In the Progressive Era between 1890 and 1920, the American economy transformed itself from traditional, commercial, rural society based on face-to-face interaction to a modern, industrial, urban one based on anonymous exchanges. As its demographic character was altered by mass immigration, Americans searched for order through innovations in social, economic, and political institutions.
Although David Huyssen's Progressive Inequality does not address the rich literature on the Progressive Era, it is reminiscent of John Chamberlain's much earlier work Farewell to Reform (1932) that provides a Marxist-Socialist critique of the Progressive movement. For Chamberlain, the Progressive Reform movement ultimately failed because the reformers treated only the symptoms rather than the root of the problem: capitalism. Like Chamberlain, Huyssen's main thesis is that the Progressive Era did little to cure inequality between rich and poor, the source of which was the trappings of capitalism that placed profits ahead of the welfare of labor. Instead, Progressive attempts to alleviate poverty only led to greater social injustice and class divisions.
The innovation in Huyssen's work is in his approach to studying the Progressive Era through the lives of individuals in New York City. At its best, the book weaves an informative tale of rich and poor whose lives became intertwined during this transformative period. While few sympathetic individuals from the wealthy class emerge, Huyssen argues that the profit motive and cultural-imperialistic attitude of the rich impeded any meaningful dialogue with the poor and the possibility of any true cooperative reform.
Huyssen proposes that the rich and poor interacted in three ways: prescription, cooperation, and conflict. In prescriptive class relations, the rich, who believe they possess superior education and knowledge, attempt to “prescribe or choreograph” the behavior of the poor through legislation, reform of urban space, education, and poor-relief structures. In rare occasions, however, the rich and poor cooperated to understand and alleviate the conditions of the working class. But, more likely than not, the rich and poor were in violent conflict as evidenced by the strikes, mob violence, and occasional acts of terrorism.
Huyssen illustrates his “prescription” case with tenement housing conditions and the Bowery Savings Bank. Despite the fact that the main goal of the savings bank was to serve local residents who supplied it with deposits, Huyssen argues that the profit driven bank owners diverted their funds elsewhere rather than using its resources to improve the inhuman tenement housing conditions. Moreover, the rich attempted to help the poor in a prescriptive, scientific manner. Huyssen highlights the cultural attitudes of the rich through the lives of Richard Watson Gilder, head of the Tenement House Committee, and Stanford White, an architect of McKim, Mead & White who was commissioned to build a new structure for the savings bank. The net result was not a useful dialogue between the rich and poor but a mistaken belief by the rich that it can mold and shape the lives of the working poor through architecture and planning.
In his study of charity in New York City, Huyssen finds evidence of both “prescription and cooperation.” In organizations such as Charity Organization Society (COS) of New York (which eventually became the Columbia School of Social Work) and the Salvation Army, Huyssen finds evidence of rich prescriptive donors whose work ultimately hurt rather than helped. The COS categorized the poor into two types (worthy and unworthy), and stigmatized many in the unworthy category. Moreover, even as the original intent of the COS and the Salvation Army was to serve the poor, their goals were coopted by industrial capitalism as these organizations found it necessary to appeal to wealthy donors.
In the case of begging letters written by the hopeful destitute, however, Huyssen finds evidence of “cooperation” between the rich and poor. According to Huyssen, the begging letters gave the poor a greater voice and ability to craft their message. We also meet two individuals who were able to bridge the cultural divide between the rich and poor—Jacob Henry Schiff and Lillian Wald. According to Huyssen, Schiff drew his inspiration from Jewish law of tzedakah that required giving to be performed in an attitude of sympathy with the poor. Unfortunately, Huyssen argues, neither Schiff nor Wald was able to become major leaders of the Progressive Era because they were outside the Protestant social circles.
The potential for “cooperation” emerges even more importantly in the case of the shirtwaist strike. For Huyssen, the early cooperative effort between rich and poor women was much more radical and potentially transformative. Yet, as time wore on, Huyssen argues that cooperation faded as class divisions emerged: one side was wealthy, sex-conscious, suffragist; the other, poor, class-conscious, socialist. While the strikes did achieve wage increases, shorter hours, and better working conditions, Huyssen argues that the strike ultimately failed to increase the real bargaining power of workers.
Huyssen's final case of “conflict” is illustrated using the episodes of violence that emerged between workers and companies. Since the wealthy property owners possessed the state and courts on their side, the only resort of the poor was to take up protest and violence. In the early years, the public tolerated labor's violent method as business leaders such as Vanderbilt and Morgan were unsympathetic public figures. However, in T.P. Shonts, according to Huyssen, a new managerial figure emerged who was able to use corporate rhetoric and strategy to undermine the union and their use of violence. As the president of the Interborough Rapid Transit and New York Railways, Shonts initiated welfare capitalist policies to create the appearance of benevolent employment practices and agreed to make concessions in response to strikes without yielding real bargaining power. In time, Shonts was able to win the public debate on the illegitmacy of the use of violence and removed the only available “common currency” (p. 263) possessed by labor for instigating change. Finally, when Woodrow Wilson's wartime policy suppressed all radical speech, it further marginalized the radical American left.
Thus, according to Huyssen, in the Progressive Era, “The ‘public interest’ became synonymous with the maintenance of efficient economic production, law and order, and growth at nearly any cost” rather than with bridging the gap between the rich and poor.
