Despite receiving plenty of scholarly attention in recent years, Christian martyrologies continue to perplex and provoke readers with their trademark blend of fantasy, horror and triumphalism. This book is a welcome addition to the growing number of studies which are less concerned with ‘what really happened’ than with what martyr stories meant to those who read and heard them. It focuses on the language of masculinity which pervades many of the texts, and explores why their authors were so keen to represent both male and female martyrs as (in some senses) paradigmatically masculine.
Cobb begins by outlining Greek and Roman theories of sex and gender before turning to attitudes to men in general, and athletes, soldiers and gladiators in particular, in Roman society. She captures neatly the complexity with which athletes, soldiers and gladiators are viewed in late republican and early imperial sources. Her summaries of ancient views about sex, gender and masculinity in general are less satisfactory. These are large fields these days, and C.'s brief and inevitably partial survey offers rather an insecure basis for her discussion of the Christian texts.
C.'s analysis of masculinity pays surprisingly little attention to masculinity theory. She does note that masculinity may be seen as an achieved rather than a given state, and that masculinity and femininity may co-exist on a spectrum, but she makes little use of either idea. She does not discuss what is perhaps the most important insight of modern masculinity theory: that masculinity is never monolithic, but we should talk rather about masculinities — multiple, competing definitions in social play. Despite her chapter on athletes, soldiers and gladiators, C.'s understanding of masculinity is basically monolithic — men are just, virtuous and in control — so she misses the opportunity to investigate the possible complexity of masculinity in the martyrologies. This is all the more surprising as C. begins the book by emphasizing that ‘Christianity’ is an immensely complex category. One might have expected her to acknowledge that masculinity is too.
The central chapters of the book analyse how masculine language is used in martyr stories, first about men, and then about women. In both cases, C. argues, it helps to create a sense that even though Christians are being persecuted by the authorities, morally and psychologically they are in control. They master their passions, go voluntarily to death, and exhibit justice and virtue at all times.
C.'s argument will not, perhaps, take those familiar with the texts by surprise, but her analysis is detailed, nuanced and convincing. It is particularly good to read an account of masculine women which does not assume that they must be transgressive. I should have liked to know how C. compares female martyrs with other Greek and Roman women who demonstrate masculine virtues, but she does not pursue that question.
The most surprising omission from the book, given the way C. introduces it, is any discussion of the (admittedly probably insoluble) question of the intended audiences of these texts. Were non-Christians meant to be impressed by the masculinity of Christian martyrs into converting? Were Roman Christians meant to feel encouraged that they could beat the pagans at their own gender-game? What about Christians from the Greek East? A large proportion of martyrologies are in Greek, but C.'s presentation of ancient views of sex and gender focuses heavily on Roman culture and does not discuss whether there are differences between Roman and Greek in this period.
In conclusion, C. argues that, contrary to what we often assume, Christians did not spend all their time rejecting Roman values in general, and Roman views about sex and gender in particular. It is a view which has been taken increasingly often in recent years, and it is certainly worth applying to these texts. I was less convinced by C.'s other main argument, that in martyrologies, one answer to the question what it meant to be Christian was ‘to embody masculinity’. Even in martyrologies that is evidently not the whole, nor even the main story. But it is part of what gives the main story color, and as such is well worth reflecting on.
