Social scientists have long sought to find a model that explains the internal tensions within Israeli society and their impact on the functionality of the state and society. Asʾad Ghanem's book falls within this genre of works. His thesis is straightforward: Israel is a “hegemonic ethnic state” controlled since its foundation by the Ashkenazi (European Jewish) elite whose prime objective has been to perpetuate power vis-à-vis other ethnic groups and to maintain the European culture of the state. Ghanem identifies four major ethnic groups that the Ashkenazi elite have dominated and manipulated. These groups include the Palestinian citizens of Israel, Mizrahim (Jews primarily but not exclusively from Arab states), ultra-Orthodox Jews, and Russian immigrants (primarily from the 1990s). The Ashkenazi elite managed to maintain hegemony until the early 1990s despite the growing political mobilization of the ethnic margins, but the Oslo accords (1993), which eased Arab–Israeli tensions, loosened the bonds between Jewish ethnic groups and heightened intergroup tensions.
The ethnic “margins,” in turn, demanded more involvement and a greater share in the political pie of the state. Palestinian citizens of Israel entered the ethnic struggle and the politics of identity by negating Zionism and calling for the transformation of Israel from a Jewish state to a binational state. The 1990s were thus marked by increased internal tensions within society. The “margins” increased their political activity in challenge to the hegemony of the Ashkenazi elite, while the elite fought back in order to retain power. Such societal conflict contributed to greater state dysfunction. The eruption of the Second Intifada in September 2000 reunited all Jewish ethnic groups against the common enemy and calmed, to an extent, the internal tension within society, leaving only the Arab–Jewish cleavage to fester.
This thesis extends through seven chapters. Chapter 1 surveys existing theories and models that explain state and society in Israel, most of which Ghanem refutes. The Ashkenazi elite, according to him, never sought to establish a democratic state but rather a political system that would guarantee Ashkenazi hegemony. For example, he argues that in the 1990s the “ruling group” (the Ashkenazi elite) encouraged Russian immigration to Israel “as part of its demographic war against Arabs, the Haredim (Jewish fundamentalists) [sic!] and against the Oriental Jews” (p. 20). Chapters 2 through 5 analyze the history of the relationship between the four “marginal groups” and the state, which has been controlled, according to Ghanem, by the secular Ashkenazi elite. Here Ghanem provides a somewhat tedious and redundant description of the evolution of the political behavior of the four groups and the way they sought “to cope with and resist the diverse ‘ethnic state’ arrangements that affect them” (p. 21). The chapters also chronicle the way the four groups used the “politics of identity” in their interaction with the state's Ashkenazi elite.
In Chapter 6 and the conclusion Ghanem returns to his prime thesis arguing that the extent of the stability or instability of Israel's political system “is related to the politics of identity that has come to constitute the primary political strategy of Israeli citizens.” Following the Arab–Israeli peace talks of the 1990s there was a “meteoric rise in demands for cultural recognition of the constituent groups within the Jewish majority” (p. 179). Palestinian citizens of Israel, however, “have become more isolated, more threatening and more threatened than they were in the past.” Ghanem thus concludes that intergroup relations in Israeli society are “fraught with ideological, political, cultural and class tensions. Relations among the groups are structured around the principle of group mobilization in opposition to other groups” (p. 187). This intergroup dynamic explains the state of conflict within Israeli society. For Israel to survive politically, Ghanem argues, there needs to be “a substantial change in the regime components, so that it seeks to rebuild a consociational democracy based on arrangements of power sharing and resources distribution in a just way between the different groups” (p. 193).
Ghanem's arguments read like a sharp verdict, a sort of a j'accuse, articulated by a Palestinian citizen of Israel who has lived in the middle of the sharpest cleavage of Israeli society and whose life has been fundamentally affected by it. Despite its acuteness, the book suffers from conceptual and editorial weaknesses. Any attempt to find a model that explains the complex nature of Israeli society is destined from the beginning to be problematic. It is challenging to fit a human society, let alone a society as complex as Israel, into a single model. Ghanem's identification of the five ethnic groups that make up Israeli society is a case in point. While Ashkenazim, Mizrahim, Russians, ultra-Orthodox, and Palestinians are valid classifications when studying the makeup of Israeli society, it is still problematic to treat them as static and cohesive groups. Ghanem does mention their shades of gray but does not modify his model to reflect these shades. In fact, there is fluidity between the four major Jewish groups that Ghanem identifies. Empirical evidence shows that intermarriage between secular Mizrahim and Ashkenazim in the country's urban centers (Metropolitan Tel-Aviv, Haifa, and elsewhere) has become an established fact, and the political and economic elite is more mixed now than it was during the first three decades of Israel's existence, to the point that it would be misleading to identify this elite as “Ashkenazi.” Socioeconomic gaps between Mizrahim and Ashkenazim can still be found, primarily in the geographical periphery of the country where there is little interaction between the two communities and where discrimination from the 1950s and 1960s has perpetuated itself. Although Ghanem alludes to the geographical context of Mizrahi discrimination (p. 62), he does not incorporate it into his model. Further, although Ghanem is aware of excellent studies by Yossi Yonah, Yehuda Shenhav, Ella Shohat, and others, which deconstruct categories such as “Ashkenazi,” “Mizrahi,” and “European culture” in order to challenge perceived perceptions of identity and ethos in Israel, such categories still form the backbone of his book.
With this in mind, it is a challenge to accept Ghanem's assertion that Israel is not democratic but rather an “ethnic state,” because “state structure and political operation is controlled by one ethnic group, Ashkenazi Jews.” “The state,” he continues, “recognizes this group and its needs as superior in comparison to other groups” (p. 16). It may have been true during the first three decades of the state that the Ashkenazi elite attempted to safeguard its hegemony, but this has changed with the socioeconomic and sectarian transformation of the Israeli elite. The army, for example, which was a vehicle for the preservation of the Ashkenazi elite, has become over the past few decades a tool of social mobility for Jews (excluding ultra-Orthodox Jews), and its middle- and high-ranking officers can no longer be identified with one single “ethnic” group. This transformation also applies to the political and economic elite of the country. More than anything else, it seems that Ghanem projects Jewish–Arab dynamics and tensions, which are marked by the hegemony of Jews and exclusion of Arabs, on to the entire society.
Ghanem's book also suffers from redundancy of arguments and language problems. To mention one conspicuous error of the many that I noticed, Ghanem mentions “Palestinian countries” several times (pp. 88, 166, 193) when in fact he means “Arab countries.” This error, like many others, could have been avoided by better editing.
In conclusion, as numerous social scientists prior to Ghanem have argued, Israeli society is undoubtedly facing acute internal challenges related to heightened tensions between its divided national, religious, socioeconomic, and political communities—communities that in and of themselves are fragmented and far from homogenous—all playing the game of “the politics of identity.” Ghanem does try to explain the reasons for this overburdened society, but I remained unconvinced about the model he presented in this book.
