In this ambitious book, Carolyn Higbie attempts to bring together the endeavours of ancient collectors, scholars and forgers. H. amasses an array of evidence from literary and material culture in her quest to explore the social and intellectual contexts which were conducive to the production of fakes and forgeries. H.’s (acknowledged) debt to Anthony Grafton's Forgers and Critics: Creativity and Duplicity in Western Scholarship is patent, although H. goes beyond Grafton's scope by including forgeries of works of art.
H. opens with a literature review of the treatment of ancient fakes in modern classical scholarship, with a view to working towards a definition of forgery. This section has a cursory feel: Wolfgang Speyer's work appears briefly, only to disappear without trace in either footnotes or body text. H. deliberately avoids establishing a taxonomy of forgery, at least initially (cf. 125), and settles on a broad definition of forgery: namely, ‘an object or document that is not what it is said to be’ (13). This leaves H. scope to explore a wide range of texts and objects. But it means that we are not necessarily comparing like with like. As H. readily acknowledges, when it comes to forgeries, the intentions of the ‘forger’ matter, likewise the audience's expectations of a particular text or object. On a structural level, the almost exclusive focus on forgery and fakes in the introduction struck this reader as odd, given the plurality of themes which H. addresses.
From this beginning, H. sketches, in the first chapter, the activities of ancient collectors, ranging in time from Croesus to Lucian's fictional ‘ignorant book collector’. By way of this outline, H. makes two points about ancient collecting. First, that there evolved ideas of ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ ways to go about collecting: the right way was pursued by the scholarly inclined, whereas the alternative was the sort of hoarding that was characteristic of the military plunderer or social parvenu. Second, that wherever there was social cachet to be gained from collecting, there arose an environment conducive to the activities of forgers.
The following chapters consider the ideas of ‘visual’ forgeries and textual forgeries. Underpinning H.’s discussion of copies of Greek statuary is an interesting exploration of ancient connoisseurship, especially with respect to the attribution of works to individual sculptors and ancient ideas of art history, specifically that of the development of artistic styles. When H. turns to textual forgeries, H. develops the (Graftonian) theme of the connection between scholars and forgeries, in so far as successful forgers needed to have mastered the apparatus of literary or antiquarian scholarship. Yet there are diversions from her central theme, which make for a somewhat amorphous discussion: for example, H.’s excursion on counterfeit coins seems out of place in a chapter on textual forgeries.
Disappointingly, some lines of enquiry are left underdeveloped. H. devotes four pages to the Ephemerides of Alexander the Great, only to come to the conclusion that they are ‘probably’ fakes, and that they find a place in the narratives of Plutarch and Arrian because there was an expectation that authors quoted such texts (168). This is all very well (although H. does not say why only some historians and biographers of Alexander chose to cite these documents and not others), but surely it is important that there were documents purporting to be the Ephemerides in circulation during antiquity, as we know from other authorities that cite them. Moreover, the important question of why these documents may have been created is not addressed.
The final chapter begins with sketches of five ‘antiquarians’: the compilers of the Lindian Chronicle, Mucianus, Pliny the Elder, Phlegon of Tralles and finally Pausanias. H. sets herself the question of whether these antiquarians may be identified as being either ‘scholars, collectors, or forgers’ (194). Given how little is known about the activities or motivations of these men, this seems a barren line of enquiry, and it is perhaps for this reason that by the last of these sketches, H. does not provide an answer to her own question. Instead, H. jumps to the impact of the Trojan War cycle on the ways some ancient writers and antiquarians conceived and re-created the Heroic past, finishing up with discussion of two literary works, the playful ‘diary’ of Dictys Cretensis and Philostratus’ Heroicus. Here again the question of the definition of forgery is important. Certainly the diary and framing narrative around Dictys are fictitious, but there is no indication that its ancient readers would have treated it as something other than a work of fiction.
One comes away from this book feeling that there are three separate books trying to escape: a book on collectors, a book on forgeries and a book on Pausanias. The digressions drawn from Renaissance and early Modern history do little to aid exposition. For a book which aims to take in such a broad chronological and cultural sweep, there are some surprising omissions. The Historia Augusta (the author of which was clearly a collector, scholar and forger — a fourth-century Edmund Backhouse) is mentioned just once, with reference to the author's use of documentary evidence. Given H.’s chronological sweep, the complete absence of Jewish and Christian pseudepigrapha and apocrypha seems like a missed opportunity.
For a project as broad as the one attempted by H., to point out omissions may seem churlish. H. deserves respect for having the confidence to comment on such a diverse range of texts, and most readers will find something of interest in this Wunderkammer-like book. Yet, in the opinion of this reviewer, this book is ultimately unsatisfying, not because of what it does not say, but because what it does say feels too fragmented and diffuse to reveal something meaningful about attitudes towards either imposture or collecting, or the antiquarian trends in the cultures of the Classical world.
