The early decades of the nineteenth century were the most innovative and downright messy years in brass history. New manufacturing techniques allowed chromatic brass instruments of wonderfully varied designs to compete for dominance across Europe and the United States, and simultaneously prompted enterprising musicians and composers to take advantage of the vastly expanded musical possibilities made possible by chromaticism. Much emphasis has been placed on the manufacturers and pedagogical innovators – Weidinger, Dauverné, Harper, Sax, Arban – with seemingly less attention paid to ensembles such as the ‘Celebrated Distin Family’ until quite recently.
The Prince Regent’s Band’s recording is partly a musical recreation of performances by members of the Distin family and partly a scholarly presentation of research of their lives and music. The liner notes, written by noted historical horn player Anneke Scott, present both sides of this proverbial coin. The Distin family, led by John Distin, included his wife and four sons (among them Henry Distin, who later would go on to found the famous musical instrument firm). They toured as a chamber brass ensemble for some two decades beginning in 1835 in Scotland. During a tour of France in 1844 – and apparently struggling to find success – they discovered Adolphe Sax’s saxhorns at a concert played by Dauverné, Arban and Dufresne. Quickly switching from slide trumpets and vented horns to the Frenchman’s latest instruments, the Distins found their niche and their ‘celebrated’ status. Scott’s liner notes present all of this information, with ample primary source quotation and in most compelling fashion.
In their musical recreation of the Distin family’s performances, the Prince Regent’s Band faced a seemingly insurmountable impediment: none of the Distin manuscripts or partbooks survive. While the members of the Prince Regent’s Band knew where the family played and approximately what they programmed, they were forced to make their own arrangements for virtually all of the tracks on this CD. Not that the Distin family’s compositions are completely lost: John Distin’s quadrilles and one polka by Henry Distin were reverse engineered for brass using published piano arrangements from the period. The bandsmen infused a bit more historical authenticity by including two of Adolphe Sax’s own brass arrangements (a quartet by Benoit Constant Fauconnier and a trio by Donizetti, ‘Ah! O sole, più ratto’). The resulting recreated arrangements are, as far as I can tell, convincingly authentic and as close to ‘the way it was’ as we will ever get without some fortuitous discovery of the lost Distin manuscripts.
The Prince Regent’s Band makes a strong and meticulous effort to document the instruments they used for the recordings, an acknowledgement of the fast-paced changes the Distin family musicians experienced in their two decades of prominence. While the newest instruments heard date to 1900, the oldest used were made by Sax and Henry Distin themselves. The noteworthy absence of slide and natural instruments from the recording indicates that the group decided to avoid the pre-1844 phase of the Distin ensemble’s development in favour of their post-1844 sound. The band’s decision is defensible, as its performers are more interested in the ‘celebrated’ part of the Distins’ history than the obscure part; however, the trade-off is that the CD as a whole has a somewhat unvaried tone, timbre and texture.
The musical performances of this CD ranges from good to excellent – a laudable achievement given the notorious difficulties of tuning and tone quality inherent to early valved instruments. The Prince Regent’s Band undoubtedly sound better than the Distin family did originally, despite some imperfect intonation. In fact if one wanted to criticize the sound at all it would be that many of the lighter arrangements of opera arias, national and patriotic songs, and folksongs actually sound too good. In other words, the players sound so good that one might sometimes mistake them as members of a modern brass ensemble playing on modern instruments. Living up to modern performance standards using flawed historical instruments is the ‘catch-22’ that many if not all period instrument recordings face at present. This reviewer does not pretend to know what constitutes historically accurate tone quality and intonation, or the extent to which recordings may present performances that sound better than the originals could have sounded. Nor do I wish to make this sound like some kind of veiled criticism of the players, since they are in fact playing so well! It is, nevertheless, difficult in some instances to distinguish between historical instruments and their modern counterparts when listening in passing to this recording. The problem in the present case is, to my mind at least, magnified by the lost historical arrangements. Brass musicians accustomed to a particular modern sound for brass quintet are almost certainly biased toward their own contemporary style in their arrangements and performances of historical music.
From a historian’s perspective, the most interesting works on the CD are those by the Distin family members themselves. These include the aforementioned quadrilles and polka by John and Henry Distin, and ‘Victory’ as well as an arrangement of ‘The Last Rose of Summer’ by Theodore Distin. At 15 minutes total these pieces constitute only a quarter of the recording – indeed the longest work is just shy of 3:30 – yet they present us with something more significant than the remaining works. While most of these tracks are themselves arrangements made by the Prince Regent’s Band members from scarce piano sheet music, the compositions are quite obscure and lay at the heart of the Distin family as musicians. Among these the cornet feature ‘Distin’s Polka’ is the most challenging technically and the most indicative of the abilities of the Distin musicians. The Prince Regent’s Band plays most ably on the Distin works, and from my perspective are the tracks that reproduce the likeliest sound of the Distins most closely. While few would accuse the Distins of writing great art music (despite all the arrangements they played in concert), these compositions are exciting and fun examples of the ‘popular’ music of the nineteenth century. These tantalizing reproductions hint at the wealth of musical materials that, like the Distins’ manuscripts, remain lost!
In conclusion, this recording presents an enormous amount of research and effort on the part of the members of the Prince Regent’s Band. Their combined efforts were not in vain; rather these musicians have brought the Distin family’s music and history back to life in a tangible and wonderful way.
