Rachel Schreiber's Gender and Activism in a Little Magazine builds upon a growing body of work on the relationship between little magazine publishing and modernist political aesthetics. Focussing on the radical art magazine Masses, published between 1911 and 1917, Schreiber charts how the magazine's cartoons and illustrative styles reflected shifting attitudes to gender and class. The brief six-year period covered by Masses was a turbulent one, especially for changes in attitudes to sexuality and gender roles, as seen in the way the magazine focussed on a variety of debates over class struggle, radical politics, workers' rights, women's suffrage, and birth control, for example. While the historical contexts of these shifts have been well covered by historians, on whom she draws, Schreiber's close reading of the eighty-three illustrations that appear in the book offer an original way of charting these changes. Through a comparison of Masses illustrations and covers with those of other magazines (both mainstream, such as Life, and suffrage and feminist magazines such as the Woman Citizen) Schreiber examines the way that the style and pen strokes employed (most notably from the Ashcan school of artists) created new representational strategies that proffered political positions in addition to the subject matter being drawn and the captions given. Tying art and politics together in this way, Schreiber shows how Masses artists worked to find a literal and figurative radical line within the conventions of cartooning and illustration, which often rely on stereotypical representations for their humour. A broader question addressed here which Schreiber goes part way towards answering is, can such art be avant-garde?
The newness is found in the detail of the drawings: in chapter 2, the turn-of-the-century “crisis” of masculinity is given a class angle as Masses illustrators depicted muscular male working-class bodies in contrast to the “fat cat” industrialists who live off their work. From 1911 to 1917 artists shifted simultaneously with growing political radicalism, from an arts-and-crafts-influenced classicism towards representations that defined a more radical, dynamic and collective vision of the powerful working body. Ambivalence and contradiction often prevailed, however, as radical support for workers often turned into depictions of a clichéd muscular masculinity or sentimental appeals to more traditional perceptions of womanhood that prioritized motherhood over labour politics. In Masses, Schreiber argues, there was a “myopia regarding female labor” within its radical pages and women workers, if depicted at all, were used in contrast to the powerful male worker to express the more adverse effects of industrial labour, as victims and not collective bargainers (52).
As shown in chapter 3, Masses artists “relied on the assumption that mothers were women who should not work for wages, thereby reiterating the normative gender roles that positioned the man as the central wage earner” (69). Despite this, cartoons operated to critique prevailing eugenic arguments of the era that the wealthy were committing “race suicide” and the poor were “overbreeding” by drawing attention to the social and economic problems that such discourses overlooked when judging the poor. Similarly, birth control entered obliquely into the cartoon depictions of the modern woman, illustrating a changing sexual morality. Cartoons skirted around the Comstock Laws on obscenity which censored open debates on birth control by showing humorous or satirical depictions of women with too many babies or not enjoying parenthood. John Sloan in particular depicted single women as more sexually confident, unrestricted by marriage and sex conventions of the bourgeois middle class.
Masses cartoons returned to more conventional fears of female independence in the final years as the magazine turned its attention to fighting America's participation in the First World War. This battle, and the depiction of worker/soldier exploitation during war, led to its demise as new antiradical legislation was passed to censor opponents to the war. In her final chapter, Schreiber contrasts Masses art with that of suffrage publications which valorized both women's pacifism and their work during war as part of the continuing fight to gain the vote. Anti-war cartoons in Masses, in contrast, focussed on the worker/soldier as the exploited class who would return to find the new woman in their job. As Schreiber shows, while conventional gender stereotypes remained in place despite political radicalism, artists used a variety of strategies to express new class and gender positions that stretched the boundaries of prevailing mainstream ideals.
Extensively illustrated and produced on high-quality paper, the book is more an art-historical examination of cartoons than a magazine history per se, as it makes no attempt to cover issues such as readership or circulation, for example. What it does do well is contextualize and read a series of radical illustrations in a nuanced way to reveal the representational politics of gender they contain.
