These two collections are a welcome addition to the growing literature which explores how musicians, repertories, practices and ideas have gained their places in the world. The individual essays explore a complex and evolving network of technologies (principally, but not exclusively, print culture), intermediaries (such as publishers) and processes (advertising, marketing and performance). Emily H. Green and Catherine Mayes's Consuming Music contains nine studies organized as four short sections: Selling Variety, Edifying Readers, Marketing the Mundane and Cultivating Communities. Some of its topics are of broad interest, while others are extremely specific: eighteenth-century publishers (Green); a Viennese art shop (Rupert Ridgewell); a music textbook by Telemann (Steven Zohn); eighteenth-century notation and print (Roger Mathew Grant); commercial string chamber music (Marie Sumner Lott); the decline of the Hungarian contredanse (Mayes), gender and celebrity in the early American republic (Glenda Goodman); the Berliner allgemeine musikalische Zeitung in 1824 (Patrick Wood Uribe); and the Paris Opéra between commons and commodity (Peter Mondelli). Christina Bashford and Roberta Montemorra Marvin's The Idea of Art Music focuses on the mid-nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Its 13 essays are organized into five sections: Publishers, Personalities, Instruments, Repertoires and (the somewhat confusingly titled) Settings. The generally more substantial topics include: Rossini's military marches (Denise Gallo); the publicity campaign for Puccini's La bohème (Michaela Ronzani); the publisher Novello (David Wright); the singer Jenny Lind (George Biddlecombe); Wagner's concealed self-promotion (Nicholas Vazsonyi); the British conductors Julius Benedict and Frederic Cowen (Fiona M. Palmer); the advertising of player pianos in the USA (Catherine Hennessy Wolter); British violin culture (Bashford); ancient Greek music in the USA (Jon Solomon); marketing Verdi in London (Montemorra Marvin); sacred repertories in nineteenth-century Leipzig (Jeffrey S. Sposato); the music business on the edge of the British Empire (David Gramit); and the music printed in French magazines at the turn of the twentieth century (Jann Pasler).
The stated aims of the collections are not identical, but they overlap. For Green and Mayes, ‘consuming music’ clearly also embraces the consumption of ideas around music, such as music criticism; for Bashford and Montemorra Marvin, a study of the ‘idea of art music’ includes repertories which are not traditionally regarded as such, but are primarily designed for commercial consumption. Both collections can be seen as a reaction against the long-standing Romantic paradigm which separates art from the world, a paradigm that various scholars have argued is a false dichotomy.Footnote 1 For many scholars, works are still best regarded as scores, and the idea of a self-justifying canonic repertoire existing above commercial concerns retains considerable appeal. How else could Karol Berger write: ‘If the work is the characteristic product of art music, its characteristic maker is the composer; the performer, whose role is to transform the work into an event, is the mediator between the composer and the user of music’?Footnote 2 For that mindset, technologies, intermediaries apart from the performer and processes other than a performance are invisible; material culture simply does not exist. Berger is not alone; many practical musicians share this position, and therefore struggle with an unnecessary ideological tension between serving ‘art music’ and positioning themselves as desirable commodities within a brutally competitive market.
The purposes of these collections are therefore important. Bashford points out that the ‘commercial world […] has become a fairly well-rehearsed topic’ in scholarship (‘Introduction: The Idea of Art Music in a Commercial World’, The Idea of Art Music, 1–17 (p. 1)), but it is only recently that these pragmatic considerations have intersected with the shifting historical and philosophical thinking surrounding music in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Bashford and Montemorra Marvin's stated aim to ‘lay to rest the residual, but powerful, taboos around the discussion of art music and money’ (p. 16) are laudable because these taboos remain destructive for musicians, and reductive for music scholars. Equally, the ‘musical consumer’ who is the stated subject of Green and Mayes's collection is indeed ‘underdocumented, underresearched, and undertheorized’ (Green and Mayes, ‘Introduction’, 1–12 (p. 3)). Their collection builds on several important books, such as William Weber's The Musician as Entrepreneur, adding publishers, theorists, impresarios and critics to Weber's list of composers, performers and patrons.Footnote 3 Green and Mayes stress that the emergence of an ideology surrounding ‘great works’ was wholly compatible with commerce, given the importance of dissemination in print. Finally, they show that many of today's publishing and marketing practices were successfully anticipated, albeit with different technology, at least two centuries ago.
The topics and methodologies of many of the chapters in the two collections also overlap – as do the questions they stimulate for further research. Bashford points to the urgency of these aims when she notes the fundamental epistemological shift in the nature of music with the advent of recordings, the concomitant impact on the role of printed scores and, by association, a decline in music literacy (p. 6). This shift has substantial – and ugly – sociopolitical implications which endure today. Who automatically participates in this process of consuming music, by investing, for example, in their own and their children's music literacy and buying instruments and sheet music? Who attends concerts? Who can't or won't? The best essays show how abstract ideas about art music are informed by and integrated into worldly structures, while the others still illuminate much about the mechanisms of the music business and invite us to investigate even further how they shape aesthetic credibility or status.
Professional musicians
Discussions of how individual musicians negotiated the musical market are particularly valuable – even moving – because their findings are still so relevant today, and because they reveal much about wider issues such as gender and nation. In that sense, it is a pity that the collections include so few essays on individuals. The famous among these are Lind, Wagner and to a lesser extent Benedict and Cowen, all in The Idea of Art Music. George Biddlecombe's essay on visual representations of Lind (‘Jenny Lind, Illustration, Song and the Relationship between Prima donna and Public’, 86–113) shows how images of her shaped ideals of femininity within domestic settings – a blend of beauty and virtue. The correlation between Lind's ballad repertoire and the values of modesty, decorum and restraint also recalls Joseph Joachim's serious performances of string quartets or the presentation of Clara Schumann as a priestess of art – although, as Biddlecombe points out, the texts of Lind's ballads could also be trivial and light.Footnote 4 And as with Clara Schumann, the external ideal of Lind was mapped onto her internal persona – her performances are conflated with herself.Footnote 5 Nicholas Vazsonyi's essay on Wagner (‘A German in Paris: Richard Wagner and the Masking of Commodification’, 114–29) presents an astute operator, who expertly and uniquely negotiated the market; identified, assessed and attacked the competition; and exploited every available means to self-publicize – yet maintained a pose of ‘artistic disinterestedness’ (p. 122). His account of how Wagner strategically limited access to Parsifal shows that commerce is encoded in exclusivity – ‘limiting the supply increases the demand’ (p. 129). Wagner's extraordinarily determined self-publicization – he ‘was the progenitor of most of the noise about him’ (p. 117) – exemplifies his ability to exploit the idea of art music to his own professional ends.
Like several other essays, Vazsonyi's touches on questions of nationhood, in this case how Wagner affirmed his German identity while in Paris. This issue is prepared in Bashford's introduction; she identifies a move towards internationalism in commercial musical life, but in tension with the seemingly deathless power of nationalist branding (p. 7). One could think of the ‘Nordic’ seasons regularly offered by major orchestras, or the runaway success of Brahms's Hungarian dances or, more controversially, the way the label ‘German’ was synonymous with quality, as shown in several of the other essays. ‘Ideal’ art music for those British conductors discussed by Fiona Palmer (‘Conductors and Self-Promotion in the British Nineteenth-Century Marketplace’, 130–49) – Benedict and Cowen – was articulated through perceived national traits, namely German versus English. Montemorra Marvin's chapter on marketing Verdi in London (‘Selling a “False Verdi” in Victorian London’, 223–47) also invokes nation: the ‘vigour and dramatic power’ of Aida are attributed in one newspaper to Teutonic influences, and this recurring motif is surely an important part of the shaping of both artistic and commercial agendas (p. 244).
Within Consuming Music, Glenda Goodman's study of female self-commodification in the early American republic (‘The Power to Please: Gender and Celebrity Self-Commodification in the Early American Republic’, 176–204) takes an unusual approach by focusing on the ‘unexceptional’ singer-actress-composer Mary Ann Wright Pownall (1751–96) and exploring the ‘mundaneness of earning a living as a female celebrity’ (p. 178). But her account of Pownall – who left her husband and lived with another man; raised a family while maintaining a career which took her to the Theatre Royal in Drury Lane and the Vauxhall Pleasure Gardens; emigrated to the USA; and had a career revival despite being over 40 years old – suggests that she was rather exceptional. The issue of Pownall within print culture is trickier in terms of writing history because the body of work Pownall published is very modest, limiting what can be extrapolated without more information about its circulation and popularity.
Music institutions
Just two chapters overall focus on public performance spaces, which is surprising given the central role of public performance in bringing together artistic ideals and commercial aims. Jeffrey Sposato's excellent account in The Idea of Art Music of how commercial repertoire-programming tactics were brought to bear in the Leipzig Thomaskirche and Nikolaikirche in the early nineteenth century (‘Schicht, Hauptmann, Mendelssohn and the Consumption of Sacred Music in Leipzig’, 250–73) shows how even churches in Leipzig drew on strategies like slimming down the service, the establishment of a ‘kind of Kenner/Liebhaber divide between vespers and the Sunday service’, coordination with the Gewandhaus's offering, and the serialization of larger musical works over multiple Sundays (pp. 261– 4). He then considers the symbiotic relationship between Leipzig's sacred and secular music, and how Mendelssohn and his colleague Moritz Hauptmann constructed a canon through a shared focus on historic repertory, thereby cultivating shared tastes in their concert audiences/congregations. This ambitious and revealing essay shows the long arm of commerce not only in music but also in religion.
In Consuming Music, Peter Mondelli's closing chapter on Parisian opera (‘Parisian Opera between Commons and Commodity, ca. 1830’, 222–40) questions the ‘historical validity of a separation between public and private ends, between commons and commodity, in early nineteenth century Paris’ (p. 224). But Mondelli too swiftly moves beyond this intriguing opening provocation to explore the shifting, transactional nature of public spaces in Paris, specifically how the Opéra functioned as a producer of commodities after its funding changed from full state subsidy to a for-profit (albeit still subsidized) venture, because of the unique cultural capital it had accumulated over an extended period of time. He also explores the links between publishers and music journals, in this case Schlesinger and the Gazette musicale and the Revue musicale. Given the implicit critique of the notion of value running through the book, it is no surprise that Mondelli writes that ‘audiences went to the performances they thought they ought to see and purchased the music they thought they ought to own, just as impresarios and publishers produced what they believed their audiences wanted’ (p. 234). But I am not convinced that this statement actually allows for the genuine expressions of aesthetic value one finds in, say, private letters. Are consumers really this passive?
Amateur musicians
Amateur musicians are well served in both collections. Bashford's chapter in The Idea of Art Music (‘Art, Commerce and Artisanship: Violin Culture in Britain, c. 1880–1920’, 178–99) focuses beautifully on this group in relation to the violin, whose place within commerce is often overlooked. As a volume editor, her chapter aligns most explicitly with the book's overall purpose. She focuses on how the violin broke ‘barriers of gender and class’ for a brief period in the 1880s and 1890s, considering practical and aesthetic aspects of the violin's materiality (it is at once cheap and compact, and physically beautiful, fragile and handmade), and tracing the delicate balance between pragmatism and idealism that can tilt the fate of an entire musical practice in new directions. She also touches on the crucial questions of children's music education, including its cost, availability and validation through the examination frameworks of Trinity College of Music and the Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music; the importance of leisure time; and career destinations for young musicians. These issues remain central in discussions of art music in society today. Bashford places violin-playing within a much larger network of historical movements, including the value of ‘art, craft and nostalgic pastness’ (p. 198). It is a pity that she speaks of a few players ‘escaping’ teaching, as if teaching were a sign of failure, as opposed to a valuable practice that nurtures, and is nurtured by, high-level performance (p. 185). Still, she persuasively argues that working-class violinists ‘sought a share in intellectual and artistic treasures and […] took the initiative to achieve them’ (p. 190). This identification of an area in which finance was pressed into service of the ideal is both inspiring and revelatory.
David Gramit, who has long been concerned with issues of commerce and art, focuses in ‘The Business of Music on the Peripheries of Empire: A Turn-of-the-Century Case Study’, (The Idea of Art Music, 274–96) on a different setting: turn-of-the-century Edmonton in western Canada. The functional, commerce-driven nature of new cities like Edmonton makes them revealing, if challenging, settings for tracing the emergence of art-music ideas. Gramit identifies the numbers of musicians, music teachers and music businesses such as piano dealers and gramophone shops, analysing his findings for trends in gender and professions. Like Bashford's, his wide-cast net includes music education (which was associated with piano, violin and voice, rather than the popular brass bands). The emergence of an idea of art music can be identified, he suggests, in the kinds of instruments which are sold, and the gradual construction of a sophisticated metropolitan environment. But Gramit puts his finger on the methodological gulf that the book is attempting to bridge when he writes that ‘musicologists are accustomed to seeking out and prizing the unique […] but the business of building music in the new cities of the west(s) constitutes an enormous worldwide phenomenon in which the imported and derivative played a role that, to its practitioners, was very far from ordinary’ (p. 296; emphases added).
The derivative, or at least the repetitive, also plays an important role in Marie Sumner Lott's essay in Consuming Music on a modestly sized middle-class male market for string chamber music (‘Musical Style as Commercial Strategy in Romantic Chamber Music’, 127–53). Sumner Lott's work on nineteenth-century chamber music has transformed the way in which I encounter musically ‘unadventurous’ scores.Footnote 6 Almost uniquely across both collections, Sumner relates her historical observations on commercial forces to detailed compositional decisions, justified by the need for technical accessibility, and the value placed on musical collegiality. Performance – specifically the fundamental experience of making music oneself – is explicitly embedded in this chapter. Sumner Lott concludes strongly that ‘one of the reasons the nineteenth century is held up as a sort of golden age of musical engagement, when a variety of new institutions were established for amateur and professional musicians and thriving audiences seemed to flourish for them all, is that composers […] wrote recreational music to engage those audiences’ (p. 151). This detailed scrutiny of actual notation might have helped bring Jon Solomon's discussion of ancient Greek music in the USA from 1875 to 1938 (‘Read All About It! Ancient Greek Music Hits American Newspapers, 1875–1938’, The Idea of Art Music, 202–22) and Montemorra Marvin's discussion of the marketing of Verdi's Don Carlos and Aida in Victorian London more fully to life. Both offer rich historical detail, but without full consideration of the actual musical scores or performances involved. Montemorra Marvin notes the transferability of operatic repertory across nations via translations, and genres via arrangements, but I wanted to know whether she believed that a potpourri of favourite Verdi tunes translated into English and arranged for the simplest possible accompaniment was still part of an ‘art-music’ ideal. The excerpt or arrangement may well be a mnemonic for the whole work, but it might also replace it or reduce it in complex ways. For many people, the opening gesture of Beethoven's Fifth Symphony is Beethoven, but is Walter Murphy's 1976 disco hit A Fifth of Beethoven, based on that iconic motif, Beethoven? Probably not.
Advertising and marketing
A common theme across both collections is advertising and marketing strategies. However, understandably, ideas of art music retreat into the background in these discussions. The marches and dances discussed in Denise Gallo's essay in The Idea of Art Music on marketing arrangements of Rossini's military marches (‘Selling “Celebrity”: The Role of the Dedication in Marketing Piano Arrangements of Rossini's Military Marches’, 18–38) were purely for consumption (Gallo herself reminds us that they already fit Christensen's description of ‘bourgeois banality’; p. 18), not music of ideas. Rossini himself is largely distanced from the processes Gallo describes, although his name was a powerful commercial draw, especially in association with aristocratic dedicatees. The essay should stimulate more exploration of how the idea of a musical work is transformed through repackaging, for example as a drawing-room arrangement. There are also performance-practice questions, such as, how do we know that pianists played all of the sections of a march ‘in the score as directed, from beginning to end’ (p. 26)?
Jann Pasler's chapter in The Idea of Art Music on musical scores in belle-époque France journalism (‘“Disguised Publicity” and the Performativity of Taste: Musical Scores in French Magazines and Newspapers in the Belle Époque’, 297–325) surveys a huge data set covering roughly half a century. Focusing on print technology, Pasler argues that a score published in a magazine can be read as a dynamic indicator of shifting tastes (p. 298). Most interestingly, she challenges received ideas about how taste is attached to class, arguing that a range of repertories was marketed to a wide band of social classes. Her findings also show that the journals showcased many female composers and earlier French music, alongside amateur entertainment pieces like dances by Chopin and Schubert. In addition, her work indicates a special role for song, which could migrate easily between classes and ‘engage in the kind of cultural work republicans expected music to accomplish’ (p. 305). In this sense, she is more concerned with ideas of political identity than art music.
Also within The Idea of Art Music, Catherine Hennessy Wolter's entertaining comparison of the advertising of conventional and mechanical pianos in early twentieth-century USA (‘“What The Piano[la] Means to the Home”: Advertising of Conventional and Player Pianos in the Saturday Evening Post and Ladies’ Home Journal, 1914 –17’, 152–77) explores the art–commerce nexus more deeply, with sidelights on gender, display, learning and performance. Wolter shows that through canny marketing, the performances on a mechanical piano of ‘good music’ could be regarded as superior to live performance of third-rate domestic music, thus challenging the automatic valorization of live performance. Wolter's study focuses on technically undemanding and repetitive songs and dances. Still, her nuanced account of how gender and generational identities were shaped by the male editors of the Ladies’ Home Journal and the Saturday Evening Post is truly illuminating. She identifies a wide range of possibilities with which women consumers could identify, from the conservative to the progressive, despite the presence of numerous images of slender, young, picturesque females, the likes of whom are still used to sell virtually everything from chocolates to cars. She also shows how male consumers were wooed by the technology of mechanical pianos. The chapter includes wonderful illustrations from these early advertisements – men as page-turners, gazers, voyeurs of virtuous/alluring femininity. The art-music idea resurfaces when Wolter discusses the pedagogy of the player piano, showing how ‘artistic, pedal-driven performances’ could create an aesthetic, idealized goal in the musical experience (p. 170). This shows how advertising could promise that the purchaser of the player piano could become ‘in a way an artist’. The conventional piano is dismissed as ‘silent’, a dismal echo of the vanishing of actual sheet music from the same magazines that Wolter studies.
Publishers
Nearly a quarter of the essays in both books reveal the considerable power of the music publisher/dealer. Here, too, ideas of art music remain remote; the question of why a publisher favoured one work over another is not part of the aims and methodologies of these authors, even though publishers were chief taste-makers. A useful backdrop is provided by Green's essay on eighteenth-century publishers (‘Music's First Consumers: Publishers in the Late Eighteenth Century’, Consuming Music, 13–28), which reveals their multifarious roles: they made and sold physical scores; acted as go-betweens for other publishers and the consuming public; were active patrons who shaped the products subsequently sold; and were often also conspicuous consumers. The theme is eloquently elaborated in Rupert Ridgewell's fascinating contribution to the same volume on the publisher Artaria in 1784 (‘Inside a Viennese Kunsthandlung: Artaria in 1784’, 29–61). Ridgewell shows that music was only one commodity within Artaria's diverse portfolio of cultural goods, including books, maps, engravings and diverse other outward expressions of cultivation across the sciences and arts, united by engraving technology. The chapter is an excellent reminder that from the perspective of the consumer, music is one item on a menu of cultural consumption.
Ideas of art music are also peripheral to Michaela Ronzani's otherwise excellent essay in The Idea of Art Music on the innovative publicity campaign for Puccini's La bohème (‘Creating Successes and Forming Imaginaries: The Innovative Publicity Campaign for Puccini's La bohème’, 39–59), despite her aim to include the ‘views of the Italian intellectuals of the day towards the campaign’ (p. 41; this is condensed in the closing paragraph). Ronzani details the publisher Ricordi's superb commercial strategy, but it is not clear how this contributed to the ‘distinction between elite art and popular entertainment’ (p. 43) – Ricordi's fearless exploitation of innovative printing and design technology was surely commerce-driven. And the question which might have illuminated the art-music ideal remains unanswered: why did Ricordi lavish this much attention on La bohème and not on the works of Puccini's contemporary Alfredo Catalani, whose disgruntled quotation from 1892 about the ‘comedy’ of publicity opens the chapter? Would Catalani's position in the opera canon have been different if Ricordi had decided to treat him similarly?
Ideas of art music also play a minor part in David Wright's essay in the same volume on the publisher Novello and the British amateur market (‘Novello, John Stainer and Commercial Opportunities in the Nineteenth-Century British Amateur Music Market’, 60–84). Like Ricordi, ‘Novello's […] decisions were strongly determined by the commercial realities of the markets it supplied’ (p. 61). Indeed, Wright's case study on Stainer's deathless oratorio The Crucifixion implies that the idea of art music was downright incompatible with commercial success – certainly the strongly adverse opinions about its musical quality (‘squalid’, ‘banal’) have not hampered its fortunes (my own church choir regularly sings it). The fact that serious orchestral music earned less money than amateur choral repertoire meant that composers were disinclined to write any – Stainer himself is a good example (p. 64). In short, the idea of art music is present here only in its inverse.
Within Consuming Music, Patrick Wood Uribe (‘Exchanging Ideas in a Changing World: Adolph Bernhard Marx and the Berliner allgemeine musikalische Zeitung in 1824’, 205–21) explores the relationship between publishers and the music journalism they financed, thereby making a clear link between aesthetic ideas and those who pay to propagate them. Uribe explores the conflict between the ostensible aim of criticism – to educate and inform the public and guide its taste – and its tacit one, namely the marketing and promotion of new scores. But more intriguingly, his chosen example, the Berliner allgemeine musikalische Zeitung founded in 1824, dedicated many articles to asking such questions as: what are the standards to which new works are held? How do we evaluate what is genuinely new, since it is necessarily unlike what we already know? What actual purpose is served by reviews and by criticism in general? What is a journal supposed to do for its public? – revealing a degree of criticality characteristic of its age, but rarely encountered in musical criticism today (p. 206). The questions Uribe does not answer are as important as those he does: for example, who was the intended readership (the elusive consumer)? His example is Adolph Bernhard Marx, a ‘tireless and enthusiastic champion of Beethoven’ and therefore a primary shaper of the dominant musical legacy of the following decades (p. 207). Uribe takes a panoramic look at Marx's critical writings, exploring how his idealism and commercial interests blended, and how he constructed a community of engaged readers, encouraging debate and exchange. Although Uribe does not explicitly state this, Marx's work is surely a model in print of Berlin's thriving salon culture.
Peripheries
Some of the topics, particularly in Consuming Music, would benefit from further exploration or contextualization; since they are so specialized, it is difficult to know what they tell us about wider musical-commercial forces (this is a criticism of methodology, above all). Steven Zohn's chapter in Consuming Music on the serial publication of Telemann's Der getreue Music-Meister (The Faithful Music Master) (‘Morality and the “Fair-Sexing” of Telemann's Faithful Music Master’, 65–101) deals with one of the earliest publishing phenomena. Probably in imitation of moral literary publications with a specifically female target, this bi-weekly 25-issue publication from 1728 to 1729 collected musical material for all genres and levels, combining didactic aims with diversion, and incorporating an interactive element (how modern that sounds). He does not touch on the question of performance, but music intended to be consumed was often deliberately written to be enjoyable to perform, and it would have been played in ways that fed early concert practices. For example, the creation of miscellaneous musical collections in the mid-eighteenth century was surely related to miscellaneous concert programmes into the twentieth. Zohn admits that many questions remain open about how consumers used Telemann's contrapuntal exercises: were the buyers mainly musicians? Or did this serial reach the general public, many of whom would not have been able to complete the exercises? The gendered aspect of Zohn's reading is more problematic, particularly if we accept his suggestion that many readers might have been male (p. 76).
Roger Mathew Grant's exploration of how metre, tempo and affect were presented in books about music (‘Eighteenth-Century Mediations of Music Theory: Meter, Tempo, and Affect in Print’, Consuming Music, 102–25) is potentially interesting, but without some knowledge of who was reading them, we cannot evaluate the significance of the chosen examples by Charles Antoine Vion and Johann Philipp Kirnberger. Grant concedes that these examples are only a small part of the communication with the reader about metre, tempo and affect, and rightly implies that the isolated printed text is a very inadequate means of communication, even if the intention is to mediate ‘between the world of aesthetic theory and the world of performance’ (p. 112). Grant's second section, on what the printed examples tell us about ‘these books’ imagined consumers’, is rather an exploration of how the authors confronted the unknowable aspects of their intended readership. Information on sales figures or geographical reach would put this into perspective. Comparable questions are raised by Mayes's chapter on the contredanse hongroise in Vienna (‘In Vienna “Only Waltzes Get Printed”: The Decline and Transformation of the Contredanse hongroise in the Early Nineteenth Century’, 154–75). There are historiographical risks associated with a niche area, a small body of evidence and a narrow timespan.
Conclusion
Ultimately, both collections achieve their aims only partially. Green and Mayes's goal of providing ‘a more thorough framework within which to understand the activity and proliferation of musical consumption during the century spanning approximately the years 1730–1830’ (‘Introduction’, Consuming Music, 3) is really only addressed in the first chapter. Given the number of specialized topics and the methodological range in the collection, a ‘taxonomy of consumers’ cannot emerge. The highlighting of ‘an interesting impulse towards the mundane’ sidesteps canonical composers and works (ibid., 5), which is welcome on historiographical grounds, but perpetuates the illusion that composers like Mozart or Mendelssohn were not part of these processes; it does not explain, for example, why Haydn and Kozeluch shared top billing in Artaria's publishing records, and why F. X. Rieger's piano sonatas sold so well but are now forgotten (Ridgewell, ‘Inside a Viennese Kunsthandlung’, 39). Lesser questions concern the near invisible role of hand-copied scores, especially if it is true, as Christian Gottfried Thomas claimed in Leipzig in 1778, that everyone ‘preferred handwritten music’; also, if printed music and other material objects like books were a ‘scarce, luxury item’ in the 1770s purchased in tiny numbers, then what can we really infer about ‘ordinary’ consumers (Green, ‘Music's First Consumers’, 16)? These questions serve only to make the point that we need a greater awareness of how music is marketed, packaged and endorsed.
Both these collections forge links in the complex, multidimensional mesh which binds works to the world, but all privilege a commercial perspective. Consequently, the idea of art often recedes; discussion of musical genres which were not composed primarily for financial gain but acquired such associations, or vice versa, are lacking. One senses that other art forms or commodities could be substituted in many of these discussions. Most of these essays treat sheet music, advertising, instruments or artists as phenomena through which to examine wider social questions; but some achieve an admirable balance between the aesthetic and the commodified nature of musical works in their consumers’ and producers’ minds. Bashford captures this best in her use of the word ‘artisanship’, which is more generous than either ‘art’ or ‘commerce’, and acknowledges key qualities of both.
