In her book, Sujatha Fernandes offers a thick description of barrio life in Venezuela that unsettles our image of the paradigmatic “Chavistas” as emotionally charged government dupes. Chavistas come to life, here, as maternal community caretakers, radical popular historians, and sober cultural warriors who are just as willing to defend their autonomy from the state as their honor from the opposition. Who Can Stop the Drums? identifies new cleavages in contemporary Venezuela. Shifting attention away from the conflict between the forces for and against Chávez, it reveals conflict between barrio Chavistas and state administrators over the logics, not just the policies, of the state. But this book does more than bring into focus new axes of conflict within Venezuelan politics.
Fernandes forges a new and promising analytical approach to the study of social movements: that of examining the “everyday wars of position.” In arriving at this approach, she eschews the narrow scope of much social movement scholarship, intent on explaining mobilization against state policy. Instead, she frames her query by first considering which forms of collective action are most likely to bring about change. Steeped in Antonio Gramsci's theory of social change, she argues the marginalized contest subordination by engaging in “wars of position” over cultural identity and representation, that is, by advancing “counterhegemonies.” But like James Scott, Fernandes contends that it is in the everyday life of the urban poor, not just the extraordinary events of mass mobilization, that people often contest their marginalization. The movements of cultural identity in which the poor affirm the importance of their everyday lived experience, she posits, demand investigation precisely because they lay the foundation for an effective class struggle.
Fernandes's analytical focus on cultural politics allows her to push far beyond the instrumental interest in antineoliberalism, typically postulated as the urban poor's rationale for supporting the region's many antineoliberal presidents. On the basis of extensive ethnographic research carried out over the course of several years, she reveals that Caracas's urban poor understand their poverty as just one dimension of their marginality. Equally subordinating have been the negative racial stereotypes long dominant but obscured by the euphemistic proclamation of Venezuela as a mixed-race society. Thus, radio hosts and muralists reenvision their origins as that of the forgotten indigenous chiefs and the African slaves who contested subordination by Venezuela's Creole elite. These cultural warriors, she establishes, understand that in contesting the dominant notion of who the barrio resident is, they expand the discursive basis for asserting their rights. They appreciate that Chávez, too, values this battlefront.
The author's close reading of her barrio-based cultural protagonists illuminates several fronts of these everyday wars of position. In redefining the barrio as a key site of marginalization deserving of restoration and celebration, residents counter the maligning of their neighborhoods by mass media and civil society as violent and uncivilized. But she also discovers that the urban poor find themselves at odds with a state they otherwise endorse. These conflicts arise from what she refers to as the “hybrid postneoliberal” Venezuelan state. Fernandes draws on Michel Foucault's more diffuse notions of power to argue that we should look not just at the state's explicit policy but also at the state's underlying logic. Such an analysis reveals a state that rejects neoliberal policies but retains neoliberal “rationalities.” These are the logics of regulating society that privilege technocratic rationales. With this concept, she cuts through various caricatures of Venezuela's state today. She also calls our attention to a particularly pernicious constraint on nations that attempt to assert greater national autonomy in defining their relationship to the world economy than the scions of global capitalism would otherwise permit.
The best evidence that the urban poor contest these neoliberal rationalities comes from Fernandes's pathbreaking research on community radio stations. While the state promotes these grassroots media outlets as a bulwark against the powerful private media in Venezuela, its regulation of the sector remains bound by the neoliberal rationalities of monitoring the private sector. It is the state's insistence that stations form a corporation and formally justify their service by a technical rationale under which these radio stations chafe. The protagonists of the coalition against the state's plan to mine on indigenous lands, however, seemed less concerned with the state's rationality than with its explicitly neoliberal policy. Indeed, this conflict underscores the fundamental contradiction of a state attempting to build twenty-first-century socialism even as it remains locked into the global economy as a producer of natural resources. It therefore raises a question: What is the relationship between the struggle against neoliberal rationalities and the struggle against neoliberal economic policies? Would Fernandes posit that the front on neoliberal rationalities paves the way for a more effective movement capable of holding the state accountable for its more ambitious vision of economic transformation? If so, would she go so far as to argue that the struggle against neoliberal rationalities is primary?
Fernandes also recasts the urban poor as political agents adept at navigating state control—the other face of this hybrid state. She substantiates this important and contested claim in several ways. First, she authenticates her contemporary movements of cultural identity as autonomous from state mandates with her historical survey of Venezuela's urban social movements. She traces the origins of contemporary barrio-based cultural projects to a “cultural revival” of the late 1970s and a long tradition of barrio residents self-consciously resisting the instrumental logic of clientelist exchange (that of material benefits for party loyalty). Second, she looks at the universe of cultural movements, instead of just those cases that receive state funding, as others have done. Thus, she finds that many radio stations and festival organizers reject state funding, while others actively offset state financing with community fund-raising. Third, her rich ethnographic data allows her to support her more ambitious claim that the barrio's protagonists contest the state's logic of promoting a certain notion of national identity. Instead, she finds, they paint murals and celebrate religious festivals that draw on “racially defined and historically invisible national cults” (p. 157) to affirm their barrio-based shared history.
Ironically, Fernandes reveals these urban cultural warriors to be more effective as a bulwark against neoliberalism than against clientelism. We see this most clearly in a failed attempt to transform a defunct neighborhood theater into a community center. This lofty goal evaporated, as a cadre of leaders used it to launch their own political careers.
Those interested in how to “deepen” democracy such that government officials are held accountable to their noblest rather than their baser aspirations should take notice of this book. Given the disadvantage of the poor within civil society, as Jon Shefner (The Illusion of Civil Society, 2008) has similarly argued, Fernandes enjoins us not to be so quick to dismiss movements that accept state funding. We should be less concerned with whether an organization receives state funding and more willing to tackle the empirically challenging task of evaluating how a collective endeavor asserts its autonomy from the state. If others take up Fernandes's research agenda, we will be rewarded with greater insight into the dynamics of contention within clientelism and revolution.
