Ruth Kinna's thoroughly researched book on Kropotkin implicitly makes a persuasive case for actually reading the work of well-known philosophers rather than apprehending them through their reputations. While few scholars would actively defend sloppy scholarship, the remarkable depth and breadth of research behind this book should make us appropriately uneasy about the shortcuts we often (perhaps necessarily) take. Unwelcome orthodoxies are created when we abstract and decontextualize key ideas. Alternative readings become unavailable.
Kinna takes readers through the complex evolution of Kropotkin's work, situating him within his philosophical and political contexts as well as within the secondary literature about him. Her analysis displaces the common take on Kropotkin as the gentle old man of “mutual aid” fame and replaces it with a more complex and interesting story of a thinker/activist whose half century of intellectual and political labor aimed “to create the conditions in which diverse groups and individuals could live anarchistically” (202).
Kinna deftly calls our attention to the ironic workings of scholars’ periodization of anarchism into classical anarchism, new anarchism, and postanarchism; like feminism's waves, anarchism's eras impose rigidity and predictability on otherwise fluid and intermingling ideas and practices. She asks, rightly, “What is the point of probing the history of anarchist ideas when we already know what particular categories of anarchists believed?” (3). Her bottom line is that the debates among representatives of the three eras issue in an unfortunate dismissal: “Kropotkin emerges as an old man: worthy but out-of-time”; not just Kropotkin but the whole nineteenth-century tradition is portrayed as “exhausted” (45). In contrast, Kinna argues that “the tag ‘classical anarchism’ is not only an obstacle to the study of Kropotkin's ideas; it is a distorting lens for movement histories. … I want to suggest that the classical stereotypes do not stand up to scrutiny and that the ideas of classical anarchism's leading representative diverge both in content and form from those that have been attributed to him” (46).
This is an exciting call to rethink an iconic figure in anarchist histories. By situating Kropotkin within the conversations and movements that provoked him, by refusing the ready-made dismissals and instead delving deeply into Kropotkin's ideas within his places and times, Kinna offers us a lively and sometimes surprising take on the “grand old man.” She investigates Kropotkin's enduring debts to the nihilist tradition in Russia, his ongoing engagements with Nietzsche, his analysis of the relations between human and extrahuman environments, and his discussion of the European state system. Kinna carefully disentangles Kropotkin's views on Nietzsche, whose influence on anarchism he condemned as “baleful,” from Kropotkin's remarkable praise of the Russian nihilist women whose radical rejection of domestic norms as well as state authority provided a model of revolutionary change. She equally carefully pulls Kropotkin's critiques of colonialism out of his historical geographies, connecting his sarcastic characterizations of Western “civilization” with his ethical arguments for human and environmental development toward self-organizing, egalitarian networks of communities.
One of Kinna's major contributions is her fresh reading of Kropotkin's often-vilified support for the Allies in World War I. She sets aside the usual explanations—that Kropotkin abandoned his anarchist principles because he hated Germany, loved France, and was staunchly patriotic toward Russia—and instead argues that Kropotkin's willingness to support the Allied effort, in the absence of an international working-class movement capable of stopping the Axis powers, was consistent with his internationalism. Kinna's conclusion engages Malatesta's passionate debates with Kropotkin over World War I, while insisting that Kropotkin's position represented a coherent moment within his anarchism, not a deviation from it.
While I second Kinna's call for us to inquire into rather than assume the contours of historical texts and practices, I long to hear Kinna say more about the dilemmas of periodization itself. How are we supposed to get a handle on enormous and varied streams of thinking and acting if we can't use some compressed measures to name and place their elements? I appreciate and share her fear of prepackaged categorizations for our ideas, but I stumble over the challenge involved in grappling with histories absent some broad umbrella categories to bring order to their constituent parts.
I think that Kinna stumbles over it, too. The dilemma is enacted in part 1 of the book, where her discussion of a profusion of sources sometimes becomes a confusion regarding them: she brings in Paul Eltzbacher, George Woodcock, George Lichtheim, Paul Avrich, and Hermia Oliver to address Kropotkin's standing within classical anarchism; Saul Newman, George Crowder, and Gabriel Kuhn to bring postanarchist perspectives to bear on Kropotkin; Colin Ward, Lucien van der Walt, Michael Schmidt, and Brian Morris to position Kropotkin in relation to class-struggle debates. All this within the first fifty pages is a bit overwhelming. It is difficult to figure out what is at stake in these disputes. It would have been easier to follow if the text had focused on first-, second-, and third-wave debates, then subsumed the various thinkers within broader categories, as Kinna does in her brief conclusion to part 1; but then Kinna's deconstruction of the wave/era metaphor would have been itself undone. Perhaps the only workable response to this dilemma is to continue to make use of periodizations (or some other umbrella categories) to organize historical material, while continually reminding ourselves of the categories’ dangers and limitations.
Kinna leaves us with a healthy skepticism of glib historical rereadings of Kropotkin and by extension of other overquoted but underread historical figures. Her Kropotkin offers anarchism inspired by the conviction, not that people are naturally good or that history guarantees progress, but that “ordinary people had the capacity to resolve complex social problems through their direct interactions” (191). While Kinna herself does not stress this opportunity, hers is a Kropotkin that we can use today.
