Mark Saad Saka seeks to explain the origins of the Huastecan peasant rebellion of 1879–84, when thousands of indigenous peasants from north-eastern Mexico rose up against the government of Porfirio Díaz, demanding ‘political autonomy for their pueblos, the protection of their churches, and the restoration of the land, water, and foraging rights that were part of their heritage’ (p. v). He argues that the causes of the rebellion were both material and moral in nature. The Spanish colonial system left the indigenous peasantry of the Huasteca Potosina in a precarious economic position, stripped of much of its territory and subject to the vagaries of subsistence agriculture. Liberal efforts to foster economic development during the second half of the nineteenth century, through the privatisation of communal lands and the promotion of commercial agriculture, turned a precarious economic situation into a desperate one, depriving peasants of much of their remaining land and forcing them into a highly exploitative labour system.
Material grievances were intensified by moral outrage. Participation in republican and liberal military movements over the course of more than half a century led, according to Saka, to the development of a subaltern nationalist consciousness among Huastecan peasants, transforming their understanding of themselves and their rights as citizens and defenders of the Mexican nation. Betrayed by their former liberal allies and despoiled of their lands, they were further radicalised through their interactions with urban socialists and anarchists, most notably Mauricio Zavala, a Catholic priest and agrarian anarchist who played a central military and ideological role in the rebellion of 1879–84.
Saka develops these arguments over the course of eight chapters. The first provides a brief overview of the region's geography, precolonial inhabitants and colonial history. The second is an account of the region's role in the independence wars and the conflict with the United States. As a result of their involvement on behalf of the republican cause, Saka argues, Huastecan peasants developed military skills, acquired weaponry and encountered ‘modern notions of constitutionalism, republicanism, and nationalism, which all served to ideologically sever [them] from colonial notions of village loyalty and caste subjugation and widened their intellectual horizons and visions’ (p. 18). These skills, weapons and visions were all promptly deployed against encroaching estate owners once the war with the United States was over, as described in chapter 3. Saka then discusses the Huastecan peasantry's participation in the liberal movements of the reform era; the following two chapters describe the liberal policies aimed at promoting economic development and agrarian capitalism, and the impact of these policies on the peasant economy. Chapter 7 is dedicated to the writings and activities of Mauricio Zavala, while chapter 8 turns to the rebellion of 1879–84 itself. Having been empowered and transformed by their participation in previous military movements, Saka argues, Huastecan peasants sought to assert their rights as equal citizens, to recover their lands and their political autonomy, to protect their churches and to create a new social order in keeping with their radicalised class consciousness.
For God and Revolution is a welcome addition to the regional historiography of nineteenth-century Mexico. It focuses on a less studied region and provides excellent accounts of the many military movements involving the Huastecan peasantry over the course of much of the century. The chapter on Mauricio Zavala is fascinating. The good padre, a prolific writer of manifestos and plans, seemed determined to leave no aspect of rural life untouched by his vision of agrarian anarchism.
Curiously, neither God nor revolution figure very prominently in the book. Zavala's writings drew upon Exodus and the gospels, and he was certainly a Catholic priest, but it would be hard to say that he had developed a theology of liberation as Saka claims. There is no discussion of popular religious beliefs and practices, and while the Huastecan peasants clearly rebelled in order to reclaim their lands and local political autonomy, there is no evidence to suggest that their churches were in need of defence or that their religiosity was under attack. Saka's comparison of the Huastecan rebellion to the Cristiada of 1926–9 seems a bit forced.
The discussion of the Huastecan rebellion itself is limited to a brief chapter. The book ends with the defeat of the rebels, and there is little consideration of the rebellion's aftermath. Saka does not define what he means by the term ‘revolution’, although he asserts that the peasants were engaged in one. Given the scope and duration of the rebellion, and the fairly traditional goals of the peasant rebels (land and political autonomy), the term ‘revolution’ does not obviously apply. The plans issued by Zavala and others like him were certainly radical, calling for the creation of a new social and political order at the national level. But radical plans are not all that unusual in Mexican history, and it is difficult to know what the Huastecan rebels made of the political pronouncements of their elite allies. Assuming that peasant consciousness can be deduced from elite manifestos is a dicey business at best.
The book pays almost no attention to local-level politics and forms of economic and social organisation. We learn little about how economic resources were allocated or how political power was wielded within indigenous communities in the Huasteca Potosina. Saka says almost nothing about how the privatisation of communal land occurred in the region, although he provides several instances of fraud and abuse, and notes that some peasants favoured the reform. In some ways, the book harkens back to the orthodox historiography of Mexican liberalism, all but ignoring the many local and regional studies that have seriously complicated the conventional wisdom, which held that a predatory and duplicitous liberal elite imposed reforms on a resistant, occasionally rebellious and all but homogeneous rural population.
Because Saka says so little about the internal workings of the indigenous peasant communities, we do not know how much the ‘new intellectual horizons and visions’ acquired by the Huastecan peasants affected the ways in which they lived their lives and organised their affairs. If the world view of the peasantry had been so thoroughly transformed, from a highly localised attachment to a specific place and its inhabitants to a subaltern nationalism inflected with a radical class consciousness, should we not expect to see some evidence of that transformation in daily life as lived within communities? Saka's argument with respect to consciousness is weakened by his lack of attention to the local level.
For God and Revolution provides an excellent account of the military and political history of the Huasteca Potosina, surely one of Mexico's most interesting regions. It just does not quite deliver all that it promises when it comes to the peasants who risked so much by rebelling in the first years of the Porfiriato.
