In God, Jews and the Media, Yoel Cohen examines the mutual impact between Judaism and the media in Israel, a country where religion is not separated from the state. This includes a diverse media landscape ranging from secular to modern religious and ultra-Orthodox media.
The book covers news and advertising from a wide range of media outlets, including print, broadcast, internet, and select Jewish press in the United States and the United Kingdom. This work will be of interest to all scholars who study Israeli state and society, as the media landscape surrounding religious issues can help explain apparent contradictions between Israel's established image of itself as a modern, democratic, Western state, and the centrality of the Jewish religion to Israeli citizenship.
Cohen's book provides an interesting window into the reflexive nature of Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) media produced by and for the ultra-Orthodox community, which are unfamiliar to many both inside and outside of Israel. To the best of my knowledge, it is the first study to provide detailed descriptions of both the content and consumption of the religious and Haredi media and to compare how secular and religious media cover religious issues. The book demonstrates the mainstream secular media's role in maintaining, and even fueling, the secular–religious conflict, which is a major source of tension in Israeli society. Cohen concludes that while they sometimes play an ambiguous or even a positive role, the media mostly preserve the secular–religious divide by using what he defines as “mutual criticism.” In other words, the secular media perceive the Haredim as a threat to the democratic nature of Israel, and the Haredim see the secular population as “lesser Jews”; these mutual attacks, according to journalists and editors interviewed by the author, indeed “add oil to the fire of the secular–Haredi relations” (pp. 129–31).
The book provides an excellent characterization of Israel's different media organizations, along with a remarkable amount of data (which would have been easier to comprehend if presented in tables) on media coverage and on consumption trends by different audiences. This is a great strength of the book. At the same time, however, Cohen falls short in providing a deeper level of analysis and discussion, especially when attempting to explain and examine the connection between religious coverage and what he calls “contemporary Jewish identity” (p. xii).
Cohen first establishes and explains inherent contradictions between the nature of Western secular media and the nature of the Jewish religion. Judaic doctrine imposes many restrictions on Israeli society, some of which form the basis for the operation of the secular media. The prohibition of work on Shabbat, the restricted use of explicit or implicit sexual content and images, and the regulation of the selection and citation of sources and quotes from interviews, each exemplify religion's influence on the media. The last of these restrictions is particularly influential, since Jewish law has strict rules and taboos on “evil gossip” and “disclosing previously unpublished information” (p.21), prohibitions that directly contradict essential rules of investigative journalism. The media's interest and ethics can, however, coincide with those of the Jewish religion, as Cohen explains, if the publication is motivated by a potential benefit to the public, such as exposing corruption. “If the media's goal is the public good will, this is justified by Jewish law, but it is not if the goal is ‘ratings,’ or the journalist seeks to ingratiate himself with his editor or the owner who expects him to locate exclusive information” (p. 22).
The problems center on the ethics of collecting and disseminating information for profit or ratings. This is in addition to gender and propriety restrictions, such as when a Brooklyn-based Hasidic newspaper famously airbrushed Hillary Clinton out from behind President Obama in a photograph of them watching the raid to kill Osama bin Laden. In practice, these restrictions cause many ultra-Orthodox groups to forbid exposure to, or consumption of, the mainstream-secular media.
Cohen demonstrates how the religious media handle restricted topics by examining the coverage of sexual scandals by former minister Hayim Ramon and former president Moshe Katzav. The Haredi press covering these affairs reported their arrests for “criminal offenses” (p. 80) in order to avoid using sexual terms. This example is especially interesting since, like removing Clinton's image, it demonstrates how Jewish law can contradict the very essence of news coverage; the religious media did not just bury the lead here, they omitted it altogether.
Cohen's Achilles’ heel is that he does not tease out the contradiction that the ultra-Orthodox, ostensible keepers of Jewish law, subvert it at their convenience. How do the Haredi media, for instance, cover topics that are well within the scope of Jewish law, in both letter and spirit? Topics such as corruption in the Haredi political parties, overt discrimination of Mizrahi (Jews of Arab origins) students in Ashkenazi (Jews of European origin) schools, and even discrimination against students with Down syndrome are not convenient for the Haredi media to acknowledge. These examples are only briefly mentioned (p. 89) when Cohen describes the new commercial Haredi media as respecting the religious code, but at the same time introducing “a new level of press freedom in an otherwise highly hierarchical media environment” (p. 88). Another layer of analysis here could have taken readers beyond the quantitative data, as some questions remain unanswered. How is religious Jewish identity reconciled with incidents of moral Jewish failure? What is the depth of the journalistic research behind stories that could potentially be considered “for the greater good of the community,” and to what extent does the new Haredi media attempt to expose religious audiences to these stories?
Another interesting perspective in the book is the comparison to studies done in the United States regarding the nature of religious coverage (Chaps. 3 and 4). This comparison illustrates that while in the U.S. all religions receive at least some press coverage, the Israeli media focus solely on the Jewish religion, giving the ultra-Orthodox substantial coverage. As Cohen writes: “Haredim, or ultra-Orthodox account for 43% of religious coverage even though they account for only 9% of the Jewish population” (p. 53).
Cohen demonstrates that the flip side of this fixation on the Jewish religion is a lack of media representation of other religious, especially Islamic or Christian, views, even when they are integral to the political process. For example, Christian and Muslim perspectives were ignored or marginalized, despite their relevance to the discussion, in coverage of the 2002 negotiations at Camp David over custody of the holy sites. Here, as well, more analysis would have provided a richer discussion of the political effects of this media fixation on Israel's Jewish population. As Cohen writes: “Ideology, therefore, clearly entered all levels of coverage. There was virtually no attention in the news pages or commentary to views and reactions of the Muslim world, including Israeli Arabs and Palestinians” (p. 75).
In other words, ideology affects media coverage, regardless of religious views, a claim that is discussed extensively by cultural-studies scholars such as Stuart Hall, Edward Said, Douglas Kellner, and Ella Shohat, to name a few. This claim was also proven by studies on the Israeli media regarding the Mizrahi-Ashkenazi conflict, for instance, or coverage of center and periphery. More analysis here using theories of identity and discourse would have provided more substantial answers to questions about media text, religion, and ideology.
In summary, the book's greatest contribution lies in its scope of research, and in laying the groundwork for further inquiry at the interface between media and religion. Religious authorities are only beginning to delineate rules for new technologies, and it is not yet clear, conversely, how new technologies might influence religion. Cohen concludes in the end that despite advances in technology and the ubiquitous presence of the internet, the synagogue and the Jewish home remain “the center of Jewish spiritual life” (p. 154).
