Sune Haugbolle's War and Memory in Lebanon is a thorough and well-crafted study of the cultural production of memory of the Lebanese Civil War between 1990 and 2005. Rather than an effort to recuperate “what happened,” Haugbolle's focus is on how people—and in particular the political and intellectual elite—represent what happened. In other words, War and Memory in Lebanon is an ethnography of the institutions and elite actors that produce memory, often in relation to ideas about national identity or a specific sectarian community. Haugbolle draws on a wide range of texts including newspaper retrospectives, art exhibitions, films, novels, music, graffiti, and urban signage. For the most part, he avoids falling into the common trap of overcelebratory depictions of left-leaning art forms. Instead, he develops a critique of nostalgia in all its registers while not losing empathy for its projects. He successfully highlights the multivalence of nostalgia itself in the context of Lebanese public constructions of postwar memory or memory cultures.
Throughout the book, Haugbolle deconstructs the social imaginary that constitutes the Lebanese nation through memory cultures, arguing that it is in the negotiation of identity itself that one can get a sense of what is “Lebanese.” His introduction includes a summation of the different historical narratives about the war, providing a useful reference to the postwar production of information and memory. Here his frank and critical treatment of the dominant mythologies of the war, including the narrative of sectarianism and the idea that it was merely “a war of others,” is especially welcome. Rather than simply refuting such statements, Haugbolle unravels them, providing a cogent political analysis of the production and origins of various narratives. He is careful to allot complexity to all perspectives and to place them into conversation with one another while working (it seems) to present as “objective” a view as possible. This adds to the value of the text as a reference, though one at times wishes that a bit more assessment and valuation (indeed, critique) entered his analyses. As is, War and Memory in Lebanon is an excellent road map for Lebanese intellectual debates on memory but not one that positions the author within those debates, for better or worse.
The second chapter begins with a historical overview of the civil war, which would be useful to the nonspecialist or readers unfamiliar with the subject. The idea that one can provide such an overview, however, seems at odds with Haugbolle's project of analyzing the multiple and overlapping memory cultures that produce this history in the first place. The chapter recovers with an excellent discussion of shifting media and public spheres in relation to rapid social change and narratives about the war produced during the war itself. These narratives are important to his later argument that many postwar memory cultures have their roots in cultural production begun while the war raged on.
The following three chapters form the core of the book. Haugbolle analyzes reconstruction narratives of the early 1990s and the perpetual assumptions of rampant amnesia that dominated that decade. Particularly interesting here is his discussion of how “culture” emerged as a substitute for history and memory. This took place through a consumerist nostalgia for an imagined Lebanese past, epitomized most blatantly but not exclusively by Solidere's downtown. To a certain extent, he also addresses memories of participation in the violence as well as localized sectarian productions of public memory. The latter emerge through a comparative analysis of urban iconography and graffiti, which not only adds a new dimension to the book but also leads to a set of unaddressed questions about spatiality and the ways that daily encounters with spaces of memory shape memory cultures and lived experiences.
War and Memory in Lebanon concludes by addressing more recent territory, including the so-called independence intifada that followed Hariri's assassination in 2005. One of the highlights here is Haugbolle's thoughtful analysis of discourses of “truth” in relation to their political contexts and deployments. This is even more striking as I write this review in August 2010, with the “results” of the commission investigating Hariri's assassination threatening revelation and provoking a new round of rhetorical memory games in the political sphere. This careful discussion of truth and of international truth and reconciliation commissions is one of the strengths of this book, as it leads to an analysis of why such a model is not necessarily applicable to the Lebanese case. Another of the book's strengths is Haugbolle's moments of deeper historicization, which remind the reader that postconflict resolution in Lebanon has a history extending beyond 1974 and which locate his work in a longer trajectory of historical scholarship on Lebanon.
Haugbolle's discussions in War and Memory in Lebanon are consistently embedded in a rich and eclectic theoretical apparatus, invoking memory studies, anthropology, psychology, philosophy, history, and cultural studies. Most of the time, this is interdisciplinary work at its best. Yet the author's own perspectives and arguments are occasionally lost in a citational labyrinth; this same quality is one of the elements that lead me to suggest this book as a valuable addition to graduate seminars on memory and history. The theoretical apparatus of memory studies from which Haugbolle draws owes much to European cultural studies and, in particular, post World War II studies of memory and history in Europe. This framework determines to a certain extent the sorts of cultural texts Haugbolle chooses as well as the limits of his analysis. The Lebanese case more closely approximates that of Belfast than that of post World War II Europe (or postapartheid South Africa, for that matter) in terms of how the postconflict world is lived and experienced in daily life. Here the book's focus on memory cultures rather than memories detracts from its ability to address civil war memory in Lebanon beyond the political-economic and intellectual elite. We do get glimpses of memory writ small through ethnographic moments, and indeed we are promised such glimpses in the book's opening, where Haugbolle tells of an interaction he had with his adoptive family in Lebanon about memory of the war. However, this feels a bit like an unfulfilled promise, as War and Memory in Lebanon provides neither an ethnography of personal memory of the war nor an analysis of the ways in which war memory is lived on a daily basis. As an anthropologist, I would have liked to see more of mundane memory, so to speak, and of the social contexts in which memory cultures are embedded.
Despite this shortcoming (and indeed, it is unfair to ask of books that they fulfill one's own disciplinary preferences), War and Memory in Lebanon is at once a thoughtful analysis of postwar memory cultures in a local case and an analysis of postconflict memory cultures more broadly. The book should be of interest to scholars of Lebanon and the Middle East as well as scholars interested in memory and conflict. It would work well in graduate seminars and courses on the Lebanese civil war or contemporary Lebanese history and society.
