Beginning with an overview of the Chinese legal framework and arbitration system, Professor Fan starts her investigations by examining the conclusion of arbitration agreements, the functioning of arbitral tribunals, and the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards. After demonstrating the Chinese characteristics in arbitration and possible cultural influences, Fan also proposes the possibility of modernizing arbitration practice.
Being a contracting party to the New York Convention and ICSID Convention, and as parties to several BITs, China has successfully attracted abundant foreign investment. For resolving possible commercial and investment disputes, arbitration has gradually become a popular alternative dispute resolution because of its convenience and also because of some conventional distrust towards the Chinese judicial system. The Chinese Arbitration Law was adopted in 1995, following the principles of party autonomy, setting an exclusive arbitration jurisdiction, assuring independence of arbitration, and guaranteeing that the arbitral awards are final. However, the competence-competence issue, qualification of arbitrators, and standards of review in recognition of foreign arbitral awards still generate some uncertainties. In actual practices, mediation also plays a weighty role, and the line between mediation and arbitration is sometimes blurred in China. Last but not least, the cultural analysis appears to be crucial, because the choice of ways for dispute resolution and respective legal mechanisms reflect the reality of legal perception among people in China.
The reviewer here would like to highlight that even traditional Chinese society was based on the Confucian thought of “Li” (rites; rituals), and Chinese people in the traditional era tended to avoid official and legal ways of resolving disputes. The modernization of China’s legal system since the beginning of the last century changed the nexus for dispute resolution. However, the mentality of harmony still remains, and a flexible legal reasoning is preferred. Consequently, the adoption of an arbitration regime in China encountered few obstacles for disputes to be resolved “in a fair and reasonable manner”. Even so, some further reforms in liberal economy, open market and finance, and a further redesign of arbitral institutions will be needed for co-ordinating the Chinese arbitration regime with transnational standards. Besides, we should not overlook that, even in arbitration, the custom of “guanxi” (personal relationship) is still deep-rooted in Chinese society and could potentially affect the impartiality of arbitrators. That is why in 2006 a new title of crime was added to the Code of Penal Law. An arbitrator who seriously acts in distorting facts or in violation of laws will be sentenced to up to three years in prison; for extreme violation, the offender will be sentenced to at least three years and up to seven years. This incrimination invoked several critiques from Chinese scholars for its ambiguities in legal terms, and worries emerged about possible abuses of this penalty from extra-arbitral regimes. The de-incrimination of arbitrators’ penal liability would be needed in the future.
