The history of Egyptian feminism is well-trodden territory. Nonetheless, a study that treats the class differences between Egyptian women as central to the formation of a diverse, vibrant, and differentiated Egyptian feminist politics has been long overdue. The recent publication of Cathlyn Marriscotti's work, Gender and Class in the Egyptian Women's Movement, is a welcome rejoinder to a body of scholarship that has perhaps been too quick to assume the congruity of interests between the elite and middle-class women who shaped Egyptian feminism in the interwar period.
Marriscotti argues that elite harem women like Huda Shaʿrawi created a concept of womanhood that reflected both their own interests and an emerging nationalist cultural ideal. This ideal privileged the social and philanthropic roles they felt women should play in the public realm but eschewed a model of feminism advocating broader political and professional roles for women. Although such a model of womanhood may have offered new roles for elite women, it was not necessarily progressive for “managerial-class” women, who sought a feminism more in line with their own class position and political interests. Elite and managerial-class feminists cooperated and competed to define the appropriate sphere of Egyptian feminist activism, a process that was indelibly shaped by the politics and culture of Egypt in the late 1920s and early 1930s. This struggle ultimately led managerial women to ally themselves with extraparliamentary forces like the Muslim Brotherhood to champion anti-Wafdist political positions against the more “cultural” feminist activities of elite women. For their part, elite women during this period increasingly turned their attention away from Egyptian nationalist politics in favor of participation in a growing international women's peace movement.
By its author's admission, this work does not seek to exploit new historical source material or data, relying primarily on the Egyptian women's journals already extensively used by Beth Baron, Margot Badran, and Marilyn Booth. Instead, Marriscotti seeks to “produce a historical argument, a framework within which to examine the complexities of ruling and managerial class Egyptian women's struggles over issues crucial to women during this period in Egyptian history” (p. 18). It largely achieves what it sets out to do. The reader of Marriscotti's study will see some familiar feminist faces—Huda Shaʿrawi, Nabawiyya Musa, Labiba Ahmad and Munira Thabit—and be treated to some new insights about how their class positions shaped their engagements with the social and political worlds of interwar Egypt.
The great strength of this work lies in its attempts to show the ways in which middle-class, professional women both complied with and resisted the hegemony of elite Egyptian women's feminism. Professional women colluded with elite women to gain support for their own endeavors, even as elite ideals of domesticity and motherhood worked against middle-class women's desires to transcend this domestic role. As one illustration of this, Marriscotti includes an interesting discussion of the ways in which professional women engaged in a process of self-fashioning, trying to carve out professional identities for themselves in their journals, a subject that could have been a chapter in and of itself.
Despite the many virtues of Marriscotti's work, there are a few places in which it falls short of its aspirations. Marriscotti presents a more complicated, differentiated view of relations between elite and middle-class feminists but largely leaves working-class women out. This does not necessarily have to be counted as a shortcoming—providing a more nuanced view of Egyptian feminism by looking at how the interests, activities, and political positions of elite and middle-class professional women differed is a significant contribution—but she does suggest in the initial chapters that she will trace the ways in which middle-class women formed alliances with working-class women against elite feminist positions. The book fails to deliver on this promise. Part of the problem may be with the slippage between the terms “managerial class” and “lower class.” Marriscotti sometimes refers to middle-class professional women as “the lower classes” (in relation to elite women), and at other times this term seems to encompass all Egyptian women who do not belong to the elite upper classes. More conceptual precision and clarification would have been welcome here.
The weakest part of the book is not the actual historical material but the initial chapters in which Marriscotti lays out her critique of the existing literature on Egyptian women. Marriscotti claims to be intervening in “dominant paradigms,” but the works with which she most engages are a decade old or more. Although her point that the majority of works in Egyptian women's history have focused largely on elite discourses without attending to the diversity of perspectives that made Egyptian feminism so dynamic is valid, her explanations for why this is the case are not especially clear. Marriscotti suggests in some places that “a lack of theory” in Egyptian women's history has led to a prevalence of neo-Orientalist paradigms. In other places she suggests that a surfeit of “poststructuralist” (interchangeable in her critique with postcolonial and postmodern) theory is to blame for analyses of the Egyptian feminist movement that do not account for class differences. This is a surprising explanation given that some of the most recent work dealing with the construction of Egyptian womanhood (if not feminism directly) using the tools of postcolonial and poststructural theory are absent from her bibliography. (Lila Abu-Lughod's edited collection, Remaking Women, which is heavily focused on Egypt, and Lisa Pollard's book Nurturing the Nation are two important cases in point.) It is a bit unfair to critique the approaches of other scholars without engaging their work or to summarize an entire field's shortcomings based mostly on works written years ago.
Despite its weaknesses, Marriscotti's book is a long-awaited contribution to an ever-rich and growing field. It is a useful and powerful reminder not to rely on a simple cooptation/resistance binary when analyzing the complicated struggles between Egyptian women to define appropriate womanhood and feminist practice. It will be required reading for anyone who works on gender politics in interwar Egypt.
