The editors and authors of these essays have two aims in mind, each in service of the other. The large or methodological concern is to draw together biblical studies, theology and philosophy toward a broader kind of biblical theology. They seek to do that around the particular issue of the unity of the canon. That much debated question necessarily confronts one with matters that arise in the formation of the text – early versions, extra-canonical writings and the early formation of different canons – as well as in the history of the interpretation of the text, a process that begins within the text, as Michael Fishbane has ably demonstrated (Biblical Interpretation in Ancient Israel, 1985). The writers assume also that the unity of the canon extends into the unity of the tradition and seek to explore how one is related to the other. That is, in fact, what the editors of the book regard as ‘this volume's key contribution to the discussion of unity’ (p. 6). There is a further interest articulated in the introduction that seems more fuzzy or vague. It has to do with the contribution of the biblical texts and traditions to reality. As best one can tell, the point is that these texts and traditions provide a particular construal of reality and so can help on the question of the philosophical determination of reality and its epistemological justification.
The unity of the canon is not in the existence of a closed canon or in a single way of speaking about God. It happens through the continuity of theological themes from the time of the text until now. It is discerned and actualised in the process and the community of interpretation, but not without significant complexity and on the basis of a common faith behind the whole of the trajectory of interpretation.
The essays seek to develop this understanding of canonical unity. In a study of Schleiermacher's view of canon, Christine Helmer concludes: ‘The nature of the transhistorical communication of a religion's ideas through language and the maintenance of a common experience across history and across cultures are aspects to the canon that steer it toward the question of unity. The unity of the canon is both a transhistorical reality “behind” the text and a transhistorical reality of individuals and communities “in front of the text”’ (p. 50). Within such a framework, the historical and exegetical investigation of the text must go on, along with the questions and issues that philosophy and theology uncover in it.
Armin Lange explores the unity and plurality of the Hebrew scriptures as central to the move from literature to scripture. Using quotations and allusions to scripture in Qumran and other Jewish texts, Lange argues that the turning point from viewing texts as having authority to regarding them as sacred with authority over the faith and practice of the community – Jewish and Christian – and thus becoming scripture, happened during the Hellenistic reforms of 175–164 BCE. In the process of making this point, Lange argues that there were no group-specific canons in ancient Judaism, nor was any specific textual form preferred by any religious groups. Amid all the references to texts and interpretations, it was the principle of reference to scripture and the reality behind it that provided unity.
Benjamin Sommer provides a provocative and helpful treatment of the Written and Oral Torahs in Judaism and their significance for Jewish theology. He explores the differences and ends up arguing that while Written Torah enjoys the greater degree of prestige, the Oral Torah actually functions more authoritatively. Building on the widespread view in modern Judaism that the Written Torah is not a product of direct revelation to Moses but of complex mediation, Sommer proposes a view of the canon that subsumes the Written Torah within the Oral Torah, which thus begins at Gen 1:1 and ‘includes, at least potentially, all Jewish religious thought and creativity’ (p. 149) down to the present and on into the future. Such a view has two important implications. One is that there can be no Jewish biblical theology, only Jewish theology. The other is that such a theology will ‘embrace variety instead of searching for unity’ (p. 146).
In a brief essay, James Barr explores what he sees as a necessary movement back and forth between the Bible and what he describes as ‘regulative statements’, some of which may be found in the Bible but most having been formulated afterward, for example, in law and Midrash in Judaism and in creeds in Christianity. He then explores the contribution and necessity of both biblical theology and the later theological moves, proposing that while ‘doctrinal formulation is essential for the theological understanding of the Bible, a return into the scriptural text is essential for the functioning of the religion’ (p. 157).
Insisting heavily on the linguistic and interpretational character of all New Testament texts and all treatments of them – a fairly obvious point – Christof Landmesser explores the interpretative unity of the New Testament and sees it in the varied ways in which the New Testament writings speak about how humankind's salvation depends on one's understanding of Jesus Christ. Looking at the different writings, he shows in detail how this is so. The unity of the New Testament is thus an interpretative unity, but it develops out of the common element, what Landmesser calls a ‘meta-criterion’, that is, faith in Jesus Christ. The outcome is, in effect, a canon within the canon, but Landmesser's point is less the critical function of his meta-criterion than its role in providing unity and coherence, in effect creating the church's canon.
Avi Saga's essay on Jewish traditions of interpretation focuses on the openness of scripture as reflected in halakhic tradition and accentuated especially in the exegesis of Nahmanides. In the process he underscores the reader's role in the creation of the meaning of a text. Saga notes, however, a modification of this ‘deconstructionist’ approach by Nahmanides' moderate acknowledgement of the reality of an autonomous text independent of interpretation. He affirms a multi-layered scripture comprised of both overt or plain meaning and the exegesis of the sages.
Finally Nicholas Wolterstorff looks at scripture as a work, a term that points to the literary entity being authorised as a whole, that is, a unity, a totality arising from something that lies behind the text. He regards it as almost impossible not to treat the whole Christian Bible as a single work with ‘two interacting story lines’, one of creation–providence–consummation and the other of redemption, a reading of scripture worked out in a perceptive way by Kendall Soulen in his book The God of Israel and Christian Faith.
This collection operates at a fairly deep and complex level. The editors’ introduction suggests the essays comprise a ‘new biblical-theological approach’ to the unity of the canon, rooted in theological and philosophical approaches. For this reviewer, the collection seems not as new or coherent as the introduction suggests. That does not mean, however, they are not useful essays, as they come at the issues of the canon's unity from various angles, especially the treatments of the Hebrew scriptures in the Jewish tradition. The collection would have been strengthened by a more extensive attempt to think about the unity of the Christian Bible with its two testaments. While Barr's essay touches on this, it is not until Wolterstorff's final essay that the Old Testament, as distinct from the Hebrew scriptures, comes fully into play. The search for unity and coherence in the church's scripture requires a larger focus on the whole of that scripture.
