Fruma Zachs's ambitious yet modest book focuses on several 19th-century Beirut authors of the Arab nahḍa, reinterpreting them as the architects of a specifically Syrian identity. This is ambitious if only because it requires Zachs to contend with the legacy of Albert Hourani. Moreover, Zachs claims that the construction of a Syrian identity antedated the violence of 1858-1860, being incubated—along with the Christian Arab “middle stratum” that bore it—at the court of Amir Bashir II (1788--1840) in Mount Lebanon. Zachs is modest, however, declining to engage with those who claim these figures as Arab or Lebanese cultural heroes. Although she identifies the process she analyzes as an example of “proto-nationalism,” Zachs shies away from that term's teleological and political implications, preferring to write, sometimes vaguely, of the elaboration of a Syrian “notion,” “idea,” or “identity.” In one case, the modesty is tantalizing: her discussion of the depiction of female protagonists in historical novels (pp. 183–212) only hints at the possibilities of a full-blown gender analysis of these sources. On the whole, Zachs's book is as much an articulation of an agenda for future research as a complete in itself case study.
Zachs's thesis is that the flourishing of the Shihabi amirate in Mount Lebanon and, later, the growth of Beirut as an entrepôt gave rise to a Christian mercantile bourgeoisie (Zachs prefers to call it a “middle stratum”) that came to adopt an identity that was culturally Arab, territorially Syrian, and politically Ottoman. One segment of this stratum was a group of “literati” who elaborated that identity in poetry, historical writing, and journalism, including serialized historical novels. This “Syrian narrative of the Beiruti middle stratum” (p. 5) had as its aim “to create a new self or a collective self that would encompass the region's entire population, be it Muslim or Christian” (p. 8). Despite the secular and territorial basis of this identity, its transconfessional vision, and the Christian literati's productive interaction with both Ottoman officials and Muslim intellectuals, “it was essentially a Christian-Arab identity” (p. 4). This was a territorial patriotism to a newly conceived “Syria” (Suriyya rather than Bilad al-Sham) that did not aspire to “national” independence, although it did call for regional unity and provincial autonomy under Ottoman aegis.
In support of her thesis, Zachs relies on a wide range of sources, most importantly the published writings of the figures she analyzes. Among archival sources prominence is given to the records of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions.
Five chapters discuss in succession the genesis of a “Syrian identity” during the reign of Amir Bashir II; the coevolution of the Christian middle stratum, the Syrian “idea,” and the city of Beirut; the effects of the Tanzimat reforms, especially the creation of the vilayet of Syria; the interaction between American missionaries and Beirut literati; and how Syrian identity was expressed in changing literary genres. These chapters are unequal in length and uneven in quality. Each chapter's theme is worth a book of its own. An epilogue and two appendices round out the book.
A main strength of Zachs's work is the connection she draws between the middle stratum's class interests and the development of a Syrian territorial identity. The merchants of the mountain and, later, Beirut saw all Syria rather than their particular localities as their field of operations, and it was no accident that this stratum's literati—often merchants' close relatives—expressed a Syrian territorial patriotism. Zachs is not deterministic in this respect, but she does plausibly demonstrate a strong linkage between the middle stratum's economic and political interests and its cultural orientation. One is reminded here of Hanna Batatu's observations on Baʿthist Pan-Arabism's roots in the class outlook of Michel ʿAflaq and Salah al-Din Bitar's Damascene mercantile milieu.
Zachs also privileges internal over external forces in the development of a specifically Syrian identity. Although crediting American missionaries with a not insignificant influence on the literati, most notably in the substitution of Suriyya for Bilad al-Sham, she concludes that they “encouraged a process of local dynamics already underway, but did not initiate it” (p. 150). In rejecting the American-centric version of the nahḍa formerly prevalent, Zachs points to such indigenous developments as the establishment of the ʿAyn Waraqa school in 1789 and the reorganization of Ottoman provincial administration in the 1860s as more significant in the development of a Syrian-Arab consciousness than the foundation of the Syrian Protestant College.
Despite Zachs's strengths, certain elements do not receive as much emphasis as perhaps they should. For example, the critical period of Egyptian rule under Ibrahim Pasha is given surprisingly little and fragmentary attention, Ibrahim appearing essentially as a patron of Amir Bashir. Similarly, other events are decontextualized or presented such that their relevance is not readily apparent, such as the 1860 violence, the Tanzimat (which Zachs has start in 1856 rather than 1839), or the 1880 placards of the “Beiruti Secret Society.” Zachs reinterprets these last (pp. 119–25) as mature expressions of the Syrian patriotism she has been discussing rather than, as George Antonious argues, the first expressions of Arab political nationalism. Given this emphasis, Zachs could have usefully provided the leaflets' full text rather than just a few excerpts. More significantly, because Zachs is emphatic on the apolitical character of the Syrian identity she posits, she needs to explore more explicitly and extensively the changing meanings of such fraught terms as balad and waṭan, as she does in her argument against Antonious, in which she shows that istiqlāl in the context of the leaflets means “autonomy” rather than “independence.”
Despite such criticisms, Zach's book is a welcome addition to the growing literature on class and identity in the Levant, one that is careful not to argue beyond its evidence and that lays out an agenda for future work.
