These absorbing, very different books examine the Maoist-inspired regime popularly known as the Khmer Rouge that governed Cambodia from April 1975 to January 1979.
Henri Locard has written perceptively on the Khmer Rouge for many years. His magisterial Pourquoi les Khmers Rouges (Why the Khmer Rouge) treats the regime in terms of what can be discerned, largely through written sources, of its ideology and practice. Ian Harris's more circumscribed study draws on a range of interviews and unexploited archival data, while Rithy Panh's incandescent and troubling book, translated from the French, blends his talent as an interrogating filmmaker with his traumatic experiences as a teenager under the Khmer Rouge.
In his synthesizing study, Locard reveals, among other things, how much the Communist Party of Kampuchea (CPK) owed to its counterpart in Vietnam, starting in the first Indochina War (1946–54) and continuing until 1973.
Vietnam's demeaning guidance to its “younger brother” consistently prioritized Vietnamese strategic interests. Chinese authorities, on the other hand, praised the CPK's “independent” revolutionary stance, and when the Khmer Rouge came to power its leaders rejected a Vietnamese alliance and privileged what they believed to be the resounding successes of China's Great Leap Forward. They had no idea how disastrous the Great Leap Forward had been. That information was withheld from the Chinese people and everyone else until long after Mao Zedong's death in 1976.
The human costs of the CPK's ill-considered policies were precipitously high. In less than four years, an estimated 1.7 million Cambodians, or one in five, died of starvation, overwork, psychological trauma, untreated diseases, and summary executions.
Locard argues persuasively that most of these regime-inspired deaths need to be called crimes against humanity rather than genocide. The vast majority of the victims, after all, were ethnic Khmer and the intent to liquidate them en masse as Khmer as opposed to executing them for their behavior or letting them die by the wayside is impossible to document. Instead, as Locard points out, parallels with Stalin's collectivization of the Ukraine in the 1930s, the Great Leap Forward, and the massacres of alleged communists in Indonesia in 1965–66 are closer to home and more rewarding than parallels with what occurred in the Holocaust or in Rwanda. That said, the systematic executions of the few thousand Vietnamese who remained in the country after 1975 can accurately be described as genocidal.
Locard's book is especially useful when it draws on his own path-breaking research on the Khmer Rouge prison system, its bizarre slogans, and its notions of “the wheel of history” and the life stories of adherents to the CPK who were educated partially in France.
In 2003, Ian Harris, a British scholar of Buddhism, was contracted by the Documentation Center-Cambodia (DC-Cam) in Phnom Penh to explore the fate of Buddhists and Buddhism under the CPK. Buddhism in a Dark Age expands the volume that Harris produced for DC-Cam in 2007 to include material about Buddhism in Cambodia before 1975 and after 1979. The book benefits from Harris's judicious use of DC-Cam's voluminous archives and also from dozens of interviews that he conducted with monks, ex-monks, and other survivors of the Khmer Rouge era.
Like all communist regimes, the Khmer Rouge sought to extirpate organized religion from everybody's lives. Attacking Theravada Buddhism, Cambodia's national religion since the fourteenth century CE, involved defrocking over 50,000 monks, closing some 3,000 wats, and, as importantly, unraveling a mass of time-honored Buddhist ceremonies connected with ordinations, illness, marriage, ancestors, and death.
In the midst of the secularization program, scattered clusters of monks survived in some areas until mid-1976 and a sizeable number of ex-monks were not forced to marry or made to engage in manual labor. Members of the clergy who resisted the Khmer Rouge, on the other hand, were summarily put to death. Harris estimates that some 12,000 monks comprising about a fifth of the 1970 sangha were executed by the regime—a grim statistic that nonetheless confirms “the absence of any centralized policy for smashing the monastic order as a whole” (p. 133).
In chapter 4, “Buddhism and Khmer Communism: A Shared Conceptual Terrain” (pp. 43–63), Harris intriguingly reveals how much of the discipline (viney) that the CPK imposed upon its members resembled Buddhist monastic practice. Revolutionaries were told to be sexually continent, wear identical clothes, practice self-criticism, renounce worldly goods, spurn personal adornment, and unquestionably obey one's superiors—to name a few.
A Vietnamese invasion in January 1979 drove the Khmer Rouge from power, and chapter 7, “Aftermath: Rebuilding the Sangha under Socialism” (pp. 139–67), examines the partial revival of Buddhism under the Vietnamese-sponsored People's Republic of Kampuchea (1979–89). These pages fill an important gap in Cambodian historiography and add value the book.
The Elimination consists of two intermingled stories. The first of these is a harrowing account of Panh's life as a teenager under the Khmer Rouge. Driven out of Phnom Penh with his family, Panh lost his parents and several siblings as well as much of his psychological balance before he escaped to Paris in 1979 and eventually established himself as an award-winning filmmaker. Several of his searing documentaries, which I have seen, deal with the Khmer Rouge period.
The second story is drawn from hundreds of hours of interviews that Panh conducted and filmed in 2008 and 2009 with an ex-Khmer Rouge official named Duch who has since been convicted of crimes against humanity. In 2009, he was sentenced to prison for thirty-five years by the international tribunal in Phnom Penh that was convened to try the former leaders of the Khmer Rouge.
Weaving the two stories together has produced a compelling, hybrid book.
What makes the parts of The Elimination that deal with Panh's experiences superior to many similar stories, aside from the power of his writing (well served by John Cullen's deft translation), is the way that he connects his experiences with his present-day personality and with Duch. The book proceeds in a dialectical, hybrid fashion, placing Panh's painful, almost unspeakable memories alongside stretches of his clear-headed, probing interrogation and Duch's intricate, often revealing replies.
Unlike Rithy Panh, Duch was born into an impoverished rural family. His academic success as a mathematician lifted him briefly, as a teacher, into the middle class. He became a communist in his twenties and was imprisoned for several years. In the Cambodian civil war (1970–75) he presided zealously over a Khmer Rouge detention facility where prisoners of war were routinely put to death.
In 1976, he was chosen to run a secret prison in Phnom Penh, code-named S-21, where perhaps as many as 14,000 men, women, and children, alleged to be enemies of the state, were interrogated, tortured, and put to death. Much of the massive archive of the prison—half a million pages, including forced confessions—has survived.
Duch left the Khmer Rouge in the late 1980s and was found living in poverty by an intrepid Irish journalist in 1998. He was arrested a few days later. In the early 1990s, he had become an evangelical Christian. He told Panh and the tribunal, perhaps disingenuously, that he regretted much of what he had done and hoped for God's forgiveness.
The Elimination contains two contrasting narratives constructed by a passionate filmmaker unwilling to forget or dishonor his past. The second, interwoven story revolves around a proud, articulate, far from banal perpetrator of horrific crimes who seems to be eager to befriend and manipulate his interrogator—under benign conditions, compared to those that characterized S-21—while being led relentlessly, on page after page, to face the intrinsic horrors of his career.
The Elimination is a marvelous, electric, deeply moving book. My only caveat is that Christophe Bataille's contributions to it are never clarified.
