Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:52:52.833Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Equilibria and stabilities of a confined floating cylinder

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 January 2023

Wanqiu Zhang
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, PR China
Xinping Zhou*
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, PR ChinaState Key Laboratory of Digital Manufacturing Equipment and Technology, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: xpzhou08@hust.edu.cn

Abstract

A two-dimensional system with a floating cylinder confined between two parallel vertical stationary plates partially immersed in an infinite liquid bath in a downward gravity field is considered. The equilibrium states of the system are investigated using the Young–Laplace equation in two dimensions. According to the symmetry of menisci at both sides of the cylinder, the equilibrium states are classified into three types: the equilibria of fully symmetric menisci, the equilibria of partially symmetric menisci and the equilibria of asymmetric menisci. The study is then extended to investigate the stabilities of the confined cylinder with bifurcation theory. Results show that there can be at most two stable regions in the bifurcation diagram. For different plates’ contact angles, there are five representative types of bifurcation behaviours for either the case of one stable region or the case of two stable regions. In comparison with the case of an unconfined cylinder, the confinement by two hydrophobic plates with a small spacing can assist the stable interfacial floatation of the confined cylinder with a large weight.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of the capillary system of a floating cylinder confined between two parallel vertical surface-piercing plates in a downward gravity field. The cylinder with a contact angle $\theta $ is located at $({x_c}, {y_c})$. The contact angles of plate PL and plate PR are equal, denoted by $\gamma $. The distance between the two plates is denoted by D.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Different types of equilibrium states: (a,b) the equilibria of fully symmetric menisci, (c,d) the equilibria of partially symmetric menisci and (e) the equilibria of asymmetric menisci. Red solid curves represent parts of menisci symmetric to each other. Dashed curves demonstrate the equivalent equilibrium states. Physical parameters in (a-d) are the same, and are given by $\bar{D} = 3$, $\bar{r} = 0.5$, $\gamma = {\rm \pi}/3$, $\theta = {\rm \pi}/2$ and ${\bar{f}_g} = 3.714$. There is no equilibrium of asymmetric menisci for the parameters given in (a–d). Physical parameters in (e) are the same as those in (a–d) except ${\bar{f}_g} = 0.595$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Resultant vertical forces ${\bar{f}_y}$ of confined and unconfined cases for different azimuthal angles ${\alpha _2} = {\alpha _3} = \alpha $, and (b) right menisci of confined and unconfined cases for ${\bar{f}_y} = 0$ in (a). The meniscus of the unconfined case (dashed line with red circles) is in a horizontal line across the centre of the cylinder. Each of the other menisci in (b) corresponds to the force profile in (a) with the same colour. The following parameters are given: $\bar{r} = 0.553$, ${\bar{f}_g} = 0.5$, $\theta = {\rm \pi}/2$ and $\theta = {\rm \pi}/4$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a) Weight ${\bar{f}_g}$ versus azimuthal angle $\alpha $ in the equilibria of fully symmetric menisci. The three blue circles correspond to the three equilibrium solutions for ${\bar{f}_g} = 0.99$ in McCuan & Treinen (2018). It should be noted that the dimensionless weight ${\bar{f}_g}$ is equivalent to the density ratio in McCuan & Treinen (2018). The red, orange, purple and green triangles represent four equilibrium states of ${\bar{f}_g} = 1.06$. Panel (b) shows the four equilibrium states of ${\bar{f}_g} = 1.06$. Each of the menisci (denoted by red, orange, purple or green curves, respectively) corresponds to the triangle with the same colour in (a). The following parameters are used: $\bar{D} = 8$, $\bar{r} = 3.996$, $\theta = {\rm \pi}/2$ and $\gamma = {\rm \pi}/2$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Solution curves of ${\bar{f}_g}$ versus ${\bar{x}_c}$ at the equilibria of partially symmetric menisci: (a) discontinuous distribution mode ($\gamma = 50^\circ $, 55°, 60° and 120°) and continuous distribution mode $(\gamma = 90^\circ )$, and (b) transition from the discontinuous distribution mode $(\gamma = 65^\circ )$ to the double-continuous mode ($\gamma = 66^\circ $ and 67°) and the continuous distribution mode $(\gamma = 68^\circ )$. The following parameters are used: $\bar{D}= 3$, $\bar{r} = 0.5$ and $\theta = {\rm \pi}/2$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Phase diagram of distribution modes for the equilibria of partially symmetric menisci in a parameter space $(\gamma, \bar{D})$. The continuous distribution mode, the double-continuous distribution mode, the discontinuous distribution mode and the no-distribution mode are denoted by black points, grey points, circles and triangles, respectively. The double-continuous distribution mode lies near the grey dashed curves. The following physical parameters of the cylinder are used: $\bar{r} = 0.5$ and $\theta = {\rm \pi}/2$. The distribution modes in figure 5(a,b) can be checked by letting $\bar{D}=3$ in this figure.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Solution curves of ${\bar{f}_g}$ versus ${\bar{x}_c}$ at the equilibria of asymmetric menisci. The plates’ contact angle $\gamma $ gets larger from 0 to ${\rm \pi} $ with an increment of ${\rm \pi}/18$. The curve ${\bar{f}_g} = 0.5$ (dashed blue line) is exactly the curve for $\gamma = {\rm \pi}/2$ in figure 5(a). The points on ${\bar{f}_g} = 0.5$ correspond to the equilibria of partially symmetric menisci. Symmetric about ${\bar{f}_g} = 0.5$, the equilibrium points A and A’ are on the two curves for $\gamma = 5{\rm \pi}/18$ and $\gamma = 13{\rm \pi}/18$, respectively. The following parameters are used: $\bar{D} = 3$, $\bar{r} = 0.5$ and $\theta = {{\rm \pi} /2}$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.(a) Relation of ${\bar{f}_g}$ and ${\bar{y}_c}$ at the equilibria of fully symmetric menisci. The black curves and the blue curves denote vertically stable equilibria, while the red curves denote vertically unstable equilibria. The point A denotes the state of $\alpha = {\ -\ {\rm \pi}/}2$, the point B denotes the state of $\alpha = {\rm \pi}/2$ and the point O denotes the states of the half-immersed cylinder with flat menisci. The two solution curves with plates’ contact angles supplementary to each other (such as $\gamma {\ =\ {\rm \pi}/}18$ and $\gamma {\ =\ 17{\rm \pi} /}18$) are symmetric about the point O where $({\bar{x}_c},{\bar{y}_c},{\bar{f}_g}) = (\bar{D}/2,0,0.5)$. The following parameters are used: $\bar{D} = 2$, $\bar{r} = 0.5$ and $\theta = {{\rm \pi} /2}$. (b) Phase diagram of the equilibrium solutions of fully symmetric menisci with the first and the second vertical stability regions (denoted by pentagrams) and with only the first vertical stability region (denoted by squares), in a parameter space $(\gamma ,\bar{D})$ for $\bar{r} = 0.5$ and $\theta = {{\rm \pi} /2}$. The occurrence of the second stability region for different $\gamma $ in (a) can be checked by letting $\bar{D} = 2$ in (b).

Figure 8

Figure 9.Bifurcation diagrams for $({\bar{x}_c},{\bar{y}_c})$ versus ${\bar{f}_g}$: (a–e) with only one two-dimensional stability region, and (f) with two two-dimensional stability regions. The main bifurcation behaviour in (f) is the same as in (a). The other four diagrams with two stable regions whose main bifurcation behaviour is the same as in (b–e) are not given here. Solid (dashed) curves denote that the cylinder at equilibrium is stable (unstable) in two dimensions. Black, red and green curves represent the equilibrium solutions of fully symmetric menisci, partially symmetric menisci and asymmetry menisci, respectively. The two plates’ spacing is given by: (a–e) $\bar{D} = 3$, and (f) $\bar{D} = 2$. The plates’ contact angle is given by: (a) $\gamma = 2{\rm \pi}/9$, (b) $\gamma = {\rm \pi}/3$, (c) $\gamma = {11{\rm \pi} /30}$, (d) $\gamma = {4{\rm \pi} /}9$, (e) $\gamma = {\rm \pi}/2$ and (f) $\gamma = {\rm \pi}/6$. The other parameters used in (a–f) are: $\bar{r} = 0.5$ and $\theta = {{\rm \pi} /2}$.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Equilibrium solution curves of fully symmetric menisci for $({\bar{y}_c},{\bar{f}_g})$: (a) a side view of figure 9(a), and (b) a side view of figure 9(f). Solid (dashed) curves denote that the cylinder is stable (unstable) in two dimensions. The coloured points are exactly the points with the same colour in figures 9(a) and 9(f).

Figure 10

Figure 11.Stable range of ${\bar{f}_g}$ at the equilibria of fully symmetric menisci: (a) the case with one two-dimensional stability region for $\bar{D} = 3$, and (b) the case with two two-dimensional stability regions for $\bar{D} = 2$. Black points, grey points, circles and triangles on the curves represent the four distribution modes of the equilibria of partially symmetry menisci, i.e. the continuous distribution mode, the double-continuous distribution mode, the discontinuous distribution mode and the no-distribution mode, respectively (see also figure 6b). The horizontal dashed lines ${\bar{f}_g} ={-} 2.88$ and ${\bar{f}_g} = 3.88$ represent the lower and upper stable limits of the unconfined case, respectively. The parameters are used: $\bar{r} = 0.5$ and $\theta = {{\rm \pi} /2}$.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Solution curves of the capillary equation in two dimensions (see also figures 2 and 4 in Bhatnagar & Finn (2016a), and figure 2 in Zhou & Zhang 2017): (a) solution family of c > 1, and (b) solution family of c < 1. Every meniscus in two dimensions can be viewed as part of a solution curve of the capillary equation. The dimensionless coordinates from (2.15) are used.

Figure 12

Table 1.Parameters in (2.6) and (2.18) for three types of position relation (see also table 1 in Zhou & Zhang (2017), with a slight difference). The three types of position relation (A), (B) and (C) have been introduced in Appendix A. In this table, ${\psi _c} = \arccos c$, ${d_1} = d{(1; }{\psi _I},{\psi _{II}})$ and ${d_2} = d(\textrm{cos}{\psi _m};{\psi _I},{\psi _{II}})$ in which $\textrm{cos}{\psi _m}$ is the lager one between $\textrm{cos}{\psi _I}$ and $\textrm{cos}{\psi _{II}}$. For the rule c > 1, it can be judged as follows: if $- {\rm \pi}/2 \le {\psi _I} < 0$ and $0 < {\psi _{II}} \le {\rm \pi}/2$ (or $0 < {\psi _I} \le {\rm \pi}/2$ and $- {\rm \pi}/2 \le {\psi _{II}} < 0$), there must be c > 1; otherwise, whether c > 1 can be judged by checking $0 < d < {d_1}$.