Cabinets of curiosities became the objects of renewed scholarly attention in the mid-1980s, and have been the subject of numerous worthy studies since then in both art history and the history of science. Ken Arnold's long-awaited monograph (which originated in his ground-breaking 1992 Ph.D. dissertation) is set apart from the main body of this work by three elements: an English focus, the juxtaposition of past and present, and the lack of illustrations.
Beyond what is known on the Royal Society's repository and the Tradescants' collection, there is little available material on English cabinets. First and foremost Cabinets for the Curious fills this lacuna, extending our understanding to the wider nation. Arnold's cast of characters includes not only established figures such as Hans Sloane, Robert Plot and Ralph Thoresby, but also a host of less visible preparators, curators and collectors. The book is largely devoted to a typological arrangement of the kinds of objects to be found in English cabinets, including natural-historical items, coins, exotica and materia medica. These chapters are impressively rich in primary detail, as Arnold submerges the reader in the world of sixteenth- and seventeenth-century British scholarship and culture. They are arranged into a loose chronology based around three ‘traditions’ Arnold discerns in the use of objects in cabinets, each a different way of rendering things into ideas. In the first, ‘narrative’, tradition, the cabinet specimen was embedded in a story. Here Arnold discusses natural history and numismatics, and how scholars wove dense county histories with such objects. By contrast, in the second, ‘functional’, tradition, knowledge was generated by using objects. Arnold explores at length the manufacture, trade and utility of exotic material, and the range of items, from plants to mummies, that was applied for therapeutic purposes. Finally, in discussing the ‘taxonomic’ tradition, Arnold shows how curators gleaned information by comparison, by ordering and arranging objects. This latter mode of arrangement was to become dominant in the following centuries. Overall, this tripartite structure is convincing, once Arnold acknowledges that the same objects could be used in multiple and overlapping traditions and were to become useful beyond the English context.
Innovative as his arrangement of the primary material may be, it is on Arnold's use of historical material to inform current museum practice that this book will stand or fall. Capping each of the three sections of the book devoted to these traditions are discursive chapters which seek to derive what he terms ‘icon lessons’ for the present. In each case, the seventeenth-century story is used as a launch pad to explore modern museological concerns. There are few museum professionals who have the historical skills (and few historians with the museum skills) to carry this off; Arnold, curator and historian, does so artfully. The question is whether he should. How profitable is it to ask whether we can ‘return to wonder’ – in its particular early modern manifestation as a disciplined form of curiosity – which he argues was lost with the rise of the Enlightenment museum? Rather than trying ‘to re-examine what went wrong in the eighteenth century in order possibly to alleviate some of our current ennui’ (p. 7), it may be that we never ‘lost’ this sort of wonder in the first place. And even if we did lose it, can we recapture the same wonder when contemporary encounters with museum objects – visual or haptic – operate in very different sensory regimes, and when contemporary re-creations of ‘cabinets of curiosity’ exist in such radically different contexts to their forebears? The wonder of seventeenth-century audiences, as Arnold acknowledges, is far removed from our own affective responses. These speculative reservations aside, Arnold's is a commendably practical use of history. Cabinets for the Curious will bring an arcane topic to new audiences and generate novel applications of the history of collections. This will be welcome in an increasingly self-reflexive museum sector.
Just as there are advantages and disadvantages to Arnold's juxtaposition of past and present, so the presentation of the book has benefits and drawbacks. The complete lack of images (beyond the cover plate) is striking for a topic that is usually presented in highly illustrated publications. Then again, the handful of standard images of continental European cabinets that survive have been over-reproduced, and there is a dearth of contemporary illustrations of British cabinets. Too often accounts of cabinets fetishize these images, revelling uncritically in their miscellaneous content. In eschewing such an approach, Arnold encourages us to concentrate on viewing, rather than on what is viewed. He is able to unpick what was going on around and behind the cabinets, to complement the extant literature on collecting with a more comprehensive account of the use of the objects. For this emphasis on museum practice alone, down to the detail of Nehemiah Grew's cut-and-paste cataloguing practice (p. 226), Cabinets for the Curious is indispensable reading for museologists and historians of science. Even if one is uncomfortable with Arnold's methods, this is an original and thought-provoking book that will become part of the essential body of work on early modern cultures of display.
