deference to free the mind to approach problems in productive new ways, then a great measure of deference they will give.
Finally, in the promotion of academic freedom, the university has a tremendous resource in its students and alumni. Higher education is a pathway to wealth, position, and influence in American society, and so the alumni of colleges and universities are well placed to influence government, direct business, and underwrite philanthropy in ways that benefit the university and support free inquiry. Many alumni are motivated to want to help the university because they share the university's values. In my experience, even when alumni feel offended by something the university or its faculty or its students has said or done (or not said or not done), they understand the university's defense of academic freedom because they appreciate the importance of free inquiry. Likewise in my experience, even when alumni have their own ideas for their philanthropy, they respond to the university's sense of its needs and priorities because they love the university and they care about its mission.
The facility with which the university navigates the brave new world of higher education finance may turn, then, on its success in the cause of liberal education. An institution that stands apart from the polity and from the market and proclaims the right to operate by its own distinctive values must be thoughtful about the point of crossing between the university and the polity and the market, about its students as they become its alumni. If students experience an education that liberates the mind, that supports them as they jostle with ideas that are stimulating, challenging, perplexing, or merely delightful, then they will also understand the value of free inquiry, because they will see its power in their own lives.
