Eighteen-year-old Angela has been an inpatient at a German university-affiliated hospital for more than two months. Initially she was referred from a psychiatric clinic for long-term patients, where she had stayed eight months without showing any improvement. She suffers from severe anorexia, with a BMI around 10 kg/m2 (weight fluctuating between 21 and 24 kg), depression, and obsessive compulsive disorder. Although her body has adapted to the low weight, such that her life is not acutely threatened, her condition, nevertheless, is serious. Angela’s history of anorexia began when she was 11 years old. Since then she has spent most of her time in clinics in various countries, where different therapeutic programs, including forced-feeding, have been tried. Despite her high intelligence, she had to leave school at the eleventh grade because of her illness. She lacks friends and any hobbies. Her father is an influential lawyer, and her mother left work in order to take care of her daughter. They are very caring parents and are actively involved in seeking her recovery.
Angela has a manipulative character and is clever at saying different things to different people. However, she has repeatedly stated that she does not want to continue treatment, that she wishes for a palliative approach in which people would leave her alone, even if that means she might die. She says she has no plans or aspirations for her life. She has been aggressively resisting treatment, has failed to comply with agreed-on procedures, and has been duplicitous with the team.
The clinical team discussed a new attempt of forced-feeding, but the physicians at the intensive care unit are reluctant on the grounds that sedation and forced immobilization might severely harm her in her weakened condition. Two psychiatrists attest to her ability to consent. But other members of the team, especially the nurses and a nutritionist, who are very much involved with the patient, doubt her ability to consent, because of psychiatric illness, the side effects of drugs, and the disturbing effect of the eating disorder on her freedom of choice. Her parents are vehemently against a palliative approach. They are persuaded that Angela’s compliance will increase only if she gains weight, even if that requires forced-feeding.
In a round table meeting (which included an ethicist and a hospital lawyer), the proposed further attempt at forced-feeding was discussed. All the members of the ward, including the treating team and other patients, are extremely stressed by Angela’s impact on them. What are the best treatment options in this situation? Is a palliative approach viable, or would a more aggressive plan be beneficial?
