Today Morocco is the only ancien regime Muslim monarchy still standing. Despite the brevity of its colonial past (1912–56), it remains unique. In no other Middle East and North Africa state was the colonial heritage so important to the formation of a national identity that incorporates its various internal others so effectively. The successful transition from The Morocco That Was (W. B. Harris [London: Eland Books, 2007]) to the Morocco that is has been largely credited to the wizardry of Resident General Hubert Lyautey (1912–24) and his team, whose bold political improvisations kept modern Morocco intact and the monarchy in place in its formative moments.
Jonathan Wyrtzen is interested in colonial Morocco because it provides him with an opportunity to discuss how French policy led to the formation of a uniquely interesting colonial political field. In some ways his book can be thought of as the culmination of a generation-long process of examining colonial Morocco through a Foucaultian lens that began with Paul Rabinow's French Modern: Norms and Forms of the Social Environment (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1989).
Morocco's transition to modernity is the subject of his excellent Making Morocco. Based upon an impressive variety of sources, ranging from colonial archival records and published materials to oral histories and Berber poetry, the book provides a comprehensive survey of the shaping of a modern Moroccan identity. Instead of a top-down account that assigns agency to the colonizers, Making Morocco presents the process as a series of interactive narratives around four major themes: religion, ethnicity, territory, and the monarchy.
Wyrtzen notes that Morocco's colonial experience (1912–56), while brief, had a profoundly important role in shaping the key elements of its modern political field. Contemporary Morocco, he demonstrates, is riven by debates over the public role of Islam, religious tolerance, the place of Morocco's Jews in the national dialogue, the legal status of women, the continued relevance of Morocco's Berber heritage, and the still-unresolved dispute over Western Sahara. Threaded through each of these debates, he argues, is the continued symbolic and actual dominance of the monarchy in the political field. Each of these debates originated under the protectorate and was structured into the modern identity of Moroccans. None has manifested itself as a zero-sum game; rather, each (so far) has been contained within the existing polity.
An original aspect of Making Morocco is Wyrtzen's decision to incorporate the narratives of the emergence of the Moroccan political field via how it has dealt with its internal others: Berbers, Jews, and women, as well as the ongoing debate over Morocco's borders (do they include Western Sahara, or not?). Bringing to bear both conventional archival and written sources, but also Berber poetry and the writings of others, Wyrtzen provides historically grounded accounts of how each became dynamized in the course of the liberation struggle. Similarly, he provides a historical explanation of the emergence of the monarchy as a central element in the overall Moroccan field (even though historically Lyautey selected Mulay Yusuf to replace ʿAbd al-Hafidh in 1912 precisely because the former was perceived as the perfect rubber stamp, a compliant tool of French authority).
This is where Making Morocco marks a significant methodological change from previous, largely ahistorical accounts of how the discursive frame was established. Moroccans and French alike played roles, not always the ones they thought at the time, in the creation and maintenance of the modern Moroccan political frame. Wyrtzen makes it clear he is building upon the research of a generation of postcolonial Moroccans and foreign scholars also influenced by the relevance of Foucaultian perspectives on modern Morocco.
There is a tension, mostly unexpressed here, between the might-have-been world of the contingent and the tendency to see the creation of the Morocco political field as the consequence of the discursive. Morocco's colonial legacy was not just an instance of the application of “scientific imperialism.” It was also the fruit of a great deal of political struggle of all kinds (very pointedly including Moroccans pushing back against the French and against one another). Wyrtzen no doubt would agree, even if the point of his book lies elsewhere.
Right from the beginning of the protectorate (1912) things went wrong, big time. The signing of the protectorate treaty was greeted by a national insurrection that thoroughly scrambled French plans and almost led to their expulsion from the interior to the coast. Only the full application of French power (and a lot of lucky breaks) allowed them to prevail. The transition to the protectorate must not be seen, therefore, as the unfolding of a master plan, but as deeply embedded in contingency at every turn.
Will the monarchy survive? This depends on how well the king and his team manage not just the Islamist challenge to the monarchy but also the major social and economic realities upon which everything is perched. These include some of the most daunting inequalities (according to UNICEF) confronted by any Middle Eastern state. For instance, demographic (the total fertility rate in 2012 was 2.7), economic (the share of household income for the poorest 40% is 17%, and for the richest 20% it is 48%) and social (the female literacy as a percentage of male literacy is 75.8%). Together they suggest that the current system is not likely to continue indefinitely, however deftly it deals with internal debate.
While Foucault affords us a powerful set of tools for understanding the emergence of modern Morocco as a contested discursive space, future scholars might be wise to supplement them with intellectual approaches that better engage material realities. Channeling the spirit of American political sociologist G. William Domhoff (and Moroccan economist Ahmed Diouiri), they might ask: who owns Morocco? Whatever did happen to the holdings of the Omnium nord africain, which was dissolved in 2011?
