No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2005
In this welcome addition to the literature addressing the tension between what he calls “the domain of Islam” and the West, especially the United States, Amin Saikal attempts to answer three essential questions. “What has gone wrong in both historical and contemporary terms? To what extent do Muslims bear responsibility and in what ways has Western, and more specifically US, policy behavior contributed to diluting the relations between the two sided? What is the way forward to repair the damage by building the necessary bridges of understanding and promoting a more peaceful coexistence between the two entities, as an important foundation for generating a lasting, stable and equitable world order?” (pp. 2–3).
The book contains five chapters and a conclusion. In addition to events of 11 September 2001 and its repercussions, the author highlights in the first chapter the wrong assumption in the West regarding the genesis of terrorism: that poverty, lack of education, and social deprivation are the roots of violence and terrorism. The profile of the perpetrators of the deadliest events on American soil presented a strong alternative assumption, the author argues. The “combination of religious extremism, wealth and political causes” has proved to be more lethal, but it received no adequate attention prior to 11 September (p. 8). The profile of a terrorist presents a wealthy and well-educated man who can fly a commercial plane.
According to Saikal, another misguided attitude that the U.S. government embraced concerned the type of regimes in the world. It did not matter whether a given government was democratic or oppressive, or what type of human-rights record it has had, “as long as it was prepared to side with the USA in its hour of need” (p. 11).
In the second chapter, the author focuses on the concept of coexistence between Islam and Christianity as an alternative to theories focusing on the “clash of civilization.” He presents the history of peaceful and positive relations Muslims and Christians enjoyed for centuries. These relations, he maintains, were altered by Western colonization of Arab and Muslim lands. This invasion was met by movements of Islamic revival and secular nationalism. However, Saikal correctly notes that hostility toward the West “had more political and nationalist than religious bases” (p. 40).
The third chapter highlights American involvement in the Middle East, which helped the latter in its struggle against European hegemonic powers but soon turned into a challenge. The Middle East was caught in the crossfire of the Cold War, the author argues, and had to befriend “either Godless Soviet socialism or American anti-Soviet benevolent hegemonism” (p. 42). The U.S. attitude, he notes, was clear-cut: it was not important what kind of a regime existed in any given country; Washington “embraced it as long as it was anti-communist and sided with the USA” (p. 49).
The fourth chapter provides the “great issues” through case studies of the most important countries in the Middle East, where events helped shape the relationship between the Muslim world and the West. Saikal surveys the recent history of the years leading to the Iranian Revolution and the experience of the Islamic Republic (during and after the leadership of Ayatollah Khomeini), the Palestinian problem, and Afghanistan. While Iraq was mentioned in more than one chapter, this part of the book could certainly have been more helpful if Saikal had discussed the Iraqi problem fully here. The main theme in this chapter is the failure of U.S. foreign policy, which often sides with the wrong allies or fails to acquire the mere appearance of impartiality, to say the least. At certain times, the United States helped create and nurture its own enemies in the process of trying to score some short-term victories in the context of the Cold War, as happened in Afghanistan.
In the fifth chapter and the conclusion, Saikal presents a theoretical discourse on Islam and democracy and the democratization trends in certain countries, such as Iran, Algeria, and Egypt. He argues that “it is possible to achieve liberty—in terms of lessening the state's grip over society—without first having Western-type democratic institutions in place. However, the achievement of liberty could well open the way for democracy” (p. 128). In terms of how to proceed, Saikal highlights the problem of the U.S.-led war on terror. “The USA and its allies,” he notes, “have primarily focused on symptoms of terrorism rather than its root causes” (p. 129). He suggests that the best way out of the current tensions is returning to the era of coexistence rather than fostering the belief in an impending “clash of civilizations.”
The author provides an elaborate and very useful bibliography, which would have been even more valuable if it contained any literature in Middle Eastern languages. With only one book in Persian and a handful of works translated into English, the presentation of the Muslim argument is essentially either the author's own or secondhand reporting. Nevertheless, the book remains an excellent contribution to the field. It provides important literature for academics, policymakers, and the general audience in both the West and the Muslim world.