Over the past three decades, the study of religion and politics has largely focused on the impact religious groups have had on domestic politics. Even when scholars have examined the impact of religious groups on foreign policy, such as Matthew Redinger's study of how the Knights of Columbus tried to influence US foreign policy toward the Mexican Revolution (American Catholics and the Mexican Revolution, 1924–1936 [University of Notre Dame Press, 2005]), their focus has been on domestic religious groups. Timothy Byrnes, a well-published scholar of the intersection of US Catholic culture with politics, in this case examines the impact of transnational religious communities on US foreign policy toward Latin America.
Drawing on Mohammed Ahari's categories of what works and what does not work in terms of “ethnic lobbying” (17) and Robert Keohane's and Joseph Nye's notion of “transnational interactions” (22) that are not performed by governments or intergovernmental organizations, Byrnes examines how the Jesuits, Maryknoll missionaries, and two Benedictine houses have drawn on their transnational character to bring into focus the atrocities linked to US foreign policy in Central America and the gross inequality between haves and have-nots reinforced by economic policies such as the North American Free Trade Agreement. Moreover, he illustrates very well how the different structures and different charisms of each transnational religious community lead to very different political engagements of US foreign policy.
The Jesuit case study illustrates how the US Jesuit education network confronted both the government of the United States and that of El Salvador in the wake of the assassination of six Jesuit leaders at the Universidad Centroamericana José Simeón Cañas (UCA) by the El Salvadoran military in 1989. Byrnes points out how the militaristic structure of the Jesuit community, its capacity for mobility, and the solidarity fostered by its spiritual exercises led to a comprehensive response to the atrocities. US Jesuits were among those who took the place of the slain Salvadoran scholars. Jesuit mobilization brought about a loan from Washington that enabled the UCA to remain open. In turn, Jesuits pressured the Salvadoran government to investigate those responsible for the atrocity. Most importantly, Byrnes emphasizes, pressure by the Jesuits on US foreign policymakers led to a negotiated peace agreement between the contesting factions in the Salvadoran civil war.
Whereas the Jesuit mobilization is an elite institutional approach, the case study of the Maryknoll sisters in Nicaragua illustrates how their mission of accompanying “the poor, the oppressed, and the alienated” (73) in their concrete lives ultimately led them to be the “voice of the voiceless” (96). In such ministry, consonant with liberation theology, the sisters observed firsthand the deleterious impact that the Contra forces, funded by the US government, were having on the human rights and well-being of Nicaraguans. These sisters felt called to return to the United States and evangelize other Americans regarding the actual situation in Nicaragua—hence Byrnes's term, “reverse mission.” Among the testimonies and actions by specific sisters Byrnes reviews, the most effective instance proves to be Peggy Healey, who through a family connection gained the ear of Speaker of the US House Tip O'Neill on the Contra situation.
Finally, the Benedictine case study describes how an alliance between the Weston Priory, a Vermont monastery, and a house of Benedictine sisters devoted to the poor in Cuernavaca, Mexico, manifests the ways in which the ancient Benedictine practice of prayer and hospitality can be put into political and social outreach. Whereas in the other two case studies the Jesuits and Maryknoll sisters engaged in specific political advocacy, these Benedictans, in a manner consonant with both the contemplative and the concrete character of Benedictine spirituality, simply seek to effect through hospitality a “change of heart” (147) that will move people to seek structural reform regarding the systemic poverty in Mexico. Still, Byrnes notes that the Weston Priory has been able to bring pressure on the Mexican government through the ties they have cultivated with US Senators Pat Leahy (VT) and Bernie Sanders (VT).
Overall, Byrnes effectively shows how the differences between the orders both in terms of structure and ministerial charism lead to different mobilizations vis-à-vis US foreign policy. The highly structured, institutional character of the Jesuit order enables it to have an extensive impact both on institutions in El Salvador and on policy debates in Washington. In contrast to this elite approach pursued by an all-male order, the accompaniment of the poor by nonordained Maryknoll sisters has led them to raise political awareness not just in the halls of Congress but in US parish pews. Finally, the respective Benedictine houses in Weston (male) and Cuernavaca (female) through egalitarian exchanges have come to realize how pursuing justice through hospitality in concrete locales can have transnational repercussions.
Byrnes's narrative contains ironical yet valuable subtexts. Although the Jesuits over the past half century have been pursuing social justice in a way that moves beyond their traditional socialization of elites, the Jesuit response to the atrocities at UCA is very elite in format, if not in intent. In the Maryknoll case, Byrnes skillfully discloses how this US-based order has shifted from its original pro-American, anticommunist outlook to casting a rather critical eye on US foreign policy. Finally, a group of Benedictine monks who spoke little Spanish and were primarily known for their meditative music and a group of Benedictine sisters who spoke little English have been able to build a bridge that has led to participation in activist initiatives such as the 1980s sanctuary movement.
Scholars interested in US Catholic culture will find Byrnes's discussion of the differences of the orders vis-à-vis political action rich. His injection of religious institutions into the discussion of the impact of transnational institutions on the policies of nation-states is a valuable contribution that tempers the social science bias against studying the impact of religion on politics.
On the other hand, political scientists will legitimately be skeptical of the degree to which Byrnes advances our understanding of the impact transnational religious institutions have on changing a government's internal or external conduct. Byrnes frankly admits that the Benedictine houses do not seek to engage in direct political action. Without denigrating the importance of Maryknoll sister Peggy Healy's personal connection to Tip O'Neill and the Weston Priory's regional connection to Senators Leahy and Sanders, more analysis needs to be done to determine whether these connections are just isolated examples rather than continual connections with these political institutions. In turn, some estimate of the outcome of these connections regarding public policy needs to be provided. Only in the Jesuit case does Byrnes show that the order's political mobilization changed US foreign policy and the conduct of the Salvadoran government.
All in all, this very readable text is stronger at illustrating the connection between a religious order's charism and its transnational engagement of politics than it is at providing a template à la Ahari regarding the impact of transnational religious organizations on national and transnational politics. Further research in this field also needs to examine how transnational religious institutions are contributing to transnational civil societies that might ultimately sustain political institutions beyond the nation-state. Byrnes, to his credit, has cleared the ground for more probing analysis of this vital religious dimension of the growing border crossings of twenty-first-century politics.
