Reading this book, as I did, during the period of imposition and revocation of the Trump administration's ban on immigrants from selected predominantly Muslim countries in early 2017 vividly reinforces its timeliness and value. At a time when questions about American inclusivity and exclusivity have (again) become supercharged, Leah Perry's book paints a portrait of a US long trapped in successive cycles of moral and economic panic about its most recent arrivals. One of the key conceptual interventions made here is the notion of the “neoliberal crossing,” a framing of immigration that works to support tenuous neoliberal ideological formations, specifically by masking and/or rationalizing “the racist and sexist social relations” through which such formations are structured (16). Calling attention to parallel gatekeeping and welcoming discourses, Perry intends to prompt thinking about the racial and gendered caste system that neoliberalism relies upon and exploits (despite the emergence of spectacularized figures of exception from subordinated groups). She shows that US culture, while romanticizing historical narratives of white ethnic striving to stress inclusivity, typically wields punitive neoliberal conceptualizations to rationalize population management and expulsion in regard to newer, often Latino, arrivals.Footnote 1
The control and regulation of immigrants is a market-centered process, Perry shows, one which desires and fosters the vulnerability of those who will likely be docile employees. We find ourselves in a historical moment marked by a paradox in which goods and labor are ever more “borderless” while designated groups of human beings are ever more securitized, surveilled and scrutinized. The conversion of the 1980 Mariel Boatlift from a display of American inclusivity to a scare tactic and cautionary tale is in many ways the kickoff incident in the author's account. Despite descriptive jacket copy that suggests a tight focus on the Reagan era, though, this book is fully as much about the 1990s as it is about the 1980s.
A key contribution made here is the historicization of discourses and phenomena that are frequently presented as sui generis. Legislative history is a clear strength of the book and Perry compellingly asserts that “under neoliberalism the law functions as a corporate entity given its orientation toward protecting the interests of capital, and the racial and gender politics that that orientation entails” (190). In particular, Perry's account treats extensively the legislative machinations related to “family reunification” in US immigration policy. These sections of the argument attest to the fact that the propounding of “family values” is always an excluding maneuver. In tandem with this the author perceptively reads the gender, familial and ethnic dynamics of 1980s sitcoms including The Golden Girls (1985–92), Perfect Strangers (1986–93) and Who's the Boss? (1984–92).Footnote 2 Perry aptly identifies other, seemingly banal but revealing, popular-culture texts such as Latino gang films, assimilating Asian daughter-centered print fiction and Genesis's controversial pop song “Illegal Alien.” It becomes evident that the spectrum of ethnic positioning from “respectability” to criminalization is intimately bound up with the fate of the white American family. The popular-culture landscape of the period discussed in this book reveals often frantic representational efforts to sustain an image of that family as secure and flourishing.
The author employs what she identifies as an “interdisciplinary Cultural Studies methodology” (22), and for the most part this works well, although this account would benefit from further acquaintance with the field of celebrity studies and in some cases feminist media studies and the scholarship on white ethnicities. While the author is quite right to point to the privileged role of Irishness and Italianness in contemporary politics of heritage ethnicity, there is a prior scholarly literature on these subjects that should be acknowledged. Perry overlooks some media studies scholarship on popular texts including The Perez Family (dir. Mira Nair, 1995), a film that Perry rightly understands as centralizing a “near queer family” and issuing a rebuke to nativists but ultimately “complementing rather than negating prevailing neoliberal logics” (68).Footnote 3 While the celebrity of Jennifer Lopez and Selena is certainly germane to the author's purposes, Lopez, in particular, has been so thoroughly analyzed by critics such as Mary Beltran, Frances Negron-Muntaner and Isabel Molina-Guzman that it wasn't always clear what Perry was adding to this scholarly corpus.Footnote 4
While the account provided in The Cultural Politics of U.S. Immigration is richly detailed, the reader does stumble upon the occasional error, such as when the author refers to the Puerto Rican pop star “Mark Anthony” (185) or contends that Clarence Thomas was nominated to the Supreme Court by Ronald Reagan (13). Overall, however, the book's writing is lucid and flowing, its readings of popular-culture texts are clear and convincing, and the relations posited between legal realms and representational ones are well reasoned and persuasive. It is easy to envision this book being taken up and put to fruitful use by scholars and students in American studies, history, cultural studies and gender studies, as well as a range of other disciplines.
