This book wastes no time making its central point. Allegations that phantom voters cast ballots in US elections are nothing more than conservative-inspired innuendo. And those who spread these rumors aim to suppress voter turnout, especially by poorer and minority citizens. The Myth of Voter Fraud, in other words, is a polemic, though one that collects and analyzes important materials.
Conservatives like the Wall Street Journal columnist John Fund in his book Stealing Elections (2004, 2008, 2d ed.) and members of the Republican Party become the target of Lorraine Minnite's investigations. The author criticizes them for inventing a problem—voter fraud—where none really exists. That an illegal immigrant would seek to impersonate a citizen is implausible; illegals prefer to remain unnoticed so that they can labor in peace. Intentionally deceiving election authorities, as Minnite notes, is even more costly than the much simpler act of voting.
Minnite marshals an array of evidence—from the study of these allegations in the 2004 federal election cycle and 12 state elections—to demonstrate that the number of cases is so small as to be nonexistent. And nowhere have such ballots been responsible for a candidate's victory; that is, none have turned a slim majority against into a slim majority in favor of a candidate (a point that she does not explore but that is an implication of her key findings). Voter fraud is a myth, as the title of the book declares.
The analysis of these allegations is the most valuable part of this book. Minnite analyzes allegations of voter fraud in the 2004 election cycle, which she compares to proven cases of fraudulent votes, data originally collected by the American Center for Voting Rights. She interviewed officials in Alabama, California, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Minnesota, Mississippi, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Texas, and Wisconsin. She obtained allegations of voter fraud—as well as on other acts of electoral fraud—from these states. The detailed analysis of these allegations accounts for most of the 158 pages of her book, which she usefully deposits in 100 hundred pages of appendices. However one judges Minnite's analysis, their presentation is a service that other researchers, whether partisan or scholarly in orientation, should thank her for providing.
Minnite reminds us that conservatives have three reasons for fanning the flames of voter fraud hysteria. First, it discourages lower-income voters from going to the polls. If voters fear that their credentials could be challenged on election day, as poll watchers are empowered to do in many states, citizens might very well be deterred from casting ballots. Second, complaining about voter fraud justifies the creation of even more legal obstacles to voter registration. Citizens, the author avers, should be able to register and vote on the same day. Third, exaggerating vote fraud shifts attention from reforming the cumbersome electoral machinery that exists in much of the country, from the way ballots are printed to the way they are tallied and scrutinized in this country.
It is not hard to see why voter fraud has become a concern on the right. These allegations have allowed conservatives to generate some fear about voter fraud—and to establish legislative and administrative remedies to reduce it. As Minnite would argue, no doubt this is time best spent facilitating turnout. If conservatives are trying to reduce turnout because lower-income voters are more likely to vote Democratic, then it is not hard to understand why the myth of voter fraud persists.
How successful are these efforts? Minnite really does not address this question. Republicans had to accept the 1993 National Voter Registration Act (“the motor voter bill”), which allows citizens to register to vote when getting a driver's license. That Republicans have spent so much time at the state level to enact legislation requiring voters to present photographic identification before casting ballots is (indirect) evidence that the motor voter bill is successful. That George Bush managed to clutch victory in 2000 from a poorly designed ballot in Palm Beach, Florida—and against a backdrop of an electoral system that saddled poorer counties with obsolete voting systems—is evidence that erecting barriers against voter participation works. Whether the alleging of voter fraud repeatedly gives Republicans victories that they might otherwise not have obtained is a discussion that would have strengthened Minnite's polemic. Perhaps the myth of voter fraud motivates the conservative faithful but does not really explain why Republicans win plenty of elections.
From a comparative perspective, the politicization of photographic identification in US politics is, in a word, strange. While deterring turnout is antidemocratic, the requirement that voters should display photographic identification is not—at least not inherently so. International electoral best practices recommend the use of photographic identification. The federal government routinely funds foreign aid programs that advocate their use to ensure that elections are transparent in other countries. Mexicans managed to topple the long-ruling Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) in the 2000 elections by becoming convinced that their votes mattered. A key element in turning cynicism into confidence was the development of a national photographic identification system, one run by the Federal Electoral Institute (IFE), by the mid-1990s.
So why do progressives and many Democrats oppose these attempts? Why is the debate about voter identification in the United States so parochial? These are questions that Minnite does not answer, and perhaps understandably so. That the US Constitution does not guarantee the right to vote would complicate the automatic registration of citizens and the issuance of confidential identification cards. Establishing a national electoral registry would generate a hornet's nest of partisanship: Judging by the debate that health-care reform has provoked—one pivoting around the claim that mandating the purchase of health-care insurance is a violation of individual rights—it is not hard to imagine why progressives allow themselves to be put on the defensive on this issue.
Scholarly investigations, though, have no choice but to ask why the United States refuses to use a national-level electoral registry and uniform election procedures. Perhaps reflection on the reasons that the United States is such an outlier regarding a basic feature of the machinery of democratic government will identify areas for reform. Perhaps international comparisons will suggest why the obvious solution is so elusive.
