Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:10:16.688Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Secondary flows induced by two-dimensional surface temperature heterogeneity in stably stratified channel flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 August 2023

T. Bon*
Affiliation:
Mechanical Engineering, KU Leuven, Celestijnenlaan 300, 3001 Leuven, Belgium
D. Broos
Affiliation:
Mechanical Engineering, KU Leuven, Celestijnenlaan 300, 3001 Leuven, Belgium
R.B. Cal
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Materials Engineering, Portland State University, Portland, OR 97201, USA
J. Meyers
Affiliation:
Mechanical Engineering, KU Leuven, Celestijnenlaan 300, 3001 Leuven, Belgium
*
†Email address for correspondence: thijs.bon@kuleuven.be

Abstract

The structure and impact of thermally induced secondary motions in stably stratified channel flows with two-dimensional surface temperature inhomogeneities is studied using direct numerical simulation (DNS). Starting from a configuration with only spanwise varying surface temperature, where the streamwise direction is homogeneous (Bon & Meyers, J. Fluid Mech., 2022, pp. 1–38), we study cases where the periodic temperature strip length $l_x/h$ (with $h$ the half-channel height) assumes finite values. The patch width ($l_y/h =\{{\rm \pi} /4, {\rm \pi}/8$}) and length are varied at fixed stability and two different Reynolds numbers. Results indicate that for the investigated patch widths, the streamwise development of the secondary flows depends on the patch aspect ratio ($a=l_x/l_y$), while they reach a fully developed state after approximately $25l_y$. The strength of the secondary motions, and their impact on momentum and heat transfer through the dispersive fluxes, is strongly reduced as the length of the temperature strips decreases, and becomes negligible when $a\lesssim 1$. We demonstrate that upward dispersive and turbulent heat transport in locally unstably stratified regions above the high-temperature patches lead to reduced overall downward heat transfer. Comparison to local Monin–Obukhov similarity theory (MOST) reveals that scaled velocity and temperature gradients in homogeneous stably stratified channel flow at $Re_\tau =550$ agree reasonably well with empirical correlations obtained from meteorological data. For thermally heterogeneous cases with strips of finite length, the similarity functions only collapse higher above the surface, where dispersive fluxes are negligible. Lastly, we show that mean profiles of all simulations collapse when using outer-layer scaling based on displacement thickness.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic overview of stable channel flow set-up with inhomogeneous surface temperatures.(a) Spanwise heterogeneous, streamwise homogeneous as in Bon & Meyers (2022), characterized by spanwise wavelength $\lambda _y$. (b) Two-dimensional (spanwise and streamwise) heterogeneous surface temperatures, defined by wavelengths $(\lambda _x, \lambda _y)$ or patch dimensions $(l_x, l_y)$.

Figure 1

Table 1.Overview of simulations. Computational domains (CDs) are further specified in table 2. Presented layout parameters are streamwise and spanwise wavelengths $\lambda _x/h$ and $\lambda _y/h$ (as in figure 1), wavenumbers $k_xh$ and $k_yh$, and aspect ratio $a = \lambda _x/\lambda _y$. Resulting global flow quantities are also provided: bulk Reynolds and Richardson numbers, stability parameter, skin friction coefficient, Nusselt number and volume-averaged dispersive kinetic energy. See §§ 2 and 3.2 for definitions.

Figure 2

Table 2.Details on the computational domain (CD) size and grid resolution. $L_x, L_y, L_z$ refers to the streamwise, spanwise and vertical dimensions, $N_x, N_y, N_z$ to the number of grid points in each dimension, and $\Delta x^+$, $\Delta y^+$ and $\Delta z^+$ to the grid spacing in wall units. ${T_{av}u_\tau }/{h}$ denotes the time period used to calculate statistics in each domain.

Figure 3

Figure 2.(a,c,e,g) Layout X8Y0.25, (b,d, f,h) layout X8Y0.5. (a,b) Time- and phase-averaged isosurfaces of signed swirling strength $\bar {\varLambda }_{ci}$. Contour levels are 10 % of the maximum and minimum values, while colours indicate positive (yellow) and negative (green) values. Bottom and side planes indicate potential temperature reduced with its horizontal average ($\bar {\theta }''=\bar {\theta } - \langle \bar {\theta }\rangle$). (c–h) Time- and phase-averaged $yz$-planes of signed swirling strength, at $x=2.5{\rm \pi}, 4{\rm \pi}$ and $5.5{\rm \pi}$, as also indicated in (a,b). Vectors are constructed from mean spanwise and vertical velocity. Red and blue lines at the bottom correspond to high and low surface temperature. Note that the spanwise axes are reversed to have them aligned with the 3-D plots in (a,b). The aspect ratio in all plots is 4:1:1.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Ratio of (a) integrated cross-stream velocity $\varPsi$ and (b) vorticity $\varOmega _x$ with respect to the equivalent streamwise homogeneous case. The $x$-axis starts at the location of a streamwise transition $x_t$ and is scaled with patch width $l_y$. Only one patch is shown, such that the length of the lines corresponds to the patch aspect ratio $a$. Blue lines indicate surface layouts with $\lambda _y/h = {\rm \pi}/4$, red lines $\lambda _y/h = {\rm \pi}/2$ and dashed lines represent cases with $Re_\tau =550$. Darker lines illustrate longer patches (larger $\lambda _x/h$).

Figure 5

Figure 4.(a) Skin friction coefficient $C_f$ and (b) Nusselt number Nu as a function of surface wavenumber ratio $k_x/k_y$, normalized by the value from the corresponding homogeneous simulations. (c) Dispersive contributions to skin friction coefficient and (d) Nusselt number, relative to the total value.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Horizontal phase- and time-averaged planes at $z/h = 0.1$ for layout X8Y0.5 with $Re_\tau = 180$. Black dashed lines indicate boundaries of underlying temperature patches. (a) Spatial fluctuations of potential temperature, (b) vertical and (c) streamwise velocity. (d,e,f) Laminar, turbulent and dispersive heat flux. (g,h,i) Laminar, turbulent and dispersive momentum flux.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Horizontally averaged profiles of (a) streamwise normal stresses and (b) temperature variances, for cases with $Re_\tau =180$ and $\lambda _y/h = {\rm \pi}/2$. The full lines in (a) represent the total velocity stress (dispersive $+$ turbulent), while in (b), full lines denote only the turbulent fluctuations. Dashed lines show dispersive variances. In (b), the left ordinate belongs to dispersive component (dashes) and the right ordinate to turbulent component (full lines). Inset in (b) shows zoom of dispersive temperature variance, where the arrow indicates the direction of increasing temperature patch length.

Figure 8

Figure 7.(a) Local Obukhov length as a function of wall distance. (b) Mapping of stability parameter $z/\varLambda$ onto wall distance $z/h$. Similarity functions for (c) momentum and (d) heat. Coloured dashed lines indicate calculations without dispersive fluxes. Grey dashed lines in (a,b) represent limits for $z/h$ that have been used for data in (c,d). Light dashed lines in (c,d) depict empirical linear relation $1+4.7z/\varLambda$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.(a) Scaled velocity deficit and (b) temperature deficit, with outer scaling parameters based on displacement thickness following Zagarola & Smits (1998) and Wang & Castillo (2003). Simulations with $Re_\tau =180$ (full lines) and $Re_\tau =550$ (dashed lines). Red indicates cases heterogeneous surface temperature and black lines are homogeneous simulations.

Figure 10

Table 3.Overview of simulations that have been performed to address the sensitivity to surface temperature smoothing and grid resolution. $\sigma _s$ refers to the standard deviation used in the Gaussian filter kernel that is used to smooth the surface temperature, as described in the text. $\Delta _\alpha$ denotes the relative difference of $\alpha$ with respect to the reference case.

Figure 11

Figure 9.Streamwise development of (a) vertical velocity and (b) potential temperature at the first grid point above the surface at the centreline of the $xy$-plane (i.e. at $y=2{\rm \pi}$). The $x-$axis is centred around one cold–hot transition, and expressed in viscous units.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Spanwise profiles of (a) vertical velocity and (b) potential temperature at the first grid point above the surface at the centreline of the $xy$-plane (i.e. at $x=4{\rm \pi}$). The $y$-axis is centred around the spanwise centre of the domain, and expressed in viscous units.

Figure 13

Figure 11.Horizontally averaged (a) velocity and (b) potential temperature profiles for cases with $Re_\tau =180$ and $\lambda _y/h={\rm \pi} /2$. Grey dashed line indicates $u^+ = z^+$. (c,d) Horizontally averaged profiles of turbulent (full lines), dispersive (dashed lines) and viscous (dash-dotted lines) (c) flux of momentum and (d) heat. Arrows indicate direction of increasing streamwise wavelength $\lambda _x/h$, while the grey dashed line in (c) represents the expected linear profile of total shear stress.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Same as figure 11, but for $Re_\tau =550$.

Figure 15

Figure 13.Same as figure 6, but for simulations with $Re_\tau =550$.