It would be very worthwhile to have a broad-ranging study that took Bernard Capp's magisterial Astrology and the Popular Press: English Almanacs 1500–1800 (London, 1979) as its foundation, incorporating the subsequent thirty years of scholarship and, in particular, exploiting the easier access to primary sources permitted by digital technology. Louise Hill Curth's decision to focus her study of 2,286 English almanacs from the period primarily on their medical contents – a subject underdeveloped in Capp's study, and done with his encouragement and consultation – promises to shed further light on this significant but still understudied source for the history of early modern medicine, science and culture. Indeed, the five chapters (6–10) she devotes to this tightly defined subject are the most successful, with discussions of astrology and physick, preventive and remedial medicine, advertisements for commercial drugs, and veterinary medicine that, taken together, make English Almanacs, Astrology and Popular Medicine: 1550–1700 a useful contribution.
The chapters on the last two subjects explore virtually virgin scholarly territory, with the one on medical advertising especially informative, treating, among other interesting topics, the rise of commercial medicines. Curth argues that the appearance of this ‘new breed of seventeenth-century commercialized drugs’ (p. 184) towards the end of that century marks a real change from the earlier and nearly ubiquitous use of ‘kitchen physick’; that is, medicines composed of ingredients easily available in the home or garden. She discusses this and other traditional patterns of what she calls ‘Galenic-astrological’ (p. 117) medicine across several chapters, making the important point that, although chemical medicaments entered medical practice in the mid-sixteenth century with Paracelsian medical innovations, traditional astrologico-Galenic diagnosis and treatment continued – and with very few exceptions – to be featured in almanacs until 1700. However, on this topic (as on others), comparisons – whether continuities or contrasts – with contemporary practices throughout Europe, or even simply citations to the relevant scholarship, would have increased her study's utility.
Alas, the book's first half, treating the broader context of the writing, publishing and reading of almanacs, is not as successful. Although clearly organized, these chapters struck this reader as wooden, one-dimensional and derivative – and altogether too long. Most, however, at least have value in leading the reader to a rich vein of excellent recent scholarship. Even this cannot be said for the fifth chapter, ‘Astrology and popular culture’, which introduces Part II, ‘Structures of practice and knowledge’. It is misleading in several respects, not least about astrology's conceptual structure.
In situating astrology within the popular literature of almanacs, Curth strangely chooses Lauren (sic) Smoller's fine study of Pierre d'Ailly (1351–1420) and his use of astrology as her guide to ‘the astrological content in early modern popular books’ (p. 107). Surely Keith Thomas's Religion and the Decline of Magic (Oxford, 1971), which she cites elsewhere, would have been a more natural choice for both time and place. Regardless, after briefly and accurately noting the four types of astrological practice (‘revolutions’, ‘nativities’, ‘elections’ and ‘interrogations’), Curth states that ‘while this [typology] is a useful, general description for printed books, it does not accurately describe the astrological content of most almanacs’. In her view, a ‘more constructive method for almanacs would be to divide them into the two categories of judicial and natural astrology’. For Curth, judicial astrology boils down to political predictions, while natural astrology covers two subcategories: what she calls ‘environmental astrology’ (p. 110), concerning the weather, agriculture and husbandry; and medical astrology, concerning health and illness.
Although claiming that judicial and natural astrology are ‘the same categories used by almanac writers’ (p. 106), Curth does not cite contemporary early modern discussions to support her definitions, which will strike fellow specialists as problematic, with the one for judicial astrology being especially egregious. In her defence, the judicial/natural distinction (however ill-defined) is rampant in the historiography, but it is almost always used in an anachronistic manner. In fact, the practical astrology most often found in almanacs belongs to the ‘revolutions’ type, or what Curth acceptably (following Smoller) calls ‘general predictions’. Made for ‘big-picture’ events or influences, these predictions were based on planetary cycles of different kinds, including conjunctions and the other planetary aspects.
A more useful and accurate analysis would focus on the different types of prognostication that can arise from revolutions. For almanacs, these prognostications derive primarily from what is called a horoscope of the year, which interprets the astrological influences of the planetary configuration occurring when the sun enters Aries, thus marking the beginning of the astrological year. The horoscope of the year can then provide information on numerous topics of interest to a broad range of almanac readers, including politics, public health, crop yields, animal husbandry and the weather, to name but a few. By classifying political prognostications under judicial astrology and predictions about health and the weather under natural astrology, Curth gratuitously imposes our modern distinction on the premodern material in a way that distorts our understanding. If there is, as she claims, an authentic ‘judicial’/‘natural’ distinction in almanacs – as we do find later, for example in Chambers's Cyclopedia (1728) – a much more useful approach would have been to clearly trace out the use of these terms and their underlying conceptual referents over the period of her study.
Fortunately, these problems do not undermine the value of the rest of Part II as an introduction to the study of the medical and veterinary content in almanacs, primarily because these both fall under her rubric of ‘natural astrology’, which, although gratuitous in this context, does not require her to make any further distorting anachronistic distinctions. Indeed, the rest of the book comes to life and ends up quite instructive, based as it is on a close reading of such a large number of almanacs. It is hard to shake the feeling, however, that the scholarly community would have been better served overall by a reprint of Capp's study with a bibliographical addendum, after reading which the interested reader would get a great deal more from the later chapters of Curth's useful but ultimately disappointing book.
