Ludvig Lorenz (1829–1891) was a modest but highly accomplished Danish physicist who made significant contributions to optics, electrodynamics, molecular science and electrical measurement. He seems to have been happy in his work, but he had the misfortune, so far as his later scientific reputation was concerned, of being overshadowed by some of the leading physicists of his time, particularly James Clerk Maxwell, Lord Rayleigh and H.A. Lorentz, all of whom achieved results that overlapped with Lorenz's own. As Helge Kragh details in this straightforward scientific biography, recognition of Lorenz's contributions has suffered especially from confusion with Lorentz, the similarity both of their names and of their work leading many later physicists, in a variant of Robert Merton's ‘Matthew effect’, to give the more famous Dutch physicist credit for results that Lorenz had found years earlier. Thus we find recent references to the ‘Lorentz–Lorenz formula’ relating the index of refraction of a substance to its density, to the ‘Lorentz number’ relating thermal and electrical conductivities, and to the ‘Lorentz gauge’ in electromagnetic theory. In each case, Lorenz was the first to publish a result that Lorentz later derived independently or developed more fully. Kragh is perhaps overly punctilious in insisting on Lorenz's right to eponymous credit on the basis of his priority in publication, even in cases such as the ‘Lorentz gauge’ where it is clear that later developments in fact stemmed from the work of the Dutch physicist rather than from that of his Danish counterpart. But given the degree to which Lorenz's achievements have been overlooked or forgotten, we can perhaps forgive a little such special pleading on his behalf.
Both Lorenz and Lorentz had the disadvantage of working in relative isolation in small countries (though later in his career Lorentz became remarkably cosmopolitan), and some of the most important writings of both men initially appeared in languages that few outside those countries could read. Both compensated for this by publishing many of their principal papers in French or German and arranging for others to be translated into those languages or into English. But some of Lorenz's writings fell through the cracks, notably his last major paper, an exhaustive theoretical analysis of the scattering of light by a sphere that he completed in 1890, just a year before his death. Written in Danish and published by the Royal Danish Academy, it attracted no attention at the time and very little when a French translation of it later appeared in an edition of Lorenz's collected works. Lorenz's work on scattering theory only came to be appreciated decades later, long after most of his results had been independently derived by Rayleigh in England and Gustav Mie in Germany.
The electrical theory of light that Lorenz published in 1867 did not suffer from neglect on grounds of language; after appearing initially in Danish, it was quickly translated into both German and English. But while it introduced some remarkable ideas, particularly a gauge that implied the use of retarded potentials (though Lorenz did not use either term), the theory had little effect on later work, in part because of doubts about its physical basis – Lorenz treated space as electrically conductive – and in part because Lorenz himself never followed up on it. In any case, Lorenz's theory was almost wholly overshadowed by the electromagnetic theory of light that Maxwell had devised a few years earlier.
In his subtitle, Kragh identifies Lorenz as a theoretical physicist, and he devotes much of the book to detailing Lorenz's elaborate mathematical analyses of optical, electrical and molecular phenomena. But as Kragh notes, Lorenz was also a skilled experimenter, fully at home in the laboratory and a master of precision measurement. Indeed, the work for which Lorenz was most highly regarded in his own time was an ingenious spinning disc apparatus he devised in the 1870s to measure electrical resistance in absolute units – that is, to determine the ohm. Rayleigh later adopted Lorenz's method in place of the one William Thomson had devised and Maxwell had carried out in the 1860s, and a revised form of it long remained the preferred way to make absolute resistance measurements. In the late 1870s and 1880s Lorenz also delved into what Kragh calls ‘the practical and more mundane aspects of physics’ (p. 182), designing an improved dynamo and an inductively loaded telephone cable, though the latter was not carried into practice. Lorenz's work on loading was based solely on the line equations, and so differed from the more comprehensive and eventually more fruitful theory of loading that Oliver Heaviside founded on Maxwellian field ideas.
The ultimate purpose of a biography is to illuminate the character of an individual. Kragh's book focuses almost entirely on Lorenz's scientific work, and in this case that seems appropriate. The sources on Lorenz's personal life are notably thin, and Kragh covers most of them in his opening chapter, tracing Lorenz's childhood as the son of a small-town grocer, his early interest in mathematics and physics, his training at the Polytechnic in Copenhagen, and the beginning of his career teaching at the Danish military academy. Thereafter Lorenz's inner life, to the extent we can recover it at all, appears to have focused almost entirely on his pursuit of the scientific questions that fascinated him. As Kragh observes (p. 237), ‘Not only was Lorenz not career-minded, he also seems to have been content with working in problem areas for the sole reason that they interested him. If others failed to share his interest, he did not care very much’. While he would no doubt be pleased to find himself the subject of such a meticulous biography, and gratified by Kragh's efforts to secure him proper credit for his achievements, one suspects that Lorenz found the real reward of his work simply in doing it.
