The much awaited edited work by Peter Sluglett, The Urban Social History of the Middle East 1750–1950, offers a review of works on the urban social history of the Middle East and a thorough and extended bibliography. It is a great tool for experts as well as newcomers to the field. The work includes seven studies and a very detailed introduction. Contributors focus on different themes and offer diverse perspectives on the subject, especially in terms of politics, demography, relations between states and the countryside, and urbanization between 1750 and 1950 (although the main focus is on the 19th century). Despite different approaches and at times diverging point of views, all contributors challenge common and elusive terms, such as “Islamic city” through the redefinition of the concept “Middle Eastern city.” Contributors also agree on a number of conclusions drawn from new and closer analyses of the available sources, such as the interconnection of city and countryside and an economic rather than religious framework for explaining sectarian violence.
The introduction by Peter Sluglett and Edmund Burke III outlines the methodological foundations of the work and presents a thorough and detailed discussion of available scholarship in urban social history of the Middle East. Although the chapter may appear dense and inaccessible to those unfamiliar with the topic, it constitutes a strong assessment of the state of the field, which researchers of the subject should take into account.
The essay by Sarah Shields, “Interdependent Spaces,” focuses on changes in the relationship between cities and countryside in the 19th-century Middle East. Through an extensive discussion of agricultural production and the effects of rural surplus on Middle Eastern cities, Shields argues that over time urban merchants acquired control over rural production. This occurred without a breaking of ties between city and countryside; on the contrary, Shields argues that such ties were intensified through the urban population's direct control over the products of the countryside. Shields’ piece represents a good attempt to bridge economic and social history in order to provide a clearer picture of Middle Eastern cities. The second essay, by Dina Rizk Khoury, focuses on the political relations between city and state from 1700 to 1850. Khoury provides an overview of available literature on the topic, suggesting that little is known about the working of the state at the provincial level. Khoury is right to argue that there is a lack of local and imperial sources on this question, and I add that an active exchange between scholars of different languages and disciplines is also lacking. The most interesting section of this essay is the discussion of political actors in the urban setting. Khoury argues that Hourani's paradigm of “the politics of notables” does not adequately explain the shifts in the meaning of the term “notables” (aʿyān) between 1700 and 1850. The critique is legitimate in light of the need to examine more thoroughly how state and city interacted over time and space, but Khoury does not explain how the paradigm should be reformulated.
The essay by Abdul-Karim Rafeq discusses the economic organization of cities in Ottoman Syria, providing a comprehensive discussion of guilds and business practices while also assessing the impact of European penetration. In this dense and very detailed chapter, Rafeq argues that capitalist Europe destabilized the economies and societies of Syrian cities, creating new social classes and institutions. Unfortunately, the extensive use of difficult jargon and data makes this chapter accessible only to experts in this particular area of interest. Similar to Khoury, the co-written essay by Leila Fawaz and Robert Ilbert discusses the political relations between city and state in the colonial era. The authors aim to provide a brief overview of the mandatory powers’ impact on particular sociopolitical institutions in Middle Eastern cities. They focus on the sociopolitical role played by the aʿyān before the 1950s and how these notables were affected by the revolutions that followed the 1948 war. The authors suggest some form of continuity, which in my view constitutes an important suggestion for further research. Bernard Hourcade's essay is based on the discussion of demography and urban space. The heavy use of a specialist vocabulary and tables makes this chapter valuable for experts but less accessible to the nonspecialist. Hourcade shows the demographic evolution of cities from the 18th century to the 1940s, highlighting three stages of demographic growth. His arguments are supported by a remarkable amount of data considering the small size of the chapter; it is no mean feat to fit a demographic study covering nearly 200 years of history into 40 pages. This data can be used in other contexts and in larger academic debates.
The essay by Gudrun Krämer focuses on minorities in Middle Eastern urban societies. This is the longest and most accessible contribution in the book. Short but very effective explanations of key terms such as dhimmī, millet, and capitulations can be utilized in readings for undergraduate students. Krämer looks at the position of non-Muslims in Middle Eastern cities in different historical periods but focuses on the 19th century, arguing that non-Muslims exploited the Ottoman reforms to move out from, or reshape, their own urban social environment. The author's overview of the dynamics of the internal and external relationships of non-Muslims also shows that this characterization was valid mainly for the upper and educated classes, while little is known about the lower classes. Krämer correctly argues that in spite of the cosmopolitanism of an urban space, the “vertical” element of religious and ethnic identification was never supplanted by the “horizontal” idea of social class. The last essay by Sami Zubaida analyzes the urban sociopolitical movements from 1750 to 1950. In this complex but well-argued essay, Zubaida aims to identify a pattern of urban politics present in Ottoman cities and its development through the 19th century until the mid-20th century. Zubaida challenges the idea that senior ʿulamaʾ were the leaders of the urban population. Using the example of Cairo, he argues that it was not the distinguished scholars but the lower clergy that played a prominent role in popular movements. Then, he introduces the idea that the majority of urban poor were not politically organized or under the control of parties or organizations but were largely responsive to Islamic appeals frequently used to mobilize the masses.
In sum, this diverse collection of essays on the urban social history of the Middle East is not groundbreaking, but it provides a greatly anticipated assessment of the status of this particular field. A perusal of the book shows that such a project has been in the planning stages for years (as Sluglett points out in the preface), which is a testimony to the necessity of thoroughly assessing this area of research. This also means that despite the clear effort of the contributors, some of the essays are not up to date. Nevertheless, the text is still a very welcome contribution and a must read for those involved in urban and social history of the Middle East.
