The Work of Politics is an incredibly rich book theoretically. Steven Klein's analysis of the welfare state through the lens of towering intellectual figures in the European tradition, such as Habermas, Arendt, and Weber, is a valuable task in itself, independent of the value of the book's particular conclusions, which are also important.
The book offers a little-explored and welcome approach to understanding the role of welfare state politics and welfare state bureaucracies in shaping democracy. The main idea that Klein puts forward is that welfare state institutions can offer lively and robust loci for democratic participation and contestation. They are not necessarily cold, rational calculation machines invariably associated with distributive measures and policies. The book's purpose is to dispel the well-entrenched assumption—primarily based on the work of Max Weber on bureaucracy—that the welfare state is the opposite of spontaneous, justice-driven political activism. In so doing, Klein shows with unmatched mastery of social theory and philosophy in the Continental tradition that the political is not confined to traditionally deliberative arenas, but also lives in the distributive and economic institutions of social democracy. The welfare state is a mechanism of collective empowerment, not a passive semiauthoritarian monster.
Klein resorts to interesting historical examples that can illustrate this idea: the development of the Bismarck welfare state and the rise of the Swedish welfare state after World War II constitute two “case studies” that show how politically transformative popular struggles for social democracy can turn out to be. Here, one may still wonder whether Klein's main argument about the democratic potential of the welfare state still holds for already long-lasting institutions. Does Medicare offer a welcome opportunity for political participation? It seems to me that his claims apply better to social movements demanding the institutionalization of welfare state policies. We know that social movements offer wonderful opportunities for political activism and participation. For long-standing and well-established welfare state institutions, it may be the case that the Weberian analysis fits better than it does for social movements demanding social democracy.
Be that as it may, the book adds a worthy piece to the puzzle of understanding how democratic norms and the democratic ethos (for want of a better term) emerge and crystallize in society. Klein provocatively suggests that we can understand the role of welfare state politics in light of Hanna Arendt's and Jürgen Habermas's thinking on transformative political action. At the same time, the book offers a helpful critical assessment of three main approaches to understanding domination in the social theory / political philosophy literature. These are the neorepublican approach, the neo-Kantian approach, and the structural approach. Klein carefully points to the deficiencies and advantages of each to later tell us that his view on welfare state political action successfully addresses these three forms of power dynamics and supersedes all of them.
Klein allows us to see that these mainstream accounts of domination are characterized by a narrow understanding of democratic agency. The neorepublican view focuses only on interpersonal power relations, but this is insufficient since domination can happen also between people and institutions or rules. The neo-Kantian view emphasizes only domination that results from lack of social recognition as a worthy and dignified person, but this understanding is incomplete since it relies on the idea that all members of society will have the heuristic tools they need to demand that they be treated as rational agents. The structural approach, echoing Marx's views on the dominating role of capitalism as a regime, relies on the idea that social structures and hierarchies—such as the market—limit the range of choices we can make as free agents regardless of how confident we are about what we deserve and regardless of the fact that nobody may be forcing us to do anything in particular. Klein's analysis incorporates the positive dimensions of all these views.
The book is so abundant in theoretical analysis that at times one can feel lost in the work of interpretation. However, once the analysis is done, the outcome proves to be original and pathbreaking. Institutions of social democracy and the welfare state are not inert vehicles of mere redistribution but fertile terrain for nondominating participatory activity. One question that would be appropriate to ask at this point is whether Klein sees democracy as an instrument to satisfy the demands of social justice or whether he thinks that political participation is valuable in its own right. Is participation valuable on both grounds, perhaps? This question is important—although the book never promises to answer it. Klein's position is unclear to me, if only because the argument seems to be heavily tilted towards the notion that democratic participation is the culmination of complete autonomy. This is a valuable argument, but I think that participation is important also because through it we gain access to social justice.
Overall, the book is unparalleled in its analytical sophistication, and its arguments are well worthy of recognition for anyone committed to a society of equals politically and economically.
