The end of the classical city and in particular ‘pagan’ religion and its physical accoutrements remains a key area of interest within late antique studies. At least two edited volumes have dealt with temple conversion in recent years and Alan Cameron's The Last Pagans of Rome (2011) has added impetus to debates on what we mean by paganism in Late Antiquity and what its end might look like (Leone explicitly engages with Cameron's thesis throughout). Leone and Jacobs provide a focus on the material culture of the city that is missing from Cameron and, in doing so, provide a picture of the efforts of Mediterranean communities to make sense and use of their monumental heritage that goes beyond simple narratives of transformation, religious antagonism or decay.
Although there is considerable overlap between them, the volumes differ, not only in terms of their regional focus where they complement each other — L. examines Africa, J. primarily Asia Minor — but also in their themes. L. focuses on what happened to religious structures and statuary, J. also deals with fortifications, streets and squares, and decorative monuments. Both examine the motivations for the maintenance, transformation, destruction and abandonment of earlier monuments into Late Antiquity. The timescales tackled are also slightly different: L.'s work runs from the Edict of Milan up to the sixth century; J.'s from the accession of Diocletian to the seventh century. The latter in particular though makes reference to earlier phases of the city to provide the context for urban change.
Despite the broad title, J. focuses on the cities of Asia Minor with comparative material drawn in from other parts of the Mediterranean world — largely the Near East, Greece and Constantinople; Africa, Italy and Egypt make occasional appearances. This is a substantial text with a wealth of detail on many aspects of the urban infrastructure and looks at buildings from construction, through maintenance to decay, dismantling and reuse. After a short introduction, chapters on fortifications, streets, decorative monuments, religious architecture and statuary, chart interventions in the city in Late Antiquity. A short sixth chapter examines simplification and reuse in architectural elements. ‘Initiators and Constructors’ considers those who paid for the work and the professionals who planned and executed it. ‘Urban Space’ examines small scale repairs, cleaning, encroachment and dumping. For a work of this size the conclusion is vital and the succinct description of changes during Late Antiquity, in places comparing evidence from the Near East and Asia Minor, prevents the work as a whole becoming unwieldy. A useful compendium of core sites in the appendix is, like L.'s tables of building work in her Changing Townscapes in North Africa (2007), a useful resource for those beginning research on a particular city or building type. J.'s triumph is the synthesis of so much material from diverse regions of the Empire in a way that will make the book a useful starting point for much research on the late antique city.
L. focuses on the eastern African provinces. An introductory chapter on paganism and Christianity tackles some of the big debates that dominate the study of late antique Africa such as Circumcellion violence — although it is slightly out of the scope of the book, one slightly misses a definitive statement of L.'s position to supplement the presentation of academic arguments. Chapters on the fate of the temples, the end of paganism, the fate of the statues, spolia in churches and a final chapter on secular life follow and explore many aspects of the use and transformation of material culture in late antique North Africa. L. examines some of the generally held views of sets of archaeological, often poorly documented material, on which hypotheses about continuity or pagan-Christian hostility have been built. For instance, the evidence from the Maison de la Cachette in Carthage whose statues are often said to show Christian damage and a desire to hide them on the part of pagans, or the cache of statues in Bulla Regia's Temple of Apollo, often regarded as a museum, are carefully re-examined and assumptions based on fragile evidence convincingly challenged.
L.'s book, because of the nature of the material tackled, is perhaps slightly more focused than J.'s. The importance of material drawn in from other regions of the Empire is not always clear in Aesthetic Maintenance. Perhaps the organization of the material would have been tighter if the temptation to include occasional Italian examples and, especially, the pilgrimage centres at Theveste in Africa and Abu Mina in Egypt had been resisted; the presence of the latter two sites is odd given that they are not really compared to pilgrimage sites in the core regions studied — they might have been compared to the Martyrion of St Philip at Hierapolis which does feature regularly. In places even those extensively used sites in the Near East are somewhat peripheral to the discussion.
Some disagreements or different emphases about interventions in the city come through in the two works. The economic benefit of late antique operations in the city is clearly present in both but is more in the foreground of L.'s transformation of the city, whereas civic pride is given more space by J. The infrequency of religiously motivated violence against temples and statues is present in both, although L. provides a more explicit sense of the shared ‘secular’ experience and expectations of the majority, Christian and pagan, in the late antique city. Respect for, and movement of, statues is important in both books but whereas, for L., this is an expensive and difficult operation to be done only when economically viable, for J. moving a statue to another location is a relatively inexpensive way of beautifying the urban landscape; both emphases are essentially impressionistic. Both writers see the evidence of lime-burning as being a post-late antique phenomenon; spoliation, storing and re-use of marble statues and architectural elements as the norm before the seventh century. The different regional and thematic focuses of the books lead to slightly different pictures being produced. For J. re-use and spoliation of temples begins in the fourth century but carries on well into the fifth, whilst L. argues that it was essentially a fourth-century phenomenon in Africa.
The End of the Pagan City and Aesthetic Maintenance are different in scale and scope but both making interesting and substantial contributions to our understanding of the motivations of those individuals and groups who were actors in preserving or transforming the early imperial city and the physical consequences of their operations.
