The last few years have seen the adoption in Europe of a series of reforms that concern the way in which the delivery of welfare benefits and services is organised. In Germany, a new institution, located between local social assistance and the public employment services, has been created, the Jobcentre. France has merged the public employment service with the agency responsible for the delivery of unemployment benefit. In the UK, Jobcentre Plus now provides cash benefits and placement services to all working-age clients of social benefits. Switzerland has developed a highly structured system of inter-agency collaboration. In all of these countries, as well as in others, we have seen a substantial increase in the role played by private actors in the provision of re-employment services.
Organisational or governance reforms have been numerous and profound, yet they have attracted comparatively little attention from social policy researchers. This is problematic, because these reforms are contributing to changing in fundamental ways the way in which welfare states are organised. This is why The Governance of Active Welfare States is a welcome contribution to current debates on social policy reform.
The book deals with two important issues. First, it maps the transformation of the way the delivery of welfare benefits and services is organised in Europe. Second, it focuses on the issue of the impact of these reforms. Do they improve the effectiveness and/or the efficiency of social security systems? Do they allow, as they purport, a streamlining of procedures to the advantage of clients? These are important questions that have been studied to a limited extent only, and generally not in a comparative perspective, as is the case here.
The book covers nine European countries: the UK, Germany, France, Italy, Sweden, Finland, Czech Republic, the Netherlands and Switzerland. These countries are a good representation of the various types of welfare state found in Europe. Each country's trajectory is examined in a dedicated chapter. In addition, the book contains three comparative chapters. The introduction fleshes out the problem: how to (re-)organise the delivery of welfare benefits and services in welfare states that put strong emphasis on the activation of non-working social security clients. This process of reorganisation takes place within tight budget constraints, and as a result in the context of the search of maximum efficiency. Efficiency is often sought with tools such a new public management of the outsourcing of re-employment services. The second comparative chapter identifies the key actors involved in the delivery of welfare services and benefits across the nine countries covered in the book. It is interesting to note that the configurations of relevant actors vary from country to country. For instance, municipalities play a key role in the delivery of social assistance in countries such as Sweden, Switzerland or the Netherlands, but are rather irrelevant in the UK, where the social assistance system is highly centralised.
The final chapter, written by the book's editors, sums up the main findings that come out from the country case studies in relation to the two key issues. With regard to the first issue, about the key trends, a number of them are identified. First, there are shifts on the centralisation–decentralisation axis. The shifts, however, go in different directions. Even within a country, some aspects of the provision of welfare benefits and services may be decentralised while others are centralised. This makes the study of centralisation–decentralisation processes particularly complex.
Second, most countries have seen an increase in the role played by the private sector in the provision of re-employment services. Often these are provided by for profit on non-profit private actors who compete in a quasi-market, based on principles such as pay for performance but also trust. Marketisation seems to be a general trend that has progressed at different speeds. So Finland and Sweden are the least enthusiastic countries of private re-employment services. The Netherlands, in contrast, has gone very far, by obliging municipalities to buy such services. This requirement, however, has been somewhat relaxed in recent years.
Third, a few countries have also tried to develop inter-agency cooperation and partnerships. Cooperation may concern different actors and may be more or less formalised. In some countries, such as in Germany, it anticipated a more profound integration of social assistance and part of the unemployment benefit system.
Does all this matter in so far as the effectiveness and/or the efficiency of policy are concerned? To address this second issue, the authors can rely on a limited number of studies only. Admittedly, research that reliably tests the impact of large organisational reforms is difficult to set up. The few studies that exist are rather inconclusive. For example, there is little evidence that introducing a competitive quasi-market for re-employment services produces better results in terms of moving non-working clients into jobs. Similarly, high-scale collaboration initiatives or even mergers do not seem to produce results that are clearly different from what was observed in pre-existing systems. Perhaps the main obstacle to labour market participation of social security claimants is not to be found within the organisation of the system, but has to do with the functioning of the labour market. Organisational reforms may have a positive impact on output, allowing systems to reach more clients.
This book provides a clear overview and a serious discussion of the trends that have characterised the organisation of social security. It is a must read for anyone interested in the process of welfare state transformation.
