Kampen's book examines how rich and powerful members of the Roman élite used the concept of family in their visual representations as a potent means of negotiating political power and identity. This ambitious work explores the ways in which ideologies of family were manipulated to serve differing élite requirements, from the Augustan period through to the fourth century, in different parts of the Empire.
The last forty years have seen the social history of the Roman family the worthy recipient of increasing scholarly attention, but unlike the majority of work examining these issues through material culture, K.'s project is not restricted to any one particular medium or period. Rather, she uses a range of different types of objects produced over a broad time-span and across a wide area. Despite the breadth of focus she is emphatic that this is not an attempt at a general ‘history of the family in Roman art’, rather, the aim is to pursue her specific enquiry about élite representations of family usually by focusing on one image or monument in each chapter. Although K.'s intention is not to create a single narrative history, the chronological development through the chapters does mean, as she notes, that the book presents a ‘sketch of a particular kind of history’ — one that is particularly susceptible to the author's choice of objects. A selective presentation of material is inevitable with such a broad subject and one of the benefits of K.'s focused approach is that it makes this process explicit. Her methodology also serves her well in avoiding unhelpful generalizations by permitting detailed study of the significance of individual objects.
The case-studies that provide the focus for each chapter are: a cameo in the Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna, showing Livia holding the bust of Augustus; the visual interactions between the emperor and different families depicted on Trajan's Column; Herodes Atticus' statuary commemoration of his beloved Polydeukion; the depiction of the Severan dynasty on the arch at Lepcis; the porphyry statues of embracing tetrarchs; and an ivory diptych thought to show Stilicho with his wife and son. It is clear from this selection that the intention was not to discuss supposedly ‘typical’ family groups. Rather, the emphasis is upon the process of how and why these family relationships were visually constructed in a particular way and this is analysed admirably throughout the book.
Her discussion of Livia and the Severan family examines relatively traditional terrain relating to the depiction of dynastic ideologies, but does so in a convincing manner that embeds the images in their physical and cultural contexts. One of the work's strengths is that it goes beyond the established focus on the negotiation of dynastic power politics to look at how élite individuals used the representation of family to shape how they wished to be seen: from Herodes' choices in his nuanced commemoration of Polydeukion to Stilicho's motives for being represented with his family. Throughout the book there is a sensitive treatment of gender, gesture and dress and the author treats commendably the different possibilities of text and material culture to weave a meticulously researched picture which explores different registers of audience response.
There are occasions when the reader may feel that the contemporary historical evidence is of greater relevance than considerably older art historical precedents which have been given priority. K. meticulously explores how particular images may have operated for different audiences, and generally the range of interpretations that she presents are very compelling. However, there are moments where the carefully researched nuances seem distinctly weighted towards possible, rather than probable receptions. For example, perhaps even the sophisticated viewer envisaged for imperial cameos may not immediately have connected the different evocations of deity in Livia's dress with the games held in honour of these particular goddesses in April and thus linked this with Livia's dedication of a statue of Augustus at the Theatre of Marcellus in that month. Similarly, the embrace of husband and wife on sarcophagi bears relatively little resemblance to that shared by the tetrarchs, as K. herself notes, so it seems questionable whether these would really have served as an ‘intensifier’ informing élite viewer responses in Italy. These are, though, minor criticisms of a book which offers a stimulating and thought-provoking approach to an important subject.
