On 27 September 2005 seven unions with six million members formed The Change to Win Federation (CTW). This massive defection from the AFL-CIO represented the second significant reorientation in organized labor and the first structural realignment in 50 years. With a penetrating critique of the establishment's problems, bold leadership, and substantial resources, the dissidents inspired fresh hopes for the labor movement. Such ambitions have been realized in new sensibilities and new priorities. However, the success of CTW is ultimately limited by its insufficient commitment to the real basis of “workers' power,” which is “deep” organization that gives rise to leadership from the rank and file. Unions must cultivate internal democracy, grounded in relationships among rank and filers on the shop floor and informed by open debate that can shape a broader vision. To the extent that labor leaders grasp this insight—and there is a lot of activism informed by it—there are hopeful possibilities for labor's fortunes. By the same token, to the extent that unionists do not understand it, U.S. labor's marginalization will persist. At the moment, there is a lot more “trouble” than “transition.” Neither the old top-down business unionism of the AFL-CIO establishment—despite all the expectations of the regime change in 1995—nor the new “bureaucratic corporate unionism” of the CTW—notwithstanding its significant accomplishments—promotes union democracy. This is the punch line of Kim Moody's most recent assessment.
To arrive at these conclusions, he evaluates broad and detailed evidence related to the circumstances and choices facing labor. Neither the decline of industry nor global competition really explains labor's predicament. The more important factors involve a conjuncture of technological displacement and geographic shifts of labor and capital within the United States and the failure of unions to respond to these changes. While large forces have worked against workers' interests, the destiny of organized labor is far from inevitable. The AFL-CIO cannot be held responsible for the world-wide recession of 1974/75, but it did play an active role in labor's historic retreat in 1980/81. Since then, even after 1995, union officialdom has failed in the two main goals it set for itself, organization and political action. Meager organizing efforts, fewer National Labor Relations Board elections, too much emphasis on mergers, and antidemocratic culture all reflect unsuccessful organization. The main political strategy of influencing the Democratic Party has yielded little as well. Labor has for the most part been incapable of producing candidates or policies that serve its interests.
Since 2005 the CTW has generated energy and ideas that appear promising. Focusing on strategic efforts in “core” industries with aggressive multi-union drives and “large, national organizing targets,” CTW appears poised for substantive success. However, Moody raises questions about its long-term efficacy. Most importantly, the centralized, corporate structure of the federation will not generate an enduring culture of engagement among its members, which is to say it will likely not hold together enough to push beyond modest expectations in class struggle.
The most important quality of this book is the multi-faceted approach Moody brings to the subject. The bird's eye view of the political economist provides context, delineating the contours of power over time. The diligent observations of the journalist generate an exhaustive inventory of labor struggles across the country in recent decades. And critical perspective on how things work on the ground is brought by the engaged activist. While the scope of the narrative is expansive, the data formidable, and the insider's take (especially on factional and leadership struggles) fascinating, it is the combination that is most compelling.
This book is written from the perspective of, about, and for persons actively involved in the labor movement. It will be of interest to many others, though, for several reasons. The real argument here is that the American economy is failing its citizens and the main institutional apparatus for responding to that problem (i.e., labor organization) is too. As familiar and bleak as this is, Moody is persuasive in suggesting that it is not inevitable or permanent. Against the odds, there are signs of vitality: the successful 1997 Teamster strike on UPS; the 2002/03 International Longshoremen and Warehouse Union contract fight; the 2003 southern California grocery strike supported by the United Food and Commercial Workers; the 2005 strike of the Transport Workers Union in New York City; the victory of the Coalition of Immokalee Workers over Taco Bell and its corporate parent, Yum!, in 2005; the protest of some five million participants in the “Day Without Immigrants” in 2006; and many other smaller cases. Moreover, it is the sense of historical contingency conveyed here that reveals the fluidity of what may happen in the future.
There is, of course, much more Moody could say about other actors (government, employers, religious groups, social movement organizations, the media, etc.) and issues (environmental challenges, identity politics, international trade, etc.) related to the fortunes of labor. At times the narrative seems disjointed, shifting from economic indicators that shape the relative leverage in class struggle, to the history of factional conflict among leaders, to narratives about specific strikes. Given the scope and complexity of Moody's project, however, the particular focus on unions and a bit of disorder are both understandable.
A more serious shortcoming involves the question of organizational efficacy. The value of union democracy is extolled here, but the risks of decentralized governance—lack of operational coordination and sustained vision—warrant more attention. If the main “promise” for labor is “revival from below,” then why the rank and file is not more militant is also worth considering.
Overall, the book's strengths far outweigh its weaknesses. This extraordinary book is at once sobering and hopeful. It shows that labor's troubles have broad implications, and that the possibilities for reform are real.
