Over the course of the past two decades, the rise of new powers on the global stage has been the central focus of a now vast body of literature in international relations. This phenomenon has inspired numerous studies, from norm diffusion on climate and intervention issues to the development—security nexus to the putative renewal of a global liberal order under American leadership; the crosscutting topics for this field of study are myriad. Exemplified by one prominent rising power, Oliver Stuenkel and Matthew M. Taylor’s Brazil on the Global Stage addresses a striking number of these issues, and will be of paramount interest to scholars of emerging powers, the global liberal order and America’s role in it, international institutions, and Brazil itself.
One of the volume’s defining characteristics is the tightness of its conceptual flow, especially as it combines topics as diverse as the domestic origins of Brazil’s attitudes towards liberalism and multilateralism, selected foreign policy stances, and the role of the United States in both. While most contributors hail from, or are specialists in, Brazil, the foreword and afterword firmly frame the book in terms that are intelligible to those interested in U.S. foreign policy. Stuenkel and Taylor’s introduction makes the strong connectedness of the contributions possible, and situates the volume as preoccupied primarily with Brazil’s role as rising power in an American-led liberal international order.
The key commonality in Brazil’s policy responses is the profound ambivalence created by the country’s simultaneous acceptance of fundamental liberal precepts and rejection of the hierarchy present in the rules of the international order—and above all, in the process of their further definition. The editors briefly relate Brazil’s policy positions to dominant IR theories such as realism and liberalism; here, the stage setting might have benefited from more attention to constructivist approaches to norm diffusion, which openly or implicitly infuse most of the book. The work of Amitav Acharya finds repeated and helpful mention in the volume; conspicuously absent is Antje Wiener’s Theory of Contestation (2014), which is eminently suited in particular to the inclusion of emerging powers in the ongoing redefinition of the normative underpinnings of global order.
The first chapter by David Bosco and Stuenkel addresses the elephant in the room for analyses of Brazil that attribute all too much intentionality and consistency to its foreign policy in an effort to apply academic concepts: the occasionally daunting gap between its foreign policy rhetoric and reality. The authors draw out key elements of Brazilian rhetoric and compare these to the country’s multilateral participation. In doing so, they highlight both Brazil’s claim to be a distinctive, exceptional voice in international affairs and the tensions inherent in navigating between global player status and that of a voice for the Global South. Indeed, the pitfalls of successfully juxtaposing the responsibilities expected of a global power—particularly as they pertain to the provision of public goods in a liberal framework—and the subaltern position Brazil has adopted with regard to American and Western leadership are, as is to be expected, a common thread throughout the volume’s contributions.
João M. E. Maia and Taylor turn to the domestic foundations of Brazil’s seemingly ambivalent reaction to the international liberal order. They highlight the disconnect between a formal adherence to liberal principles in foreign policy and a significant failure of liberal precepts to take hold in domestic politics, where a strong central state has never relinquished its fundamental position. They characterize the ensuing ambiguity as a result of an instrumental approach: “Brazil would sign on to international law as a shield against the great powers, using international law as a weapon of weak state realism. But it would temper this belief in the rule-based order with a close eye to the biases and inequalities perpetuated by international institutions” (p. 49). Ralph Espach’s chapter investigates this phenomenon in greater detail, focusing on the case of Brazil’s security relationship with the United States as the core power in the global liberal order. Providing an overview of postwar bilateral relations, he outlines the prospects for the bilateral security relationship in the absence of a common threat perception or a shared view on the utility of coercive means.
Marcos Tourinho’s chapter focuses on an area in which Brazil has had a prominent international role, and which is particularly conducive to contributing to the volume’s mission of “locat[ing] exactly where Brazilian dissent from the contemporary international order lies” (p. 80): norms of humanitarian intervention. In analyzing diplomatic debates on the “responsibility to protect” principle, Tourinho states perhaps most clearly the finding shared by all the contributors that while Brazil ultimately has few qualms about the normative content of the liberal order—of whose stability it recognizes itself as a major beneficiary—it rejects its own marginalization from meaningful participation in shaping that order. Togzhan Kassenova comes to a similar conclusion in her analysis of Brazil’s interaction with the global nuclear order. The country’s reluctance to embrace the Non-Proliferation Treaty has its roots in the accord’s double standard, enshrined in the division between nuclear “haves” and “have-nots.” Brazil itself faced strong international opposition to the development of its nuclear capacity, and has insistently pointed out the nuclear regime’s emphasis on nonproliferation over disarmament of existing capacities. These two contributions drive home with particular clarity the perceived dissonance between the normative content of the liberal order and the inequalities inherent in its implementation. This dichotomy lies at the heart of an understanding of Brazil’s position.
Eve Z. Bratman similarly identifies an instrumental approach in Brazil’s engagement with environmental issues. With environmentalist precepts losing out to state-led developmentalism in the domestic context, Brazil has supported the liberal order in this issue area precisely due to its inability to produce a rigidly applicable system of regulations; paradoxically, Brazil here finds itself benefiting from the very inequalities of implementation it criticizes elsewhere. The final two contributions, by Arturo Porzecanski and André Villela, focus on Brazilian economic policy; both are pessimistic about the extent of liberalism’s influence on the country’s policies. Porzecanski outlines how state-led developmentalism has left Brazil with a significantly smaller economic footprint—both quantitatively and in terms of trade integration—than would justify its ambitions. Villela neatly illustrates how this translated into a trade policy marked by a defensive skepticism regarding the opening of markets and regional integration.
Held together by a clear common focus throughout the volume, these contributions amount to a convincing picture of Brazil as a rising power that, while inclined to accept the normative foundations of the global liberal order, is held back from doing so by the inherent inequalities in the international system that interfere with their just implementation. Brazil on the Global Stage demonstrates neatly that rather than being ambivalent or inconsistent, this is a coherent and logical response to the ambiguities with which the order itself confronts a peripheral rising power.
