The American Political Science Association (APSA) needs to do more to communicate the value of political science research. However, we should be wary of the temptation to believe that the association can agree on or deliver a single message that will overcome our problems and win over skeptics in Congress and the press. It is unlikely that any such message exists. Moreover, APSA is not necessarily the best or only means for delivering or disseminating messages about political science. Disciplinary associations face organizational and political constraints that may render them less effective than other means of public outreach. These constraints do not mean that we should be passive, however. Instead, APSA should support public-engagement efforts by creating incentives for outreach, which should be considered a form of disciplinary service, and amplifying those voices that emerge from within the discipline and succeed in the marketplace of ideas. This bottom-up approach will better reflect the pluralism of the field and allow for more creativity and agility in the approaches undertaken.
After numerous attempts by Congress to reduce or eliminate political science funding or place limits on the purposes for which it can be used, there is widespread consensus within the profession that political science should engage more effectively with the public, journalists, and policy makers in the United States. Many scholars look to the APSA to improve the image of political science and communicate its value to these stakeholders. The hope, it often seems, is that we can identify a singular message about the value of political science that APSA can use to win over our discipline’s critics.
However, research in political science and cognate disciplines suggests that the search for a winning message is likely to be futile. Although APSA could do more to promote the merits of political science and its relevance to contemporary problems, it is unlikely that any single message exists that would satisfy all of the different constituencies within the association and also mollify the discipline’s external critics.
Moreover, APSA and other membership associations face well-known organizational and political constraints that make it difficult to reach a consensus on specific messages or to communicate them effectively. Rather than trying to create official messages, APSA should instead seek to amplify voices and contributions to public life from within political science—an approach that is potentially less divisive internally and more effective than top-down messaging. As an illustration of the potential value of such an approach, we include a brief case study from political science blogs, which have increased the prominence of the discipline in current debates despite operating independently without any consensus on methods, approaches, or message.
The challenge, however, is that career incentives within the profession fail to sufficiently encourage and facilitate this type of engagement. We therefore present a series of proposals for how APSA could more effectively encourage contributions to public life from within the profession and support those attempting such contributions. In this way, APSA could encourage its members to engage in outreach without explicitly dictating its form or content.
The payoffs of these efforts for APSA and its members can be significant. By providing new incentives, opportunities, and recognition to political scientists who engage in public outreach and by leveraging the efforts of the most effective communicators in the field, APSA can improve the status and profile of the discipline in public life; expand the scope of the funding, speaking, consulting, and publishing opportunities available to scholars in the field; bring political science research to new audiences among the public and journalists; improve the quality of information available to policy makers; and raise the profile of scholars’ home departments and universities.
THE NECESSITY OF A BOTTOM-UP APPROACH
Many political scientists are rightfully frustrated that the value of political science has not been communicated more effectively, but we should be wary of the temptation to believe that APSA can develop some unidentified message to solve this problem. We know from research in American politics that this idea—however tempting—lacks empirical support. For instance, commentators frequently suggest that President Obama could shift the national debate and change policy outcomes by using the bully pulpit or even by adopting different language (e.g., Brooks Reference Brooks2013; Kuttner 2013; Westen 2012). However, the data show that presidents have great difficulty changing public opinion or attracting congressional support when they go public (e.g., Edwards Reference Edwards2003; Lee Reference Lee2009), Likewise, research on public opinion and motivated reasoning suggests that persuasion efforts often are ineffective when conflicting messages are available or people are predisposed to resist their content (e.g., Taber and Lodge Reference Taber and Lodge2006; Zaller Reference Zaller1992). It is important not to overstate the likely effects of messaging about political science on key audiences and stakeholders.
We also caution against the assumption that academic associations are responsible for or even especially influential in shaping perceptions of the disciplines they represent. For example, economics is not more prominent and influential in public discourse than political science because of communication from the American Economic Association but rather because members of the discipline and smaller, more flexible organizations within economics (e.g., the National Bureau of Economic Research) offer policy-relevant advice and commentary based on rigorous empirical and theoretical research. A similar principle is likely to apply to political science and the role of APSA in its reputation and influence.
In particular, political science research suggests that APSA will struggle to adopt a unified message because of the differing views of its many stakeholders and governance structures, which allow minority factions to block change. For instance, states with internally heterogeneous or divergent populations often divide power among levels of government (Stepan Reference Stepan1999) or create systems with a greater number of veto players rather than unitary parliamentary systems (Mainwaring and Shugart Reference Mainwaring1997), which can increase governmental tendency toward inaction (Tsebelis Reference Tsebelis2002). Likewise, principal–agent theory suggests that significant agency loss often occurs under delegation to an agent such as an association (see, e.g., Miller Reference Miller2005), especially when multiple principals with divergent preferences or incentives are involved (Gailmard Reference Gailmard2009; see also Gailmard and Patty Reference Gailmard and Patty2012).
To the extent that disciplinary associations are effective in promoting their disciplines, it is by leveraging the collective wisdom and contributions of the field. For instance, associations support the publication of journals that select the best research from the field through a distributed process of thousands of article submissions and peer reviews. We should embrace a similar network-style approach to improving the prominence and influence of political science in public life.
…the scholars who are most successful at reaching audiences and communicating effectively will maintain engagement over time and encourage others to use similar approaches.
Rather than launching a bureaucratic process to develop and broadcast a unified message, APSA should amplify the diverse set of voices within political science and create incentives for new voices to emerge. This bottom-up approach would encourage more flexible responses to events and circumstances from individual entrepreneurs and groups within the field. It is difficult to determine the best messages for communicating with the public or the most promising formats for public engagement. Instead of solving these problems from the top down, we should rely on the responses from audiences within and outside of political science. This approach will create a natural evolutionary process that identifies the most compelling voices and the most effective means of communication over time. In our view, the scholars who are most successful at reaching audiences and communicating effectively will maintain engagement over time and encourage others to use similar approaches. Other efforts necessarily will be less successful, causing those scholars to scale back their involvement, opt out of the process, or try another approach. APSA can assist in this process by ensuring that political scientists who want to engage publicly have the opportunity and incentives to do so. Amplifying the efforts of those scholars who want to engage—especially those who can engage the public most effectively—offers the best long-term hope for success.
A CASE STUDY: POLITICAL SCIENCE BLOGS
The growth of political science blogs suggests the potential value of a more decentralized strategy. In the past 10 years, political scientists have used blogs to become regular contributors to public debate (Farrell and Sides Reference Farrell and Sides2010). Blogs, of course, are not the only means of contributing to the larger discourse. However, they offer advantages—such as editorial control and the ability to write and publish quickly—that make them an appealing alternative to formats such as the traditional op-ed (Sides Reference Sides2011).
Political science blogs are as varied as the discipline. Almost all regularly engage with current events in politics and present ideas and analysis from scholarly research. Some blogs cover political science writ large, whereas others focus on particular subfields, countries, or regions. Some blogs also provide normative evaluations of political events and policies or comment on nonpolitical topics, including academia, popular culture, and sports. This variety reflects the diverse perspectives, personalities, and goals of different blogs and bloggers. There is not—nor should there be—one template for political science blogging (Farley Reference Farley2013).
Political science blogs and bloggers also demonstrate their potential as vehicles for scholarly communication to a broader audience. Some political scientists blog or regularly write for larger media outlets, including Dan Drezner at the Washington Post, Brendan Nyhan (an author of this article) and Lynn Vavreck at the New York Times, Seth Masket at Pacific Standard, and Jon Bernstein at Bloomberg View. Several political-scientist group blogs—including Lawyers, Guns, and Money; Crooked Timber; and Duck of Minerva—have built substantial and loyal audiences as independent sites. Individual political scientists, including Andrew Gelman and Rick Hasen, also maintain popular blogs; others have become regular contributors to blogs hosted by research institutes such as the Program on New Approaches to Regional Security (PONARS) and the Brookings Institution. One political science group blog, The Monkey Cage (to which Sides and Tucker contribute), became part of the Washington Post in 2013 after almost six years as an independent blog.
These blogs may not convince every reader—or every member of Congress—of the value of political science. (Indeed, there is likely disagreement about the value of political science among the bloggers themselves.) Nevertheless, blogs do effectively amplify the discipline’s voice. Most important, their success illustrates how a diverse group of scholars from within the discipline can influence public debate without any centralized coordination or a unified message.
POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS
How can political science promote contributions from within the discipline that will increase its profile and contribution to public life? We offer the following four recommendations.
Support Blogging by Ungating Research
The recent report of the APSA Publications Planning Ad Hoc Committee (2014) to the APSA Council is a useful starting point for considering how to promote public engagement with political science research. We strongly support the recommendation to create an “easy, smooth, fast, and egalitarian process to allow bloggers to temporarily ungate any APSA journal article about which the blogger is writing” (Publications Planning Ad Hoc Committee 2014). This process allows political science bloggers to determine in a distributed manner which articles are most important, relevant, or topical and to bring them to the attention of a public audience outside of academia. The proposed option to identify a set of blogs that have the discretion to ungate articles without further approval is especially creative. It would allow those blogs to quickly make relevant research available, thereby increasing their stature and influence. We (i.e., Sides and Tucker) have been pleasantly surprised at publishers’ willingness to ungate articles for posts at The Monkey Cage, but the process is time-consuming and requires substantial startup costs. If APSA had a coordinating role in securing agreements from publishers or in providing a staff member whose responsibilities included rapidly facilitating these arrangements, it would be a valuable contribution. We also encourage APSA to expand the list of sites beyond disciplinary blogs to those that discuss social science research, including Vox, The Upshot, Wonkblog, and FiveThirtyEight.
By contrast, we are dubious about the benefits of certifying outside blogs as “official,” as the APSA Council report suggests. Having APSA or other disciplinary organizations endorse some blogs and not others is likely to create divisions and conflicts that are not useful. Moreover, official recognition could implicate the associations in controversies involving the content of those blogs. There are more subtle ways to support the most effective blogs (e.g., facilitating ungating arrangements with publishers) that avoid these complications.
Rather than endorse existing blogs, it is conceivable that APSA and other disciplinary associations could create new blogs. If so, they should seek to design a process that is as decentralized and demand-driven as possible. First, any such sponsored blog should be created as a new website, which should minimize the potential for crowd-out and help avoid conflict over certifying existing blogs. Second, political scientists or other contributors should be recruited to compete for the blog by guest-blogging during an interim period. This trial period will allow authors to demonstrate their commitment to the task and skills in the medium. In addition, it will provide performance indicators that make it possible for APSA to evaluate the blog content and the success of the authors in engaging with external and internal audiences. Third, APSA should learn from the experiences of other organizations that have developed academic blogs (e.g., PONARS and the London School of Economics and Political Science) about which techniques and approaches are most effective.
Provide Training and Resources to Develop Public Voices
APSA could provide training and resources to help political scientists learn how to write for a wider audience, which would improve the quality and reach of new blogs or op-eds from scholars who previously have not participated in public life. The training could consist of panels at conferences, preconference short courses, mentoring, and/or video tutorials (e.g., we [Sides and Tucker] recently participated in a roundtable at the 2015 Midwest Political Science Association Annual Conference on “How to Guest Blog at The Monkey Cage”). APSA also could compile perspectives and “lessons learned” from existing bloggers within the discipline. All of these resources then could be featured in a special part of the APSA website and published in PS: Political Science and Politics, thereby efficiently disseminating lessons learned to interested scholars who seek advice on how to pursue public writing.
Furthermore, APSA could learn from or collaborate with existing projects that seek to improve how scholars communicate with the public. For example, the Bridging the Gap project (www.american.edu/sis/BTG) sponsors a summer workshop for international-relations scholars, which includes presentations by editors and bloggers as well as practice in writing op-eds and blog posts (for more information, see Bruce Jentleson’s article in this special issue). The OpEd Project (www.theopedproject.org) is another resource for training scholars, particularly those from underrepresented groups, on how to speak publicly and communicate more effectively (see also Khalilah Brown-Dean in this special issue).
Offer Incentives and Recognition for Contributions to Public Life
APSA should create exposure and status incentives to encourage scholars to come forward and communicate with the broader public. To be sure, public communication already may bring some types of recognition, including raising one’s profile among a larger set of disciplinary peers, but these benefits may not be enough for many scholars. One idea is for APSA and its sections, as well as affiliated professional associations, to award prizes for contributions to public debate. They could reflect not only writing (e.g., blogs and op-eds) but also other types of public engagement (e.g., service within government). A model for these awards exists in the prizes given for the best blogs and blog posts by Sage Publications and the international-relations blog, Duck of Minerva.
Another idea is to use virtual communication among scholars to promote public engagement. One way is a public-engagement newsletter modeled on the Political Methodologist, a publication of the Political Methodology Section that is widely read among its members. The newsletter could disseminate best practices for how to engage with the wider public and also recognize leaders in public engagement within the discipline. Alternatively, APSA could encourage affiliated sections to promote public communication and recognize section members who engage most effectively with the public in their newsletters.
… encourage APSA members to recognize public engagement as a legitimate form of academic service in hiring, tenure, and promotion decisions.
Encourage the Recognition of Research-Oriented Public Engagement as Service
Although it may be difficult, the most important step that APSA could take is to encourage APSA members to recognize public engagement as a legitimate form of academic service in hiring, tenure, and promotion decisions. We do not suggest that public engagement can or should be a substitute for research or teaching. However, given that service to a department, university, and/or the discipline often is a tenure criterion, it seems reasonable to consider public engagement as a form of service. As mentioned previously, outreach and engagement—like other forms of service—create positive spillovers for departments and universities. They can raise the profile of departments and universities at the local, state, and national levels and also meet the growing demand for evidence of research impact among external stakeholders (e.g., donors). In particular, writing in blogs and other electronic media can provide useful material for a university’s outreach to alumni through social media and other mechanisms.
Although disagreement may exist about precisely how much public engagement should count in these decisions, we must correct the mistaken idea that disseminating your ideas means you are not a “real” scholar. Many political scientists fear that public engagement may actually reduce their chances of tenure or promotion. Like any form of service, public engagement must be balanced against the competing demands of research and teaching. However, we should strive instead to have it perceived as a positive form of service similar to being a peer reviewer for a publisher or a journal, serving on a panel to evaluate grant proposals, or sitting on a university or disciplinary committee.
Changing disciplinary norms is difficult, of course, but we offer one suggestion to begin. Those who are involved in providing written evaluations of our colleagues—third-year reviews, tenure letters, promotion files, and letters of recommendation—should include examples of public engagement as components of disciplinary service. If a colleague’s blog post is cited in a court case or a newspaper article, for instance, this contribution should be recognized as a valuable form of service. Fortunately, it is becoming increasingly easy to measure the effects of public engagement in these evaluations by estimating the number of website visitors, articles published, citations in the mainstream media, and so forth. These measurable indicators of scholarly impact should be included in tenure and promotion reports with more traditional metrics. If public engagement were recognized positively in these evaluations more frequently, it could help to change the culture and incentives of the discipline over time. Political scientists who are involved in administration and university committees also should seek to include these measures among the contributions that are evaluated during tenure and promotion decisions.
CONCLUSION
We have argued for a bottom-up approach to communicating the value of political science research that is supported by efforts to change the incentives that scholars face to engage in public communication and improving the tools they can use to do so. APSA can be most effective in this process by providing training, resources (e.g., sponsoring new blogs), and support to scholars who want to engage with the public. Although we propose the recognition of these activities as service, it is worth noting the extent to which public engagement also can strengthen research by challenging us to sharpen our ideas, ask new questions, and consider different avenues of inquiry. By seeking to communicate research findings more effectively, political science likely will improve the quality of that research as well.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank Arthur Lupia for his leadership of the APSA Presidential Task Force on Public Engagement, which inspired this article. We are grateful to him and Daryl Press for helpful comments.
