This is a wide-ranging book with ambitious and constructive aims. It consists of eighteen chapters in total that explore different aspects of gentrification and mixed communities, or the ‘social mix’ debates as the latter aspect is also commonly known.
The key aims, as expressed by the three editors, are to:
(1) illustrate similarities and differences in the ways that mixed communities policies are enacted internationally through gentrification;
(2) evaluate the claim that introducing middle-income people into low-income neighbourhoods breaks down social segregation in positive ways; and
(3) encourage wider debate about social mix policies that promote gentrification − specifically between relevant interest groups, which include gentrification and housing researchers, policy makers and planners.
In order to meet these aims, the book encompasses an interdisciplinary and international collection of contributors, spanning academics from sociology, geography and urban studies to policy analysts from across the Trans-Pacific-Atlantic. This assortment provides varying insights from a range of countries, academic disciplines and policy makers and practitioners.
In relation to the third aim of encouraging debate between different interest groups, the editors are concerned that deliberations about mixed communities are occurring without noting the insights from a growing knowledge base about gentrification (p. 9). This is a worthy aim although mixed communities and housing researchers could equally argue like points from their own alternative perspectives. That aside, undoubtedly there are benefits in greater dialogue and overlap between the two groups and their often separately evolving but clearly related research aims and in developing multiple standpoints for informing policy agendas. The book starts to address this issue through including at least some key contributions from mixed communities’ researchers. Manley et al., for instance, in chapter 11, investigate the evidence for mixed communities policies and outline some methodological problems in modelling neighbourhood effects. This provides a foundation for engagement between the different groups.
Given the large number of contributors, the book is divided into five thematic parts. This works well and makes the book more easily navigitable for the reader. In part one, containing chapters 2 through 5, the focus is on some broad reflections on social mix policies, namely in the United Kingdom, United States and Australasian regions. Paul Cheshire, for instance, writing from the UK disputes the commonly held view that living in poor neighbourhoods causes people to have poorer health, lower incomes and skill levels. He argues that there is no evidence that these sorts of adverse effects are the result of living in poor neighbourhoods as ‘correlation does not demonstrate causation’ (p. 19). He likens such an approach to ‘trying to cure fever by attaching leeches’ (p. 24). Other contributors explore some of the numerous problems associated with social mix both as a concept and in implementation. As Le Gales illustrates conceptually, social mix lacks definition and a theoretical underpinning.
In part two (chapters 6 and 7), social mix policies are explored in liberal and neoliberal contexts. Ley, drawing on the city of Vancouver, provides an interesting analysis of how the idea of social mixing has interlinked with gentrification and changed over time from representing progressive policy in the 1960s and 1970s to contemporary regressive policy, as critiqued by current commentators in the debates.
The third part of the book (chapters 8 through 10) focuses on some key social mix policy interventions that have been implemented in working-class neighbourhoods in different national contexts through exploring the cities of Chicago, Paris and Melbourne. The overarching question addressed in these chapters is what types of policies have dominated and whether they have been successful. A common theme that emerges is that deconcentration policies undermine social support networks, dilute political power and cloak structural inequalities that advance social disadvantage and inequality. Lipman reaches the important conclusion that the power of the deconcentration thesis is in the lack of any alternative social program to take its place.
Part four explores the question of what represents rhetoric and reality in the social mix debates. Manley et al. return to the enquiry initiated earlier on in the book by Paul Cheshire (chapter 3) about causality. Specifically, the uncertainty about whether neighbourhood type effects that are found in the current literature are a ‘result of causation or selection’ (p. 165). There are also context specific contributions from Brussels (chapter 12), Scotland (chapter 13) and Nashville. The latter is an interesting account of a study that involved 120 interviews with households from across four Hope VI sites and provides a nuanced account of life in these neighbourhoods.
In drawing together the key findings from the vast array of contributors, the editors conclude that it is questionable whether social mix policies benefit the poor. It is argued that they may even have harmful effects. It is also contended (although this finding is not novel) that the anticipated mixing between different income groups does not occur. Thus, tackling poverty requires investment in resources and addressing unequal power bases − and it is hoped the book will assist in moving policy debates in the right direction.
Despite its utility, there are some limitations and oversights within the book. It would have been interesting to hear more from the voices of residents themselves, about their experiences of gentrification and social mix, although it is acknowledged that there are some chapters commencing from this premise. There are also some key international contributors to these debates and experts on this topic that would have strengthened this book if they were able to be included. Two commentators that come to mind are Damaris Rose from Canada and Tom Slater from the UK. In summary though, the book provides a wealth of important information for researchers, educators, policy makers and students that are interested in this topic.
