One of the hallmarks of totalitarian takes on history—be they nationalist, Marxist, or religious—is that they are virtually devoid of irony; there is no place for seemingly random events or actors that fall out of character. Post-histories have therefore made heavy use of “ironic” events to deconstruct such master narratives—yet in the course of doing so have sacrificed irony on the altar of serious deconstructivism. Perhaps the best way to puncture self-serving interpretations of history is simply to ferret out the details of what happened, which will inevitably throw up facts that do not fit the master-narrative, and in this Hwansoo Kim's Empire of the Dharma succeeds brilliantly.
The dominant narrative in the history of modern Korean Buddhism is that of the colonial hijacking of the original tradition and the subsequent attempts to remove the stains of that legacy. After liberation, the question of clerical marriage was thus at the center of discussions on Korean Buddhist identity. Clerical marriage was seen as a practice imposed by the Japanese; hence married priests were considered pro-Japanese whereas celibate priests represented the pure Korean tradition. One of the key events in this narrative was the attempted takeover of the representative Korean Buddhist organization, the Wŏnjong, by the Japanese Sōtō sect in 1911. The key players were the head of Wŏnjong, Yi Hoegwang, and the Sōtō representative Takeda Hanshi. As the author notes, Hoegwang has been vilified ever since as a traitor of the same ilk as Yi Wanyong, the prime minister who signed the 1910 annexation treaty (p. 231).
This book traces back the antecedents of this key event, starting with the arrival of the very first Japanese Buddhist missionaries in 1877, when the ink of the Kanghwa Treaty that opened Korea's doors to Japan had barely dried. It ends in 1912 with the reaction of the new colonial government to both the Japanese missionary activities and the Korean attempts at self-representation. Rather than explaining the Japanese Buddhist missionaries as henchmen for Japan's imperial project, Hwansoo Kim looks to the missionary complex that gripped Japanese Buddhism after the Meiji restoration (due to a sense of inferiority vis-à-vis Christianity) as a more fundamental motivating factor.
But despite the fact that many Japanese Buddhist sects had missionary ambitions, there was little in the way of coordinated effort, and thus it was up to maverick monks to forge a path. Ironically, some of the key actors—notably Sano Zanrei, who obtained the lifting of the ban on Korean monks entering the capital, and Takeda Hanshi, who acted as advisor to the Wŏnjong—can best be described as loose cannons. Sano was a virtual outcast in the Nichiren sect to which he belonged (p. 120) while Takeda, though a monk, was active mostly in the political realm; the project of trying to merge the Wŏnjong with the Sōtō sect was very much his own initiative, and Sōtō headquarters were anything but enthusiastic about his demarche.
Although their actions secured the goodwill of the Korean monastic community (in Takeda's case, this lasted until the merger was announced), they proved fruitless. King Kojong allowed monks to enter the capital and proselytize in 1895, but he soon reimposed the ban. The merger between Sōtō and Wŏnjong also never materialized—not only due to the protests of Korean monks, as is well known, but also due to the fact that the Sōtō leaders distanced themselves from the project, as is revealed by the author. It is thus impossible to maintain any more that the Japanese Buddhist monks acted as a kind of spiritual vanguard to prepare the way for colonization, yet this does not imply that their actions were insignificant. Korean monks were not passive victims in the process, but tried to manipulate the Japanese monks to achieve their own ends. The author explains this mainly through Bourdieu's notion of “capital”: Korean monks appropriated some of the cultural or political clout of their Japanese counterparts to strategically further their own ends. Thus Yi Hoegwang sought the influence of Sōtō as a kind of collateral against the incursions of both the Korean government and later the Japanese colonial authorities, who seemed totally disinterested in Buddhism.
The author's arguments are convincing; his treatment of these key events in Korean Buddhist history should be required reading for anyone interested in this aspect of Korean history. The writing is not always crystal-clear, rendering the treatment of key background information, such as the Japanese sectarian landscape, somewhat shaky. Also, though I generally agree with the author's conclusion that we should not see the Japanese Buddhist missionaries as self-conscious emissaries of Japanese imperialism, just as Western cultural discourse on the Orient has been shown to be part of a project of domination, the same can be said for the mental landscape imposed by the Japanese monks. The 1881 encounter between Okumura Enshin and an unnamed Korean monk, in which Okumura browbeat his Korean counterpart into submission (p. 86), serves as an explicit reminder of power relations that were mostly implicit, but in which it was always clear that Korea was the inferior party.
