No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2005
This book is a welcome addition to demographic analysis in the Arab Gulf states of Bahrain, Kuwait, and Oman, a subject that remains underdeveloped—even neglected—in research. It is not easy to gather reliable information on these countries because they have only recently commenced data collection and census taking. As the author points out, demographic data in the Gulf countries is “either incomplete, irregular or full of gaps, and can rarely be checked for accuracy” (p. xv). Nevertheless, she seems to have managed to produce a credible analysis based on available data.
While the states of Bahrain, Oman, and Kuwait are the focus of the study, the analysis often is extended to other Gulf countries (Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates), as well. This is warranted due to the fact that the entire Gulf region is unique in many respects. The countries are almost totally dependent on oil revenue. Moreover, except for Saudi Arabia, they are ministates in geography and in population. Furthermore, all these states are ruled by traditional families with hereditary succession and authoritarian systems of governance.
The chapter on employment indicates a curious demographic reality of the Gulf states. Few countries in the world rely as heavily on foreign labor and immigrant workers as these societies do. The high concentration of nonnational labor is formidable, reaching 80 percent in Bahrain, 60 percent in Kuwait, 55 percent in Qatar, and an average of 47 percent in Saudi Arabia. The implication of this fact for the social and economic growth of these countries is profound. Sayed Ali Mohammed indicates that discovery of oil in the 1950s prompted a large influx of workers from around the world. Whereas foreign workers provided human capital for the development of the Gulf states, such employment has also had serious social, economic, and political consequences that reach beyond infrastructure construction and economic growth.
Clearly, the book recognizes and underlines many demographic anomalies in these ministates. Reliance on foreign labor creates serious cultural impediments for current and future development. Nationals of these states have become a privileged and pampered superclass, enjoying the largesse of oil revenues and anxiously guarding various archaic public policies that perpetuate their political dominance and economic benefits. One remarkable example is policies on citizenship. It is extremely difficult for a nonnational in these countries to become a citizen. Even children of noncitizens born and raised in these countries, who have known no other country of residence in their entire life, are rarely granted citizenship. Furthermore, reliance on foreign labor contributes to a condition of inequality for women in the employment domain and creates numerous legal issues. While the study recognizes some of these problems, it offers little by way of a blueprint for reform.
Noteworthy, as the book indicates, is the politicization of importing and hiring foreign labor in the Gulf countries. Disagreement with the political stance of the governments of the imported workers often results in massive terminations and hiring bans on their citizens, causing enormous human-rights issues. The worst example is the treatment accorded to Palestinian and Jordanian workers in Kuwait in the aftermath of the 1990 Gulf War. Currently, these Gulf countries have increased their hiring of Asian workers (from Pakistan, India, the Philippines, and Thailand) not only because of their willingness to accept low wages and to do menial labor, but also because they are deemed “safe” politically for Gulf regimes.
Linkages between demographic factors and various aspects of the economic, political, and social characteristics of these countries are often implied or specifically recognized in the book. The author emphasizes such factors as the high birthrate and the dramatic improvement in the mortality rate in these countries and how they translate into citizens' increasing demands for employment and educational opportunities. This trend, along with the states' heavy reliance on an exhaustible product (oil) generating unstable revenue, is increasingly a matter of concern if these countries are to sustain expected or necessary socioeconomic development in the future. Alas, the analysis presented offers tenuous conclusions as remedies or public-policy alternatives.
While the book provides a large number of statistical tables and demographic projections, the data are often not that current. Most tables provide information that is more than ten years old. Still, the main weakness of this study is its lack of serious attention to public-policy recommendations for reform. The strategic issues seem buried in the analysis; the effects of type of governance are rarely brought out, despite their dominant influence on all aspects of public policy. While the author emphasizes the need for rational population management, the issues involved go far beyond questions of fertility and population growth. The public policies of these countries seem intended to preserve the current privileges for citizens, subsidize their needs, and support in perpetuity their dependence on huge numbers of foreign servants. These servants are relegated to doing the hard work, thus maintaining the special privileges of the few and reducing the need for women to be equal participants in the employment field.
Population and Development of the Arab Gulf States represents a serious jump in scholarly interest in the demography of the Gulf states. However, the scholarly community ought to continue exploring the major political and economic considerations related to demographic data.