Awarded the Joseph W. Elder Prize in the Indian Social Sciences, Ramnarayan Rawat's Reconsidering Untouchability charts a new trajectory for scholarship on Dalits in North India. Rawat engages two scholarly tasks. The first task is to interrogate how the Chamar caste came to be associated almost exclusively with leatherwork. The second task is to reclaim Dalit agency in historical narratives of “untouched” (acchut) identity movements. Ramnarayan Rawat succeeds admirably on both counts.
Rawat provocatively opens the discussion with reference to the murder of five members of the Chamars caste who were stoned to death for purportedly poisoning cattle so that they could profit from tanning the hides. This association between Chamars, leatherwork, and criminality has a long history that Rawat dissects in order to challenge the dominant framework equating caste with hereditary occupation—an “analytic framework” that has only served “to obscure and erase history” (p. 6).
Chapter 1 considers how Chamars were accused of poisoning cattle with arsenic in nineteenth-century India. Chamars were involved in “containing and controlling cattle diseases” (p. 46) through a variety of ritual remedies. Arsenic was applied medicinally in North Indian villages, and evidence suggests that Chamars may have used arsenic to kill abandoned or sickly cattle. But, as Rawat makes clear, Chamars were often scapegoated on the basis of nonexistent evidence and constructed as “criminal” by colonial authorities with the complicity of the Hindu middle classes. The stereotype of the Chamar as a leatherworker and landless laborer is addressed in chapter 2. Here Rawat presents a description of the role of Chamars in the rural economy of nineteenth-century India. Chamars were skilled cultivators, and many were not landless in the conventional sense. Most crucial are Rawat's overall points that Chamars “occupied a range of vocations” and that “their untouchable status … did not necessarily map to the social world” (p. 74). As Rawat persuasively argues in chapter 3, the association between Chamars and leatherwork was a colonial construction, actuated by the establishment of leatherworking schools exclusively for Chamars. In any case, for those Chamars involved in the leather trade, the qasba, not the village, was the locus of activity.
The remaining two chapters of the monograph consider Chamar efforts to articulate a new identity for themselves as a basis for political and social action. Chapter 4 examines two strategies that the Chamar community pursued before Indian independence. The first was to claim Kshatriya rank—an effort that intersected with the activism of the Arya Samaj. The second was to claim “Adi-Hindu” status. This movement's primary intellectual voice belonged to Jigyasu, a non-Dalit, who argued that that contemporary Dalits were heirs to the original Indian civilization that was destroyed by invading Aryans. As Rawat points out, Jigyasu's vision, and the movements inspired by it, laid the foundation for a more inclusive sense of Dalit identity as “untouched,” rather than “untouchable.” The final chapter considers the rise of political activism among Chamars. A central pivot was the Poona Pact of 1932 in which Dalit leader Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar compromised the demand for separate electorates for untouchables. The protest against the pact galvanized many of the organizations advocating for Dalit rights, particularly the Adi-Hindu Mahasabha and the Scheduled Caste Federation. Rawat also discusses the formation of the Republican Party and suggests that understanding it as “class-based” distracts our attention from how Chamars used the party to make alliances with other social groups “without diluting their commitment to an acchut identity” (p. 178).
Rawat concludes his study by reflecting on the state of contemporary Indian historiography. Observing that the “central dichotomy of colonialism and nationalism” has effectively cut off the voices of Chamars and Dalits, Rawat argues that Chamars are “historical actors who have themselves questioned the dominant mainstream assumptions concerning their society and history” (p. 190). In its extensive archival research and attention to Dalit writings in Hindi, Reconsidering Untouchability opens a scholarly space for appreciating Dalit intellectual and political agency. It also raises important ethical issues for scholarship on Dalit communities. In the middle of his monograph, Rawat briefly reflects on being asked how he could understand “what it means to be an ‘untouchable’ in Hindu India?” (p. 122). Reconsidering Untouchability is a sensitive and nuanced response to this challenge; it stands in its own right as an important contribution to contemporary scholarship on Chamar and Dalit communities. But space still remains for Ramnarayan Rawat to reflect, both more personally and more broadly, on the relationship between history, historians, and the putative subjects of historiography. Reconsidering Untouchability is a dialogue that has just begun.
