The anthology of essays Angels in the American Theater: Patrons, Patronage, and Philanthropy is organized around the argument that “investors and backers with money … have played a monumental role in shaping and developing the American theater” (1). While the certainty of this premise is undoubtedly beyond question to anyone familiar with the history and practice of theatre in the United States, the subject has been all but ignored in scholarly circles. As editor Robert A. Schanke points out in his Introduction, outside of work focused on the funding models used by the Federal Theatre Project and the NEA, “research and writing on the history of arts philanthropy is meager and of fairly recent practice” (1). Fortunately, the contributors to this collection go a long way toward addressing this omission.
Comprised of sixteen essays, Angels in the American Theater is divided into two parts: “Individual Angels” and “Institutional Angels.” While all the contributors deal with the histories, peculiarities, and vagaries of various and particular individuals and organizations, all also shed light on how philanthropy and patronage in the United States are uniquely formed and carried out and, moreover, fundamentally different from European arts-funding models. This overarching theme is initiated with Schanke's Introduction, which in part serves to chart the U.S. practice of arts funding and show how that venture has been shaped by the nation's history and culture—most clearly by capitalist economics and often concomitant landmark legal decisions (particularly state and federal tax laws) that have variously encouraged and discouraged giving. Such information helps to contextualize the choices made by various individuals and institutions, discussed in the subsequent chapters, to lend (and sometimes not) financial support for theatre making. For example, in Theresa Collins's excellent essay, German émigré and financier Otto H. Kahn's numerous forays into the theatre in the first decades of the twentieth century are positioned as concurrently altruistic, artistically daring, and financially savvy. Similarly, the philanthropic efforts of the Ford, MacArthur, Humana, and Rockefeller foundations—smartly explicated in the essays by Sheila McNerney Anderson, Bruce Kirle, Jeffrey Ullom, and Stephen D. Berwind, respectively—are shown to be activities that are equally benevolent to the artist(s) and society writ large, and advantageous to the public image, if not the bottom line, of the umbrella (usually, corporate) institution. Thus, while the philanthropic activities explicated are by and large extolled and celebrated by the volume's contributors, there is, nonetheless, a recurrent recognition that many of these efforts were (and continue to be) complex and, frequently, not wholly selfless acts. In the end, then, the greatest achievement of the contributors is their collective ability to situate these acts of philanthropy within the intricate matrix of living social relations.
While the whole of the anthology stands as a significant contribution, the number of quality essays in the first section is especially impressive. Collins's essay on Kahn is one such highlight. Centering on the thesis that Kahn's philanthropic endeavors were primarily “important because [they] secured a legacy of transatlantic modernism that prefigures globalism and still challenges us to think as much about cosmopolitanism as about nationalism and localism in modern histories,” Collins demonstrates how it was not only Kahn's financial acumen but also his predilection for European modern art that played a determining role in the noncommercial theatre movement in the United States in the 1910s, 1920s, and 1930s (22). Similarly persuasive are Jennifer Schlueter's essay on the relationship between playwright Charles Mee and patrons Richard B. and Jeanne Donovan Fisher, and John R. Poole's explication of David Geffen's efforts to support live theatre, both on Broadway and in Los Angeles. In the former, Schlueter offers a balanced consideration of the Fisher's “no strings attached” support of Mee, and deftly reflects on how that backing may have both positively and negatively informed the development of Mee's aesthetic. In the latter, Poole contemplates Geffen's patronage, linking the entertainment industry mogul's slow, constant, and ever-growing support of theatre to a lifelong love of Broadway, a late-life acceptance of his gay identity, and AIDS advocacy. Both Poole and Schlueter powerfully demonstrate the capacity of an individual's backing to shape American theatre.
As a final highpoint from the first section, in his essay contribution Schanke takes a slightly different tack, focusing on not one but three individuals who funded a single artist, Eva Le Gallienne: patrons Alice De Lamar, Mary Bok, and Otto Kahn. Most compelling here is not Schanke's careful review of how the support Le Gallienne received from these individuals was first issued, but instead his moving description of how the funding from all was subsequently withdrawn—and how those difficult decisions had little to do with the faith the patrons had in the artist's work, and everything to do with external forces, primarily the whims of the capitalist market. Though now some eighty years removed from her experience, the problems faced by Le Gallienne seem alarmingly current in an era when individual and corporate purse strings are tightening.
While the second part of the anthology, “Institutional Angels,” is perhaps a bit uneven compared to the first, it nonetheless includes a handful of excellent essays, principally those by Anderson, Kirle, Ullom, and Berwind. From Anderson's well-argued demonstration of how the funding policy of the Ford Foundation became the model “replicated by other funding organizations that followed suit and persists even today” (174), through Berwind's convincing description of how the Rockefeller Foundation's ardent support of new work has helped reshape the definition of theatre, the impact institutional giving has on theatre making in America becomes abundantly clear. Nonetheless, what is most striking in this part is the way in which the labors of a number of individuals working for and within larger institutions—for instance, W. McNeil Lowry with the Ford Foundation, or Joan Shigekawa with Rockefeller—are drawn to the fore in the authors' narratives and, subsequently, shown to be crucial to the process of shaping American theatre. Thus, even the “Institutional Angels” are given a human face.
Accessible and thought-provoking, Angels in the American Theater is a foundational work on the subject of theatre patrons, patronage, and philanthropy. Other scholars focused on exploring the business of theatre, as well as the ways that economics intersects with art making, will find the volume invaluable. More broadly, however, it seems fair to posit that anyone concerned with the ways material conditions have influenced and continue to influence theatre practice in America will want to read this volume and consider its arguments.
