Samuel Edgerton's latest book returns to the subject of his first, The Renaissance Discovery of Linear Perspective (1975): Filippo Brunelleschi's pioneering use, in 1425, of one-point perspective, and the significance of this new way of depicting three-dimensional space for broad cultural developments in Renaissance Europe. His new book traces this cultural influence by focusing on optics and optical tools. Brunelleschi's first perspective demonstration invited viewers to peer through a small hole in a wooden panel towards a mirror placed a short distance away; they saw a reflection of the panel's unseen side, where Brunelleschi had painted a perspective image of the Florence Baptistery, but all insisted that they had seen the real thing.
Mirrors, peepholes and optics, then, were fundamental to the first invention of perspective. The window came later, when scholar–architect Leon Battista Alberti provided a general written account of linear perspective, c.1435, in his treatise On Painting; here he refers to the plane of a picture as a ‘window’ through which the artist looks in order to set up a perspective system that will make a two-dimensional image look three-dimensional. From this moment on, Edgerton contends, a new interest in optical effects would spark the creation of devices like the camera obscura and the telescope, which in turn would change perceptions of reality and the structure of the world. Thus, he concludes, art's preoccupation with depicting nature eventually altered the understanding of nature.
The Mirror, the Window, and the Telescope reconsiders the author's early work in light of his later scholarly career, in light of recent research in the history of Renaissance art, and above all in light of the cultural shifts that have occurred in the study of the humanities in recent years. The mature Edgerton's deepened knowledge of Florentine social and religious life inspires him to put Brunelleschi's perspective experiments, interestingly, into a religious sphere, dominated by the influential Dominican friar Antonino Pierozzi, archbishop of Florence from 1446 and, eventually, a saint. Both Brunelleschi – goldsmith, sculptor, painter and superb architect – and Friar Antonino – impassioned preacher – aimed to make Florentines more conscious of God's presence in their lives, Antonino by comparing divinity to light, Brunelleschi by observing the way light worked and attempting to capture its effects. Hence, Edgerton contends, perspective began as religious symbolism. Its first use in a public work of art, Masaccio's Trinity for the Florentine church of Santa Maria Novella, reinforced this spiritual connection. Quickly, however, perspective renderings of space became standard practice for Italian artists portraying secular as well as sacred spaces. As Edgerton notes, Renaissance Christians believed that divine and human realms had combined in Jesus, the Son of God who lived and died as a mortal man; in him, therefore, sacred and secular merged, in Masaccio's Trinity and in the rigorously perspectival religious paintings of the later fifteenth century. By the early sixteenth century, however, Italian artists sought to distinguish sacred things from secular, and did so, he suggests, by new ways of depicting space that went beyond one-point perspective.
In her influential After Raphael: Painting in Central Italy in the Sixteenth Century (1998), art historian Marcia Hall identified a ‘relief-like style’ developing among painters in Rome during the second decade of the sixteenth century. This compressed, frontal composition emulated the skill of ancient sculptors, who could layer multiple ranks of figures, or present deeply receding architecture, within the few centimeters’ depth of a bas-relief. Hall demonstrated how Raphael, Michelangelo and the artists around them exploited the contrast between the deep spaces of one-point perspective and this flat, up-front ‘relief-like style’ with great ingenuity, sometimes in the same painting, so that different ways of representing space effectively distinguish mortal figures from saints, the Madonna or the classical gods, or separate Earth from Heaven. Edgerton finds her distinction convincing, and develops it further.
The Mirror, the Window, and the Telescope also addresses a new generation of readers, those brought up on what Edgerton terms ‘a new wave of art criticism that no longer considers it [perspective] a positive idea; that it has instead actually inhibited innate artistic expression, even becoming an imperialist means to colonize the cultures of non-Western societies’ (p. xiv). He traces linear perspective to colonial Mexico, and a superb sixteenth-century portrayal of Christ by an indigenous artist who handles the holy figure in a grand manner distantly inspired by Michelangelo. Finally, Edgerton returns to Europe, and Galileo's observations of the Moon with the telescope (1609), and proposes that the great astronomer's skill as a draughtsman helped make the Starry Messenger of 1610 so revolutionary a study. Galileo's perspective technique (and artistic license) made his illustrations of lunar craters convincing evidence in themselves that the Moon's surface was rough and mountainous rather than smoothly spherical. Ironically, then, the perspective technique that began in a spirit of religious devotion eventually fostered its opposite: a secular, scientific outlook.
The Mirror, the Window, and the Telescope is too short a book to settle any of the controversies it arouses. It is meant to stimulate and provoke, and to inspire a new generation of students to explore this remarkably creative period for the beauty of its artistic works, the intensity of its human interest and its formative impact on our own ways of seeing and thinking. In fact, of course, academic ‘culture wars’ have never stanched the flow of visitors to Florence and Rome: Brunelleschi, Masaccio, Raphael, Michelangelo and Galileo still exert their pull on the rest of the world, and this little book, with infectious enthusiasm, helps to explain what marvellous things were happening in those days under the Tuscan (and Roman) sun. Wandering scholars rarely come back to the terrain of their early research; Edgerton's return to Renaissance perspective, with all his added insight, is a rare treat.
